A5 PDF.pwd

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "A5 PDF.pwd"

よいかずおえづか
7 years ago
Views:

1 Kwansei Gakuin University Rep Title Author(s) スポーツにおけるルール社会的効用と不法行為責任 : 最近のイングランド法の分析を中心に Onishi, Kunihiro, 大西, 邦弘 Citation 法と政治, 67(1): Issue Date URL Right

邦弘 Citation 法と政治, 67(1): 201-231 Issue Date 2016-05-30 URL

4 and

8 LEX / DB LEX / DB

9 LEX / DB

14 Sports Medicine 2011 web

15 Kiley v. Patterson, 760 A.2d Rhode Island, 2000 The Common Law Library, Clerk and Lindsell on Torts, 21 st ed., 2014; Deakin, S., Johonston, A., and Markesinis, B., Markesinis and Deakin s Tort Law, 2013; Witting, C., Street on Torts, 14 th ed., 2015; The Common Law Library, Charlesworth and Percy on Negligence, 13 th ed., 2014 Clerk and Lindsell 2014; Markesinis 2013; Street on Torts 2015; Percy 2014 Occupiers liability

, Johonston, A., and Markesinis, B., Markesinis and Deakin s Tort Law, 2013; Witting, C.

16 Denning Volenti non fit injuria Volenti non fit injuria battery Wooldridge v Sumner and another Diplock

17 battery Smoldon v Whitworth

18 Murray v Harringay arena ltd King v Redlich

19 emergency Wilks v Cheltenham Cycle Club Caldwell v Maguire and Fitzgerald Condon v Basi

20 Harrison v Vincent Wooldrige

21 Phee v Gordon Craven v Riches Smoldon v Whitworth and Nolan social utility

22 Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd 2010 EWHC 46 QB Health and Fun Day BBC It s a Knock-out Field

23 Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd and another Smith Field Field trial judge Foskett Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd and another Blair-Ford v CRS Adventures Ltd

24 see, Markesinis 2013, at 259; Street on Torts 2015, at 212. Percy 2014, at Lane v. Holloway QB 379, at See, Percy 2014, at Percy 2014, at see, Street on Torts 2015, at 196. Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at QB 43, All ER 978. Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at PIQR P 133 at 147. Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at Wooldridge v Sumner and another 2 QB 43, All ER 978. Diplock Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at KB 529, All ER

25 WWR 567. see, Percy 2014, at Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at see, Street on Torts 2015, at All ER, WLR 668. see, Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at EWCA Civ Caldwell v Maguire and Fitzgerald 2001 EWCA Civ Tuckey 2001 EWCA Civ. 1054, at 39 Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at All ER 453, WLR 866. Percy 2014, at Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at Harrison v Vincent 1982 RTR RTR 8, CA. see, Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at 558; Percy 2014, at CSIH 18; 2013 SC 379; 2013 SLT 439. see, Clerk and Lindsell 2014, 8152 at n Percy 2014, at EWCA Civ 375. see, Percy 2014, at PIQR. P 133. Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd 2010 EWHC 46 QB Field see, Street on Torts 2015, at 119. cross appeal

26 2011 EWCA Civ. 66. Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd and another 2011 EWCA Civ Smith See, Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at EWHC 353 QB EWHC 353 QB, at See, Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at 8153, at 708. Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at EWHC 2360 QB. See, Clerk and Lindsell 2014, at 8153, n Youtube

27 social utility

28 Murray v Harringay arena ltd. LEX / DB LEX / DB

29 Uren v Corporate Leisure UK Ltd

30 KB 529, All ER

31 2010 EWHC 46 QB

32 Tort Liability in Sporting Events Kunihiro ONISHI When a significant accident occurs during sporting event, should tort liability be imposed? In Japanese tort law, it is uncertain 1 whether the victim s consent to participate in the sporting activity exempts other parties from tort liability; 2 how the rules of sports might affect the application of tort liability; 3 what elements of tort liability could apply in deciding whether negligence liability should be imposed. Discourse on English tort law has discussed these issues for some time. These long standing discussions on the applicability of tort in regards to sports participants are referenced in this paper for an extremely stimulating rethinking of the application of Japanese tort law in such instances. In this article, it is argued that 1 a claimant s consent does not always exempt a defendant from tort liability, although it may provide some immunity from say slight bodily touches in a game; 2 the rules of a sport do not always affect tort liability; and 3 social utility is a very important factor in deciding whether there negligence has occurred based on the level of the duty of care for sporting event organizers, which has a significant bearing on determining whether there is a case for tort liability

A5 PDF.pwd

A5 PDF.pwd Kwansei Gakuin University Rep Title Author(s) 家族にとっての労働法制のあり方 : 子どもにとっての親の非正規労働を中心に Hasegawa, Junko, 長谷川, 淳子 Citation 法と政治, 65(3): 193(825)-236(868) Issue Date 2014-11-30 URL