1304ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｺｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ09ｨｨｨｬｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06

Transcription

1 , ｨｰｨｪｨｨｨｺ ｨｨ0102ｨｪｨｰｨ ｨｨｨｨ, , 01ｨｨ0802ｨｺｨｰ ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮｨｰｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ ﾁ ｰ0006ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｬ0600ｨｮｨｰ ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｮ06ｨｴ02ｨｦ 0708ｨｨｨｰ ﾂｨｨ ｨｨ 0904 ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨｨｰ ｨｨ 0906ｨ 09ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｪｨｹ00ｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0902ｨ 07, 09ｨ ｨｹｨｬｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨｮ02ｨｰ, 09ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ02ｨｰ0907, ｨｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｪｨｨ 08ｨ ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｨ 0904 ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨｨｰ ｨｨ 0906ｨ 09ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｪｨｹ00ｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0108ｨｮ ﾂ ｨｺｨ, 09ｨ ｨｪ 02ｨｬｨｮ ｨｹｨｬｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨｮ02ｨｰ, 09ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ02ｨｰ0907, 0601ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06 09ｨ 09 ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｹ0302 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨｮ02ｨｰ ｨｰ06, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｪｨｨ 08ｨ ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｨ 0904 ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨｨｰ02 ﾂｨｮ03ｨｨ ｨｪｨｹ00ｨｨ ｨｪｨ 09ｨ ｨｬ ｨ 07, 09ｨ 09 ｨｪ ｨｨ03ｨｺ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨｮ02ｨｰ ｨｰ06, 09ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ02ｨｰ0907, ｨｪ ｨｹｨｬｨ 06ｨ ｨｺ0602ｨｪ04 ｨｰ02ｨｬ, ｨｺ ｨ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｪｨｨ 08ｨ ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ 0904 ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨｨｰ02 ﾂｨｮ03ｨｨ ｨｪｨｹ 00ｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0108ｨｮ ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｨ03ｨｺ06ｨｬ 06ｨ ｨｺ0602ｨｪ04 ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ, 09ｨｺ 0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ02ｨｰ0907, ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｪｨｨ 08ｨ ｨｮ06ｨｰ0907 ｱ ｨｨ01ｨｬ02ｨｪ ｨｰｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｺｨ ｨ ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 09 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ 05ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨ ｨｰｨｮ ｨ 04 ﾂｨｪ ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ04: ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ07ｨｰ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ 0902ｨｺｨｰ ｨ ｨｴ02ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｪ07ｨｰ0401; ｨｮ ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ090609, ｨｪｨ ｨｴｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 0906ｨ 09ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰ ｨｨ, ｨｪｨ 02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0401 ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨ 01; ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮｨｺ02ｨｨｨｨ, ｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ07ｨｰｨｨ0701, ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ06ｨｬ 06ｨ ｨｲ02ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｰ09ｨ ; ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ0401 ｨｨｨｪ090209ｨｰｨｨ02ｨｨｨｦ 09 ｨｪｨ 02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0401 ｨｨｨｪ090209ｨｰｨｨ02ｨｨ0701; ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨ ｨｬ 09ｨｪｨｮ ｨｰ0802ｨｪｨｪ02ｨｬ ｨｮｨｺｨｰ ｨ ｨｰ0208ｨｬｨｨｨｪ ｰ08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｱ 0708ｨｨｨｬ 02ｨｪ0702ｨｰ ｨｰｨｪ060302ｨｪｨｨ06 ｨｺ ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｬ ｨC ｨｺ ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ03ｨ ｨｴｨｨ01 ( ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ0302ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ05), ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｬｨｮ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨｮ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ0401 ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ090609, ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｪｨ 07 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｴ02ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｮ ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨ07 06ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹ ｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨ ｨｬ ｨｺｨ 01 06ｨ 09ｨｮ0301ｨ 02ｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｰ02ｨｬ04 ｨｬ0603ｨｪ ｨｬｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｪ0209ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｮｨｴ0209ｨｰ09ｨｮ02ｨｰ 05ｨｨ ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ09ｨ ｨｹ ｨｬ020301ｨｮ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ07ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ? ｨｰ ｨｨ 05ｨｰｨ ｨｹ 05ｨｨｨｪ02ｨｦｨｪ06ｨｦ? ｨｨ 01ｨ, ｨｰ06 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ? ｨｨ ｨｪ02ｨｰ, ｨｰ06 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ0609ｨ ｨｬｨ 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｨ? 08ｨ ｨｺ ｨ 02ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 09 08ｨ 0405ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ0401 ｨｮ ｨｨ0701? 05ｨｮｨｴ0209ｨｰ09ｨｮ02ｨｰ 05ｨｨ 0607ｨｰｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹ ｨｪ04ｨｦ 09

2 1304ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｺｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ09ｨｨｨｬｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ 08 ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ? ｨｨ 01ｨ, ｨｰ06 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ0609ｨ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪｨ? 08ｨ ｨｺｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｬ02ｨｪ 01ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 0905ｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 02ｨｬ 0401 (0607ｨｰｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0401) 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｬ0603ｨｪ ｨｬｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ? 08ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｮ 06ｨｰ08ｨｨ02ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｬ020301ｨｮ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09 ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｬ ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｴ02ｨｪｨ 06ｨ 03ｨｨ08ｨｪｨ 07 05ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨ ｨｰｨｮ08ｨ ｨｪｨｹ ｨｰ0600ｨｨ : 0708ｨｨｨｬｨｨ0802ｨｪｨｨ02, 09ｨｰｨ ｨ ｨｨ05ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ. 00 ｨｺｨｪ.: 03ｨｮｨｰｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｮｨｪｨ ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｰ. 00.: ｨｦ 05ｨｺ , 2001; ｨｪｨ 0102ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ 09 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨ 01 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 00 ｨｺｨｪ.: 03ｨｮｨｰｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｮｨｪｨ ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｰ; ｨｰｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｪ0206ｨ ｨｨｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ09ｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹ ｨｪ0401 ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 00 ｨｺｨｪ.: 03ｨｮｨｰｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｮｨｪｨ ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｰ; 05ｨｰ0806ｨｮ07 04., 0109ｨ 08ｨｰｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｮｨｺｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ. 00.: 06ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮｨｰ ｨｪｨ 02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｬ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1996; Alesina A. The Political Economy of High and Low Growth. Paper prepared for the Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics, Washington, DC, 1997; Barro R., Lee J.-W. Losers and Winners in Economic Growth. ｨC NBER Working Paper, April 1993, No 4341; Beach W. Why Taxes Affect Economic Growth. ｨC Heritage Lectures, 1998, September 10, No 624; Begg D., Wyplosz Ch. How Big a Government? Paper presented at the 5 th Dubrovnik Conference on Transition Economies, September 1999; Chu K., Schwartz G. Output Decline and Government Expenditures in European Transition Economies. ｨC IMF Working Paper, June 1994, No 68; Commander S., Hamid D., Lee U.J. The Causes and Consequences of Government for Growth and Well-being. ｨC The World Bank background paper for the World Development Report, 1997, April 3; Engen E.M., Skinner J. Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth. ｨC NBER Working Paper, December 1992, No 4223; Freedom, Democracy and Economic Welfare. Ed. by M. Walker. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, 1988; Grier K.B., Tullock G. An Empirical Analysis of Cross-National Economic Growth, 1951ｨC80. ｨC Journal of Monetary Economics, 1989, v.24; Grossman Ph.J.Government and Economic Growth: A Non-Linear Relationship. Public Choice, 1988, v. 56; Gwartney J.D., Lawson R., Block W. Economic Freedom of the World. 1975ｨC1995. The Fraser Institute, 1996; Gwartney J.D., Lawson R. Economic Freedom of the World. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, 1997; Gwartney J.D., Lawson R. Economic Freedom of the World. 1998/1999 Interim Report. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, 1998; Gwartney J.D., Lawson R., Samida D. Economic Freedom of the World Annual Report. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, 2000; Gwartney J.D., Lawson R., Edwards C., Park W., de Rugy V., Wagh S. Economic Freedom of the World Annual Report. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, 2002; Gwartney J.D., Stroup R.L. What Everyone Should Know about Economics and Prosperity. The Fraser Institute, 1993; Gwartney J., Holcombe R., Lawson R. The Scope of Government and the Wealth of Nations. ｨC The Cato Journal, Fall 1998, v. 18, No 2; Higgs R. Eighteen Problematic Propositions in the Analysis of the Growth of Government. ｨC The Review of Austrian Economics, 1991, v. 5, No 1; Index of Economic Freedom. Washington, The Heritage Foundation, Annual Reports, 1995ｨC2002; Kosterna U. A Comparative Analysis of Fiscal Policy in Selected Central European Countries. In: Fiscal Policy in Transition. CEPR, London, 1997; Landau D. Government Expenditure and Economic Growth. A Cross-Country Study. ｨC Southern Economic Journal, 1983, v. 49, No 3, January; Landau D. Government and Economic Growth in the Less Developed Countries. An Empirical Study for 1960ｨC1980. ｨC Economic Development and Cultural Change, 1986, v. 35, No 1, October; Marsden K. Links between Taxes and Economic Growth. Some Empirical Evidence. ｨC World Bank Staff Working Papers, 1983, No 605; Masson P., Michael M. Long-Term Tendencies in Budget Deficits and Debt. ｨC IMF Working Paper, 1995, No 128, December; Peden Ed., Bradley M. Government Size, Productivity and Economic Growth: The Post-War Experience. ｨC Public Choice, 1989, v. 61; Rothbard M. Power and Market. Government and the Economy, Institute for Human Studies. Mission, Kansas, 1970; Tanzi V. Fiscal Policy and the Economic Restructuring of Economies in Transition. ｨC IMF Working Paper, 1993, No 22, March; Tanzi V., Schuknecht L. Reforming Government in Industrial Countries. ｨC Finance and Development, 1996, September; Tanzi V., Tsibouris G. Fiscal Reform over Ten Years of Transition. ｨC Paper presented at the 5 th Dubrovnik Conference on Transition Economies, 1999, June 23ｨC25; Tanzi V., Schuknecht L. Public Spending in the 20 th Century. A Global Perspective. 2* 19

3 ｨ 08ｨｨ06ｨｪ0609, ｨｨ090609ｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨ 0405ｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨｺｨｨ 0607ｨｰｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01 ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｴ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｨ01 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｹ 06ｨｰ08ｨｨ02ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｬ020301ｨｮ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ07ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ 09 ﾂｨｨｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ06ｨｦ 3. 02ｨｰ08ｨｨ02ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 01ｨ 08ｨ ｨｺｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｮ080609ｨｪ07 08 ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ 09 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪ020601ｨｪ06ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06 06ｨｰｨｬ02 ﾂｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ 0608ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 01ｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹｨｨ ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺ06ｨｦ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ 01ｨｨ09ｨｺｨｮ0909ｨｨｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ- Cambridge University Press, 2000; Unproductive Public Expenditures. A Pragmatic Approach to Policy Analysis. IMF, Washington, 1995; Vedder R. Economic Impact of Government Spending: A 50-State Analysis. ｨC NCPA Policy Report, April 1993, No 178, Dallas, Texas; Wildavsky A. How to Limit Government Spending. University of California Press, 1980; Wolf Ch. Markets or Governments. Choosing between Imperfect Alternatives. Cambridge, Mass, The MIT Press, ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ. 08ｨ ｨｺ ｨｪ? ｨｮ0909ｨｺ ｨ 07 00ｨ 0402ｨｰｨ, 1998, 17 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; The Budget, Taxation and Economic Growth. ｨC US Congress, Growth and Prosperity Series, 1999, v. 2, October; Chao J.C.P., Grubel H. Optimal Levels of Spending and Taxation in Canada. In: How to Use the Fiscal Surplus. What Is the Optimal Size of Government? Ed. by H. Grubel. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, 1998; Economic Growth and the Future Prospects of the US Economy. ｨC US Congress, Growth and Prosperity Series, 1999, v. 1, October; Gupta S., Leruth L, de Mello L., Chakravarti Sh. Transition Economies: How Appropriate Is the Size and Scope of Government? ｨC IMF Working Paper, 2001, No 55, May; Mitchell D. Reducing the Size and Scope of Government. In: The Supply-Side Revolution: 20 Years Later. US Congress, March 2000; Scully G.W. What Is the Optimal Size of Government in the United States? ｨC NCPA Policy Report 1994, No 188, November; Scully G.W. Measuring the Burden of High Taxes. ｨC NCPA Policy Report 1998, No 215, July; Scully G.W. Economic Freedom, Government Policy and the Trade- Off between Equity and Economic Growth. Manuscript,1999; Smith D.B.Public Rags or Private Riches? High Public Spending Makes Us Poor. London, Politeia, 2001; Tanzi V., Schuknecht L. Can Small Governments Secure Economic and Social Well-Being? In: How to Use the Fiscal Surplus. What is the Optimal Size of Government? Ed. by H. Grubel. Vancouver, The Fraser Institute, Gerson Ph. The Impact of Fiscal Policy Variables on Output Growth. ｨC IMF Working Paper, 1998, No 1, January; Fisher S., Sahay R., Vegh C.A. From Transition to Market. Evidence and Growth Prospects. ｨC IMF Working Paper, 1998, No 52, April; Roll R., Talbott J. Why Many Developing Countries Just Aren ｯt; Sala-I-Martin X. 15 Years of New Growth Economics: What Have We Learnt? Columbia University, Discussion Paper, 2002, No 0102ｨC47, April ｨ 08ｨｨ06ｨｪ ｨｹｨｺ ｨ 07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨ 06ｨ ﾂｨｨｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｰ06ｨｦｨｪｨｮ06 03ｨｨ04ｨｪｨｹ. ｨC 08ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ07, 1995, 16 ｨｪ0607ｨ 0807; ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 04 09ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ｨｨ ｨｨ07. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1996, 01 7; ｨｬ0208ｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ 05 06ｨｺｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｰ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ. ｨC 08ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ07, 1996, 22 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1996, 01 9; 04ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨ 06 05ｨｹ0302, ﾂ02ｨｬ ｨｬ060302ｨｰ 0904ｨｪ0209ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰ02 ﾂ0209ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪｨ 07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨ. ｨC ｨｰｨｨ07, 1996, 15 ｨｪ0607ｨ 0807; ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨC ｨ 01. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1 998, 01 2; 0502ｨｺ0802ｨｰ ｨｺｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｦ09ｨｺ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｰ ﾂｨｮ01ｨ ｱ. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06 ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1998, 01 4; 00ｨｨ0004 ｨｨ ｨｮ0806ｨｺｨｨ ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰ060909ｨｺ ｨｺ08ｨｨ04ｨｨ09ｨ. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1999, 01 9ｨC10; 08ｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｰ ｨ ｨｰ060502ｨｰｨｨ02. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2000, 01 1; 08ｨ ｨｺ 04ｨ 08ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨｹ 100 ｨｰ08ｨｨ0505ｨｨ06ｨｪ ｨ ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2000, 01 8, ｨ 0507; 06ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨ ｨ 0601ｨ ｨｨ ｨ 05ｨ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｪｨ ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2000, 01 4; 03ｨｨ090609ｨ ｨ ｨｹ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 09 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ080605ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｬ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｨ. 00.: 0107ｨC000106, 1996; ｨｰ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 0502ｨｬｨ ｨｬ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ: ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ, 1996, ｨｪｨｰ07ｨ 0807; ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｦ ｨｰ, 1996, 14 ｨｪ0607ｨ 0807; 08ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬｨｮ ｨ ｨｰｨｮ? 1997, 6 06ｨｺｨｰ07ｨ 0807; 08 ｨ ｨｺ 06ｨ ﾂｨｨｨｰｨｹ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ? 1998, ｨ 0507; 06ｨ ｨｦｨｪｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｦ09ｨｺ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ 0209ｨｺ ﾂｨｮ01ｨ, 1998, 25 ｨｬｨ 08ｨｰｨ ; 0808ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨｨｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ 2, 1998, 22 ｨｨ 29 ｨｬｨ 07; 06ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨ ｨ 0601ｨ 09 ｨｬｨｨ ｨｦ 0106ｨｺ05ｨ 01 ｨC 2000, 2000, 11 07ｨｪ09ｨ

4 1304ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ 02ｨｨ ｨｪ0201ｨ 09ｨｪ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｹ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ06 ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ, 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｰ020507ｨｬｨｨ, 06ｨｰｨｪ060907ｨｴｨｨｨｬｨｨ0907 ｨｺ 08ｨ 04ｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ﾂ 0209ｨｺｨｨｨｬ ｨｰ02 ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｬ 03ｨｺ0605ｨ ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｬ ｨｨ05ｨｨ09ｨｹ 08ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ04, ｨ 09ｨｰ ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｺｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｹ04ｨｮ 0706 ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｦｨｪ02ｨｦ ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 01ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ02ｨｦ ｨｮ090205ｨｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｪ04ｨｪ0203ｨｪｨｨ01 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ 0008ｨｮ04ｨｺｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨ ｨ 05ｨｺｨｨｨｪ ｨｨｨｺｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 00.: 06ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮｨｰ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｺｨｨ , 2002; ｨｹ ﾂｨｮｨｺ 08., 0808ｨｨ01ｨｬｨ ｨｪ ｨｨｨ 0208ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 00ｨｮｨｪ01ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｰｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｬ. ｨC ｨ 09ｨｨ 09ｨｨｨｬｨ 07 00ｨ 0402ｨｰｨ, 2000, 13 ｨｬｨ 07; 00ｨ 0502ｨｪｨｰｨｨｨｪ ｨ ｨ 05ｨｨ ｨｬ02 ﾂｨｰｨｮ. ｨC ｨｰ09ｨｺｨ ｨｨ07, 2001, ｨｺｨ ｨ 0807; 01ｨ 0908ｨｨ0502ｨｪｨｺ ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺｨ 07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨ : ｨｺｨｰｨｨ0904 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ080605ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2000, 01 4; 01ｨ 0908ｨｨ0502ｨｪｨｺ ｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ0906 ｨｨ ｨｺ0605ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2002, 01 21, 3 ｨｨ06ｨｪ07; 01ｨ ｨｦ01ｨ ｨｨｨ 0208ｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨ07 ｨｨ 09ｨｰｨ ｨ ｨｨ05ｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨ07 ｨC 0707ｨｰｨｹ 0502 ｨｰ 0907ｨｮ09ｨｰ07. ｨC 01ｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ0402 ｨｰ08ｨｮ , 1997, , 09. 8ｨC11; 0105ｨ 04ｨｹ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨ ｨｬ ｨ ｨｬ. ｨC 0608ｨｨｨ ｨｮｨｪｨ, 2000, 7 ｨｨ06ｨｪ07; 0105ｨ 04ｨｹ ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ ｨｮｨｰ 0902ｨ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｺ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｬ0601ｨｪｨｨ0202, 0006ｨｰ060906ｨｦ 08ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨ. ｨC OPEC.RU, 2001, 25 ｨｨ060507; ｨｰｨｪｨ 07 09ｨｨ09ｨｰ02ｨｬｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ 0706ｨｰ02ｨｪ 02ｨｨｨ 05 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2002, 01 4; 0108ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｰｨｹ 0502ｨｰ 09ｨｨ09ｨｰ02ｨｬｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ. ｨC ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬｨ 07 00ｨ 0402ｨｰｨ, 1999, ｨｺｨ ｨ 0807; 0108ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨ 00ｨｬｨ ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨｰ06ｨｺｨ. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2000, 01 6, ｨ 0507; 0108ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｰｨｹ 0502ｨｰ 09ｨｨ09ｨｰ02ｨｬｨｪ ｨｪ06 ﾂｨｪ ｨ 08ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ 09 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｰ08ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ: ｨｨｨｰ0600ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ0806ｨｺｨｨ. 00 ｨｺｨｪ.: ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺｨ 07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨ : ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｺ ｨｰｨｨ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ , 2000; 01ｨｮ0809ｨｨ ﾂ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ 09ｨｰｨｨｨｬｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 05 ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 00 ｨｺｨｪ.: 06ｨｪ09ｨｰ08ｨｮｨｬ02ｨｪｨｰ04 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ080605ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ. 00.: , 2001; 0202ｨｦｨｺｨｨｨｪ ｨｰ06ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｰ09ｨ. ｨC ｨｬ , 2001, 14 ｨｪ0607ｨ 0807; 02ｨｮｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｨｨｬｨｨ 08ｨｮｨｺｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨ 02ｨｬ ｨｨ04 08ｨｮｨ 0502ｨｦ 00ｨ ｨｪｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｭ ｨC ｨｬ07, 2002, 01 32, 11 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; ｨｰ ｨｰｨｨ07ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺ02. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2001, 01 12; 0609ｨ ｨｪｨｰ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ 0200ｨ 02ｨｰ. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2001, 01 13, 2 ｨ ; ｨ ﾂ 08., 05ｨｬｨｨ08ｨｪ , 03ｨｮ , 06ｨ 08ｨ 00ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｨｨｨ: ｨ ｨｬｨ ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨ 0802ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ0904. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2002, 01 8; ｨ 05ｨｨ03ｨｨｨｪ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰｨ. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2002, 01 30, 19 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; 00ｨ ｨｮ ｨｨｨ 0208ｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｬ ｨｹ0204 ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2000, 01 11, 20 ｨｬｨ 08ｨｰｨ ; ｨｹ07ｨｪ , 0808ｨｨ01ｨｬｨ ｨｪ ｨｺ ｨｺｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｬ020301ｨｮｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ. ｨC ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬｨ 07 00ｨ 0402ｨｰｨ, 1997, 10 ｨｪ0607ｨ 0807; 0102ｨｺｨｨ ｨ ｨｬｨ ｨｪ ﾂｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ02. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 1999, 01 30, 16 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; 0002ｨｪｨｹ03ｨｨｨｺ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｬ04 ｨｨ ｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ02 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1997, 01 6; 03ｨ 08ｨ 05ｨｨ ﾂ ｨｨ. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2002, 01 30, 19 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｬ 06ｨ 0609ｨｪ0609 ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ 05ｨｨｨ 0208ｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ. ｨC ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1999, 01 12; ｰ ｨ 07 ｱ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ ｨC ｨｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪｨ 01 08ｨ 0405ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｦ ｨｮｨ ｨｨｨｪ02 ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬｨ 02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 01ｨ. 00 ｨｺｨｪ.: 08ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ090609ｨ 07 ｨｪ02ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ｨｪ06 ﾂｨｪ ｨ 08ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨｨｨ. 00., 1999; ｨｺ06ｨｰ0208ｨ 07ｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ ｨ 01ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｬｨ : ｨｰｨｹ 0502ｨｰ 0907ｨｮ09ｨｰ07. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2000, 01 31, 28 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0906 ｨｨ 0804ｨｪ06ｨｺ 0706-ｨ ｨｬ0208 ｨｨｨｺｨ ｨｪ09ｨｺｨｨ. ｨC ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬｨ 07 00ｨ 0402ｨｰｨ, 2000, ｨ 0507; ｨｺｨ ｨｨｨ 0208ｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｬ. ｨC 02ｨｰｨｺ0804ｨｰｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ, 1999, 01 7ｨC8; ｨｺｨ ｨｮ 06 ｨｬ06ｨｪｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｮ ｨ 0601ｨｮ. ｨC 06ｨｺ ｨｰ, 2000, 01 15, 17 ｨ ; 0808ｨｨ01ｨｬｨ ｨｪ 09., 00ｨｨ , ｨｹ07ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ. ｨC 00 ｨｨ080609ｨ 07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨ ｨｨ ｨｬ020301ｨｮｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｰｨｪ060302ｨｪｨｨ07, 1999, ｨｨ 11; 09ｨ ｨｪ0108ｨｮ ｨｰｨ ｨｬ ｨｪ02 ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ. ｨC ｨｰ04, 2001, 16 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; ﾁ0208ｨｺ ｨｨ0008ｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｹ. ｨC ｨｰ09ｨｺｨ ｨｨ07, 1998, ｨｪｨｰ07ｨ 0807; 08ｨｺ06ｨ 0906ｨｪ ｨｦ09ｨ ｨｪｨ 07ｨｮｨｰｨｨ ｨｺ ｨｰｨｮ00ｨ 05ｨｨｨｨ. ｨC 08ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ07, 2002, 2 ｨｨ ｨ 0908ｨｨ0502ｨｪｨｺ ｨ 09ｨｪｨ 07 ｨｮ ｨ ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺ06ｨｦ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺ02 ｨC ｨｬ ｨｪｨｪ0402 ｨｨ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨｬ04. ｨC ｨｰｨｨ07, 2002, 1 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ; 01ｨ ｨｦ01ｨ ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ 0008ｨｮ04ｨｺｨｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｮ. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1998, 01 4; 00ｨ ｨｮ ｨｰｨｺ06ｨｬｨｬｨｮｨｪｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨ ｨｨ ｨｰｨｨｨｪ01ｨｮ09ｨｰ08ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｬｨｨ0802: ｨ 0502ｨｬ ｨｪ0706ｨｴ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 2002, 01 7; 0709ｨｰｨｨｨｪ ｨｨ 07ｨｪｨｨ02 09ｨｰ08ｨｮｨｺｨｰｨｮ08ｨｪ ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ ﾂ ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ｨｺｨｪ.: 06ｨｪ09ｨｰ08ｨｮｨｬ02ｨｪｨｰ04 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ080605ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ. 00.: , 2001; 01ｨ 08ｨｨ070609ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 0106ｨｺ05ｨ ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ, 2001; 0809ｨｨｨｪ ｨｮｨｪｨｺ02ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪ06 ﾂｨｪ06ｨｦ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺ02. ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1997, 01 6; 0809ｨｨｨｪ ｨ 0302ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｨ05ｨｨ 06 ｨｰ09ｨｰｨｮ070502ｨｪｨｨ02? ( ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺｨｨ ｨｬ04 ｨｨ 00ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｦ ｨｺ08ｨｨ04ｨｨ09). ｨC ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, 1999,

5 ｨ 08ｨｨ06ｨｪ0609, ｨｨ090609ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 05ｨｬ07ｨｨ08ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ ｨｪ0206ｨ ｨｨｨｬ06 ｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨ ｨｬ 0706ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ. 0306ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｰ0802ｨ 0502ｨｪｨｨ , ﾂｨ 09ｨｰ06 ｨｨ ｨｹ04ｨｮ02ｨｬ04ｨｦ 09 05ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨ ｨｰｨｮ0802, 06ｨ 05ｨ 01ｨ 02ｨｰ ｨｪ020906ｨｬｨｪ02ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ ｨｰ06ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 09 ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｺｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬ020301ｨｮｨｪｨ ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｰｨ 09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺｨｮ 08ｨ 0909 ﾂｨｨｨｰ0409ｨ 02ｨｰ ｨ ｨｬｨｺｨ 01 09ｨｨ09ｨｰ02ｨｬ04 ｨｪｨ 02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹ ｨｪ ﾂ02ｨｰ ｨ ｨｴ ｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06 06ｨｪ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ 0906ｨ 06ｨｦ 05ｨｨ03ｨｹ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨ 0903ｨｰｨ ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｪ 06 (0106ｨｰ07 ｨｨ ｨｪ02 ｨｨ09 ﾂ ｨ 06ｨｴ02) 06ｨｰ08ｨ 03ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ02ｨｬ 00ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ ﾂ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｰ06ｨｬｨｮ 09 ｨｺｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 09 01ｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ02 ｨｨ04ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｪｨ ｨｮ080609ｨｪ02 08ｨ 0903ｨｨ0802ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 09ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹ 09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06, 06ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｨｨｰ0409ｨ 06ｨｰ 08ｨ ｨｦ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｨ09ｨｰ 02ｨｬ04 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04, 0609ｨｮｨｴ0209ｨｰ ｨｬ0402 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 0202ｨｪｨｰ08ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬ 0708ｨ 09ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹ09ｨｰ0906ｨｬ, ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｬ0209ｨｰｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ 0905ｨ 09ｨｰ07ｨｬｨｨ, ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｪ02ｨ ｨｰｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ 0006ｨｪ01ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｰ0902ｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨ02 08ｨ 09 ﾂ02ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮｨｰ02 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ 0209ｨｺ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨ 0402 ｨｬｨ ｨｰ0208ｨｨｨ , ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ0302 ｨｪｨ 02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ. 0209ｨｪ0609ｨｪｨ 07 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｹ 08ｨ 09 ﾂ02ｨｰ0609 ｨ 0405ｨ ｨｪ02ｨｪ ｨ ｨｨ 1998ｨC ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨ 07 ｨ ｨ 04ｨ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｪ ｨｪｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 09 ﾂ02ｨｰ04, ｨｮｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ02ｨｪ04 ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨｨｨｨ ｨｬｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ0707ｨｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｬｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨｺｨｨ 06ｨ ｨｪｨ 08ｨｮ03 02ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｪ ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰ02ｨｦ ｨｹ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 01ｨ ｨｨｨ ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ02 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ0208ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰ08ｨｨ 02ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 04ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｨ ｨｰｨｪ ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨ ｨｰｨｮ0802, ｨｮ ﾂ02ｨｪ04 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨｨｨｬ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ02 05ｨｰｨ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ0208ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰ 08ｨ ｨｪ ｨC (09ｨｬ. 08ｨｨ09. 1). 0602ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｺｨｰ0208ｨｨ04ｨｮ06ｨｰ0907 ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｹ03ｨｨｨｬ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ , 0708ｨｨ09ｨｮｨｴｨｨ, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 0708ｨ 09ｨｨ0506, ｨ ｨｺｨｨ02 ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 06, ｨｪｨ 06ｨ ｨｰ, ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 09 ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬｨｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809 ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｬ., ｨｪｨ 0708ｨｨｨｬ0208: Barro R. Economic Growth in a Cross-Section of Countries. ｨC Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1991, vol. 106, No 2; Barro R. Determinants of Economic Growth. MIT Press, 1997; Barro R., Sala-I-Martin X. Economic Growth. McGraw Hill, IMF International Financial Statistics, various issues; IMF Government Finance Statistics, various issues; IMF World Economic Outlook, various issues; IMF WEO Statistical Database. 9 05ｨｬ., ｨｪｨ 0708ｨｨｨｬ0208: Gwartney J., Lawson R., Holcombe R. The Size and Functions of Government and Economic Growth. Prepared for Joint Economic Committee, US Congress. Washington, 1998, April ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ 0906ｨ 06ｨｦ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨC ｨｪｨ ﾂｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0401 ﾂ0502ｨｪ ｨｰ02 ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ0502ｨｰｨｨｨｦ: 1961ｨC , 1971ｨC , 1981ｨC , 1991ｨC ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ 06ｨ 08ｨ 0406ｨｬ, 09 06ｨ ｨｴ02ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｺｨ 0301ｨ 07 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｬ060302ｨｰ ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｰ0408ｨｹｨｬ07 ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬｨｨ. 0609ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪｨｨｨｺｨｨ 01ｨ ｨｪｨｪ0401: OECD Database; OECD Economic Outlook, various issues. 22

6 ｨｨｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨｺｨｨｨｬｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ07ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 0308ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ01 08ｨ 09ｨｪ0401 ｨｮ ｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ02 ﾂ02ｨｰ ｨｰｨｨ0502ｨｰｨｨ ｨ ｨｹ 09ｨｪｨｨ0302ｨｪｨｨ02ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｨ080609ｨｰｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06 ｨｪｨ 0,1%. 0308ｨｨ 08ｨ 0909ｨｬ06ｨｰ0802ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨ ｨｨ0806ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｰ ｨｮｨｬ02ｨｪｨｹ0302ｨｪｨｨ02 04ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｨ08ｨｮ02ｨｬ06ｨｦ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ0208ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨ ｨ 0502ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｲ0709ｨｪ0706ｨｴ02ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, 09ｨｪｨｨ0302ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｺｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ09ｨ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ01 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ ｨｮ08ｨ 09ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 05ｨｨｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｰ0802ｨｪ01ｨ, 0106ｨｰ07 ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ0506ｨｪｨ ｨｪ02ｨｦ 06 09ｨｰｨ 02ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨｨ02ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬ (09ｨｬ. 08ｨｨ09. 2). 02 ﾂ0209ｨｨ01ｨｪ06, 04ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06ｨｬ09ｨｰ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨ ｨｬ ｨｬｨｨ 0708ｨｨ ｨｪ02ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｰ020502ｨｦ ｨｺ ｨｮ 06ｨ 06ｨｰ09ｨｮｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ0906ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｬ020301ｨｮ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ07ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 01ｨ ｨｪｨ , ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨ ｨ 0405ｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ. 05ｨｪｨｨ0302ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｺｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｨ08ｨｮ02ｨｬ06ｨｦ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ0208ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨ ｨｲ0709ｨｪ0702ｨｰ0907 ｨ 0605ｨｹ0302ｨｦ ｨｪ020601ｨｪ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ06 08ｨ 0909ｨｬｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ09ｨ 02ｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨ ｨｮ02ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｺ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｮ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨC (166 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ) y = -0,058 x + 4,427 R 2 = 0,041 04ｨｨ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ ｨｪ0206ｨ ｨｨｨｬ ｨｨｨｰｨｹ 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰ060804, 0905ｨｨ0706 ｨｴｨｨ02 ｨｪｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｰ0902ｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｨ 09 05ｨｰｨｨｨｬｨｨ 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰ0608ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ 08ｨ 04ｨ ｨｨ02ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｨ08ｨｮ02ｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｮ070704, ｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ02 ｨｨ09ｨｺ06ｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｬ ｨｮ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ07ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ. 00 ｨｺｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 09 ｨｬ ｨｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 08-09ｨｰ09ｨ 08ｨ 0909ｨｬｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ09ｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｹ 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ0804 ｨ ｨｰｨ 08ｨ 0903ｨｨ0802ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 09ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｪ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｺｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ0902 ｨｪ0204ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 0909ｨｬｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ09ｨ ｨｹ ｨｰ02ｨｪ02ｨｨｨ 05 ｨｹｨｪ ｨｨｨｺｨｰ (09ｨｬ. 0308ｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ02) ｨｰ0902ｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨ02 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ02 09ｨｺｨｨ02 01ｨ ｨｪｨｪ0402 ｨ 0405ｨｨ 0906ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｬ ｨｬｨｨ08ｨ ｨｨ0601ｨ 1991ｨC ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ, 06ｨ 08ｨ ｨ 0903ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰ020808ｨｨｨｰ0608ｨｨｨｨ ｨ ｨｨ ｨ ｨ 09 ｨｨｨｨ, ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ020809ｨ ｨC ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ020507ｨｬ, ｨｨｨｬ0206ｨｴｨｨｨｬ 0709ｨｪｨｮ06 ｨ 09ｨｨｨｬｨｬ02ｨｰ08ｨｨ06, ｨ 0405ｨｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｪ0206ｨ ｨｨｨｬ ｨ 08ｨ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ07 (050600ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ02, ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ020702ｨｪｨｹ) ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04 ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬ06ｨｴｨｹ06 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ ｨｺ02ｨｰｨ SPSS ｨｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｪ04 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ ｨ 08ｨｪ ｨｨｨｪ02ｨｦｨｪ ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ0401 ｨｮ08ｨ 09ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, 01ｨ 08ｨ ｨｺｨｰ0208ｨｨ04ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ09ｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｨ080609ｨｰｨ ,% ｨｪ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｨ080609ｨｰｨ ,% ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ 09 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ (24 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04, 94 ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07) y = -0,097 x + 7,326 R 2 = 0, ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ %ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ %ｨｺ

7 ｨ 08ｨｨ06ｨｪ0609, ｨｨ090609ｨ ｨ ｨｨｨｺｨｰ ｨｪｨ 06ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｮ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ ｨｨ01ｨｪ06, ﾂｨｰ06 ｨｪｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪ02 06ｨｺｨ ｨ 06 ｨｰ 04ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｬ ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｺ 00ｨｨ ｨｬｨｮ 06ｨｺ02ｨ ｨｪｨｮ, 06ｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｹ09ｨｺ ｨｦ09ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ 0402ｨｬ0507ｨｬｨｨ, ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, 01ｨｨ ｨｨ00ｨｨｨｺｨ 02ｨｨ07 ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ00ｨｨ 0604ｨｪ06ｨｦ 0708ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｬ , 05ｨｺ ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｬ070608ｨｰ ｨｪ0200 ｨｰｨｨ, ｨ 01ｨｬｨｨｨｪｨｨ09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ ｨｪｨｨ02 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04, 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0208 ｨｨｨｪ ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｪ ｨ ｨ, ｨｨｨｪ0102ｨｺ09 ｨｮ ｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｨ. 04ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｨ05ｨｮ ﾂ03ｨｨｨｬ 06ｨ 08ｨ 0406ｨｬ 0607ｨｨ090409ｨ 02ｨｰ ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 (050600ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬ ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 08ｨｨｨｰ02ｨｰｨ ｨｬ 0706ｨｺｨｮ07ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ) (09ｨｬ. 08ｨｨ09. 3), ﾂｨｰ ｨｰ0902ｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ02ｨｰ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪｨｮ 00ｨ 00ｨｪ0208ｨ ｨｪｨｮ06 ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨ 04ｨｬ0208ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 0102ｨｬ06ｨｪ09ｨｰ08ｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ0302 ｨｪ02ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｬ060008ｨ 00ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ, 09 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｨ02 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ. 0201ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ ,5 3,0 3,5 4,0 4,5 5,0 04ｨｨ09. 3 ｨｪ0608ｨｬｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 0609ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｺ ｨｪ02ｨｬｨｮ 0706ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ 05ｨｨ 09ｨｹ 01ｨｮ ｨｰ06ｨｬｨｮ 09 ｨｺｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨｨｨｺｨｰ0608ｨ ｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 (R 2 = 0,416). 0208ｨｮ00ｨｨ ｨｨｨｺｨｰ060804, 09ｨｮｨｴ0209ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ0706ｨｴｨｨ02 ｨｪｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ (ｨｮ01ｨ 0502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ 06ｨｰ 05ｨｺ09ｨ ｨｰ0608ｨ, ｨｺ05ｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ, 0102ｨｬ060008ｨ 00ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ, ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ 04ｨｦ ｨｮ0905ｨｮ , ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ07ｨｰ ｨｮ0905ｨｮ ｨ ｨｴ02ｨｦ ﾂ ｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｪ07ｨｰ0401, ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ ｨｮ08ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ, 06ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ 0202ｨｪ, 0706ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｨ 0202ｨｪｨｰ08ｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ 02ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｨｨｪ0102ｨｺ ｨ 04ｨｪ0606ｨ 08 ｨ 04ｨｨ07), 06ｨｺｨ 04ｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｹ ｨｰ0209ｨｪ06 ｨｺ ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ 09 ｨｮ080609ｨｪ02ｨｬ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ｨｺ0506 ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｮ080609ｨｪ07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 09 ｨｬ ｨｹ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 06ｨｪｨｨ 0706ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ 0608ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ0401 ｨｪｨ ｨｮ05ｨｮ ﾂ0302ｨｪｨｨ02 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｨ 06ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨ02 05ｨｨ03ｨｹ 09ｨｺ0506 ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 (050600ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬｨ ｨｪ ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07). 02ｨｰ08ｨｨ02ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 04ｨｪｨ ｨｺ ｨｰｨｨｨｬ 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰ060806ｨｬ 0909ｨｨ0102ｨｰ0205ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ02ｨｰ ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｨ ｨｺｨｰｨ ｨｬｨ 0903ｨｰｨ ｨ ｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｪｨ ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪｨ 07 ｨｬ ｨｹ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ06ｨ ｨ ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨｨｦ 09ｨｨ01: REV = -15, ,723 ﾁ LnGDPpc ｨC 1,357 ﾁ LnPOP + ｦﾅ, (1) (-2,541) (11,081) (-4,013) : REV ｨC ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ; LnGDPpc ｨC ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 08ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｰｨ ｨｬ 0706ｨｺｨｮ07ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ; LnPOP ｨC ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ｦﾅ ｨC 0609ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｺｨｨ; t-09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ ｨC 09 09ｨｺ06ｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ %ｨｺ ｨｪｨｹ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨC (166 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ) 60 y = 15,771x - 28, R 2 = 0, Lg ( ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｪｨ ) 11 Wagner A. Three Extracts on Public Finance. In: Classics in the Theory of Public Finance. Ed. by R.A. Musgrave, A.T. Peacock. New York, St. Martin ｯs Press, 1967, p. 1ｨC15. 24

8 1304ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｹ ｨｰ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ 04ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｰｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ020809ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ R 2 = 0,47. 05ｨｰｨ ｨｪ01ｨ 08ｨｰｨｪｨ ｨｨｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｪｨｺｨｨ = 8,33. 06ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ 06ｨ 08ｨ 0406ｨｬ, ｨｬ0603ｨｪ06 ｨｮｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨｹ, ﾂｨｰ ｨｨｨｬ0208ｨｪ06 47% ｨｨ04ｨｬ02ｨｪ ﾂｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｲ0709ｨｪ0702ｨｰ0907 ｨｨ04ｨｬ02ｨｪ ﾂｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ01 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰ ｪ ｨｮ080609ｨｪ07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01 ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｺｨｰ0208ｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ 08ｨ 09ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｮ01ｨｮ0103ｨ 06ｨｰ0907: EXP = -0, ,398 ﾁ LnGDPpc ｨC 1,311 ﾁ LnPOP + ｦﾅ, (2) (-0,141) (8,097) (-3,527) : EXP ｨC ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ; LnGDPpc ｨC ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 08ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｰｨ ｨｬ 0706ｨｺｨｮ07ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ; LnPOP ｨC ｨ 08ｨｨ00ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07; ｦﾅ ｨC 0609ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｺｨｨ; t-09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ ｨC 09 09ｨｺ06ｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｹ ｨｰ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ 04ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｬ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｰｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ020809ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ R 2 = 0,33. 05ｨｰｨ ｨｪ01ｨ 08ｨｰｨｪｨ ｨｨｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｪｨｺｨｨ = 9, ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ 0905ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｺｨ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｺｨｰ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ｨｹ- ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨ ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ06, ﾂｨｰ06 05ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｬ 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｬ 06ｨｺｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ0907 ｨ ｨ ｨ 04ｨｬｨｨ, ﾂ02ｨｬ 09 ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ 08ｨ 0909ｨｬ06ｨｰ0802ｨｪｨｪ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ ｨｦ, 08ｨ 04ｨｪ0609ｨｰ060806ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ090409ｨ 06ｨｴｨｨ01 ｨｮ ｨｨ07 09ｨｮｨｴ0209ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨ 00ｨｮｨｪｨｺ02ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｪ02 ｨ 0405ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｦ0102ｨｪ04 ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨ02, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｬ ｨｹ, ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ ｨｨ090409ｨ 06ｨｴｨｮ06 ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ06 09 ｨｬ ｨｹ06 ｨｮ080609ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ06, 06 ﾂ0209ｨｨ01ｨｪ06, ｨｨ ｨｪ02ｨｮ01ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06, ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺｨｮ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ05ｨｨ ﾂｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｰ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｪｨ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪｨｮ ｨ ｨｰｨｪ ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰｨ. 04ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨ 0605ｨｹ0306ｨｦ 09ｨｰ020702ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ0907 ｨｪ02 09ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06 08ｨ 0909ｨｬｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ09ｨ 02ｨｬ04ｨｬｨｨ 0706ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ020507ｨｬｨｨ, 09ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨ 02ｨｪｨｪ 0609ｨｰ07ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨｨｬ06ｨｦ 0905ｨ 09ｨｰ07ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ. 02ｨｰ090601ｨ ｨｮ02ｨｰ, ﾂｨｰ06 06ｨ ｨｲ02ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ0804 ｨC ｨｮ ｨｪｨｹ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ 0202 ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨC ｨ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ ｨｺｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ , ﾂ02ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ06ｨｬｨｮ ｨｪｨｨ07 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｪ06 ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｬ ｨｹ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｮ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 09 ﾂ02ｨｰ ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｬ ｨｨ, ｨ 0405ｨｨ 07 08ｨｨｨｪ07ｨｰ04 04ｨ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ0402 ｨｮ080609ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ080602ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬ ｨｨ 07ｨ 08ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰ ｨｰｨｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ 12 06ｨｺｨ 04ｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｹ 0904ｨ ｨ ｨｬｨｨ, ｨｨ04 01ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ02ｨｦ ｨ 0909ｨｬ06ｨｰ0802ｨｪｨｨ07 05ｨｰｨｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨ 0405ｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0502ｨｪ ｨｰｨ 0903ｨｨ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨ 0405ｨｨ 08ｨ ｨｪ03ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ02 06ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ01 04ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨ 04ｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ 08ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｪｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ 08ｨ 09ｨｪ ﾂｨｨ0905ｨｮ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ 0008ｨｮ (09ｨｬ. ｨｰｨ ｨ 05. 1) ｨｪ000605ｨ, 0908ｨｮｨｪ02ｨｦ, ｨｰ06, 05ｨ ｨｪ-0606ｨｬ02 ｨｨ 0308ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｨ07ｨｨ, 06ｨｺ09ｨ ｨｰ0608ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪｨ ｨｨｨｪ0207 ｨｨ 0608ｨｨｨｰ ｨｮｨｬｨｬｨ 08ｨｪ0602 ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ02 05ｨｰｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ 0,3%, ｨ 09ｨｮｨｬｨｬｨ 08ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨC 0,05% ｨｰ0902ｨｰ09ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｰ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ, ｨｰｨ 09ｨｨ09 03ｨｨ01 ｨｨ ｨｪｨｮ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ. 25

9 ｨ 08ｨｨ06ｨｪ0609, ｨｨ090609ｨ ｨ 0108ｨｮ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ 0706 ｨｰ0802ｨｰ07ｨｬ 09 04ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰ 06ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ01 08ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨ 05 ｨｨ 02 ｨ 1 04ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ 09 04ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰ 06ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ0401 (166 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ) 02ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ02 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ- ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ01 08ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ % ｨｺ ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨ 09 % ｨｺ ,7 28,9-3,7 32,7 2,53 33, ｨ ｨｮ0707ｨ -6,6 23,2-1,5 24,7 4,06 48, ｨｰ0608ｨ ｨｮ0707ｨ 4,0 26,6-4,4 31,0 2,35 17, ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ0707ｨ 13,8 37,1-5,2 42,3 1,19 34, ｨｰｨｪ060302ｨｪｨｨ ｨｦ 0008ｨｮ ｨｺ ｨｰ0802ｨｰｨｹ02ｨｦ, % -48,0 62,5 29,6 58,5 340,9 140,3 128, ｨｮ0707ｨｮ ｨｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04, 09 ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ01 04 ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｹ ｨｬｨｨｨｪ ｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ, ｨC ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨｨ 06ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬｨｨ, ｨｮ0707ｨｮ ｨC 09 ｨｬｨ ｨｺ09ｨｨｨｬｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ. 04ｨ 0909ｨｬ06ｨｰ0802ｨｪｨｨ02 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ 0008ｨｮ0707ｨｨ080609ｨｺｨｨ ｨｰ ｨｨｨｰｨｹ 04ｨ ｨｬ02ｨｰｨｪｨｮ06 ｨｪ0200ｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪｨｮ ｨｹ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ 08ｨ 0909 ﾂｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨｦ 0008ｨｮ ｨｪｨｨ0302, ﾂ02ｨｬ 09 3-ｨｦ, ｨｪｨ 37,5%, ｨｮ010205ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨC ｨｪｨ 41,5%. 00 ｨｰ ｨｬ07 ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ 09 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ 01 1-ｨｦ 0008ｨｮ , ﾂ02ｨｬ 09 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪｨ 01 3-ｨｦ 0008ｨｮ070704, 0706 ﾂｨｰｨｨ 09 3,5 08ｨ 04ｨ (4,06 ｨｨ 1,19% ｨｰ0902ｨｰ09ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ06). 0108ｨ 00ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ 09ｨｨ01 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ 04ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ % ｨｺ ｨｬ ｨｨ080609ｨｰｨ , % ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ02, ｨｬ05ｨｪ. ﾂ ｨｺ ｨ 0906 ﾂｨｪ06: ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ , ｨｪｨ ｨｨ09. 4 ﾂｨｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ 05ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ 06ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ ｨC (166 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ) y = -0,140 x + 3,051 R 2 = 0,163 ｨｪｨ 08ｨｨ ｨｨ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｨ02 06ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ0401 ｨｪｨ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ01 08ｨ 09ｨｪ0401 ｨｮ ｨｨ ｨ 02ｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ0302ｨｪｨｨ02ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｨ080609ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨ 0,14% ｨｪ ｨｰ02ｨｬ ｨｨ080609ｨｰｨ ,% ｨｰｨｺ0506ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ02 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｹｨｪ0401, ｨｪｨｰｨｪ ｨｮｨｪｨｺｨｰ ｨ 04ｨ ｨｨ02ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｨ ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0601ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｮ0707ｨｨ080609ｨｺｨｨ ｨ 04ｨ ｨｨ02ｨｪｨｨ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ ｨｮ ｨｪ0206ｨ ｨｨｨｬ06 ｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｺ0605ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ0402 ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ02 08ｨｨｨｨ 0706 ｨｺｨ ｨｬｨｮ ｨｨ04 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰ , ｨｨ01 09 ｨｬ ｨｹ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｮ080609ｨｪ07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ( ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ

10 1304ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺｨｨｨｦ ｨｰ 07ｨ 08ｨｨｨｰ02ｨｰｨ ｨｬ 0706ｨｺｨｮ07ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 09ｨ 0506ｨｰ) ｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｺ0605ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ0401 ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨｨ07: 3000 ｨｨ ｨｪｨ , ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨC ｨｰ08ｨｨ ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨｨ07: 1 ｨｬ05ｨｪ., 5 ｨｬ05ｨｪ. ｨｨ 20 ｨｬ05ｨｪ. ﾂ ｨｺ ｨ ｨｰ0205ｨｹｨｪ ｨｨｨｬ02ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ02 05ｨｰｨｨ01 ｨｺ0605ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ 0401 ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨｨ0209 ｨｺ ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｨｨｰ ｨｹ:0706 ｨｮ080609ｨｪ06 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ｨC ｨｪｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ: 0905ｨ ｨ 0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ( ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬ02ｨｪ ), ｨｪ0208ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 (06ｨｰ ), ｨｺ0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ( ); 0706 ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨC ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｰ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ: ｨｺｨ 0805ｨｨｨｺ (09 ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ02ｨｬ ｨｬ02ｨｪ ｨｬ05ｨｪ. ﾂ ｨｺ), ｨｬｨ (06ｨｰ 1 ｨｬ05ｨｪ ｨｬ05ｨｪ.), ｨｪｨｨ02 (06ｨｰ 5 ｨｬ05ｨｪ ｨｬ05ｨｪ.), ｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｨ02 ( ｨｬ05ｨｪ. ﾂ ｨｺ). 0201ｨｪ ｨｬ02ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨｨｬ02ｨｪ02ｨｪｨｨ02 ｨｺ0605ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ0401 ｨｺ08ｨｨｨｰ0208ｨｨ ｨ 06ｨｨｨｬ 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰ0608ｨ ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨ 04ｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨｨ08ｨｮ02ｨｬｨｮ ｨｺｨｮ07ｨｪ0609 ｨｰｨｹ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ0707: 0905ｨ ｨ 0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨｺｨ 0805ｨｨｨｺ , 0905ｨ ｨ 0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨｬｨ , 0905ｨ ｨ 0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ02, 0905ｨ ｨ 0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｨ02, ｨｪ0208ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ 0402 ｨｺｨ 0805ｨｨｨｺ , ｨｪ0208ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨｬｨ , ｨｪ0208ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ02, ｨｪ0208ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｨ02, ｨｺ0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨｺｨ 0805ｨｨｨｺ , ｨｺ0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨｬ ｨ , ｨｺ0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ02, ｨｺ0608ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰ0402 ｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｨ02 (09ｨｬ. ｨｰｨ ｨ 05. 2). 00 ｨｺｨ 0301ｨｮ ｨｮ ﾂ02ｨｪｨｪｨｮ ｨｮ0707ｨｮ ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ. 06 ｨ ｨ 05 ｨｨ 02 ｨ 2 04ｨ 04ｨｬ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｮ0707ｨ ｨｬ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬｨｨ08ｨ 09 04ｨ 09ｨｨ09ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｮ080609ｨｪ07 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ( ｨｮ0707, ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ) ﾂｨｨ090502ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ 0706: ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｪｨ 01ｨｮ03ｨｮ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ｨｺ , ｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ 1 ｨｬ05ｨｪ. 02ｨｰ 5 ｨｬ05ｨｪ ｨｬ05ｨｪ ｨｬ05ｨｪ ｨｬ05ｨｪ. 20 ｨｬ05ｨｪ. 06ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ % ｨｺ ,2 24,6 18,9 19,7 21, ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨ 09 % ｨｺ ,5-8,0-4,7-4,5-5, ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ % ｨｺ ,6 32,6 23,6 24,2 27, ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ % ｨｺ ,0 30,2 29,8 26,2 29, ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨ 09 % ｨｺ ,4-3,0-3,4-3,3-3, ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ % ｨｺ ,4 33,1 33,2 29,5 33, ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ % ｨｺ ,4 38,1 41,2 37,8 38, ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨ 09 % ｨｺ ,4 1,2* -2,4-2,8-1, ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ % ｨｺ ,8 36,8 43,6 40,5 40, ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ % ｨｺ ,3 29,9 27,2 26,8 28, ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨ 09 % ｨｺ ,5-3,9-3,8-3,6-3, ｨｮ01ｨ 0809ｨｰ0902ｨｪｨｪ ｨ % ｨｺ ,8 33,8 31,0 30,4 32, ｨｨ ﾂ0209ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ * ｨｨ02ｨｨｨｰ. 0308ｨｨｨｬ02 ﾂｨ ｨｪｨｨ02: ｨｪｨｨ01 ｨｮ0005ｨ 01 06ｨ 0604ｨｪｨ ﾂ02ｨｪ04 ｨｪ06ｨｬ0208ｨ 0008ｨｮ