, ｨｨ ｨ into account the accumulated experience. In this connection special attent

Transcription

1 ｨｨ ｨ * , ﾂ ｨ : ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ0906, 0708ｨ 0906, ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ, ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ, 00ｨｮｨｪｨｺ0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ030ｨｪｨｨ07, , ｨｰ00ｨｪ ｨｨｨｨ, ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ0906, 04ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰｨ, ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ E.V. Kirdyashova. Intellect, State, and Law Existence and development of the modern society is unthinkable without using achievements of scientific and technical progress, innovative economy, single and open information space, freedom of thought and speech as well as other benefits of civilization. The humankind has attained recognition of freedom of literary, artistic, scientific and other kinds of works as well as the right to take part in cultural life. Article 5 of the 966 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights declared respect for intellectual labor freedom 00indispensable for scientific research and creative activity03. At the same time the states recognized the right of everyone to enjoy the results of scientific progress and their practical application as well as to protect the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he/she is the author. The intellectual property right has not only secured in national and international law but has also entered people's mind as a necessary attribute of the modern life. The changes which took place at the turn of XX ｪXXI centuries undoubtedly have a positive significance. And the matter is not only that in Russia legal regulation of relations connected with intellectual property finally takes place based on the world standards (although this is really a very important moment for both the civil society development and the country's integration into the world economy). The state has begun to perceive a person as a carrier of intellect ｪ reason, brainpower being of essential significance for development and existence of both the society and the state as well as the holder of the rights for the results of his/her activities. The introduced novelties required development and implementation of an integrated state policy in this sphere ｪ the state influence did not limit itself only to the sphere of intellectual property products turnover. The contemporary global problems as well as internal state problems of each separately taken state testify to the necessity of their resolution on a scientific basis taking * 08ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｨ0ｨ ｨｰ 0608ｨｨ0ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｮｨｺ, 00600ｨｪｨｰ ｨｺｨ ｨｰ00608ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 0708ｨ 09ｨ ｨｺ060909ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 0608ｨｨ0ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｺｨ 00ｨｬｨｨｨｨ ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮｨｰｨ 00ｨｨｨｪｨ. [elena.kirdyashova@yandex.ru] 4

2 , ｨｨ ｨ into account the accumulated experience. In this connection special attention should be paid to the socially-oriented, creative, original side of the intellect, to the kinds of intellectual activities encouraging the progress of the humankind and its development which is demonstrated by the modern states. However, it is obvious that the intellect has not brought only benefits to the humankind. In this connection, isn't it time to pay attention to the reverse of the coin? ｨｪ ｨｮ ｨｴｨ 0ｨｰ0907 ｭ ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨｪｨ 08ｨｮｨ 0030 XX ｪXXI ｨｨ04ｨｬ0ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ 08000ｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ06, 09ｨｪ ｨｺ ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｨｨｬ006ｨｰ ｨｨｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ060 04ｨｪｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ0 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｪｨ 0708ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｬｨｨ ｨｬ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ0906ｨｬ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｪ0ｨ 08ｨｰ04 (006ｨｰ07 05ｨｰ06 00ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ06 06 ﾂ0ｨｪｨｹ 09ｨ 03ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｬ06ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｰ ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｺ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ00008ｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04 09 ｨｬｨｨ080609ｨｮ06 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｮ), ｨ 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ, ﾂｨｰ06 06ｨｰｨｪ04ｨｪ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨｰｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｰｨｹ ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ ｨ 060ｨｪ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨ ｪ 08ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬｨ, ｨｬ040905ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｨｨｬ006ｨｴ0ｨｦ 0708ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ07ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ060 04ｨｪｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07 ｨｨ 09ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｪ ｨｰ09ｨ 0706ｨｰ080ｨ 0609ｨ 05ｨｨ 08ｨ 0408ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰｨｺｨｨ ｨｨ 080ｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｬ07050ｨｺ09ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ 09 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ 06ｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ ｪ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨ0 ｨｪ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｨ050609ｨｹ ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｦ ｨｰ0609ｨ ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｮｨｺｨｰ0609 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 05ｨｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｪ040 ｨ 09070ｨｺｨｰ04 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ040 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨｪｨｨｨｺｨ 06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｮ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ0609, ｨｮ06 06 ﾂ00800ｨｹ ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨ0, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 06ｨｰ0005ｨｹｨｪ040 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｨ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ0 ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨｮ0804, 06ｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｰ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ 00609ｨｰｨｮ07ｨ ｨｺ ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨｮ08ｨｪ04ｨｬ 00ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰ07ｨｬ, 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ0 ｨｨｨｪｨｪ0609ｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨｨｺｨｨ, ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｨ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ0 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ0ｨｪ0ｨｨｨ 05ｨ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ. 0ｨ ｨｲ00ｨｨｨｪ070ｨｰ ｨｰｨｨ 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｰ06, ﾂｨｰ06 06ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｬｨｮ ｨ ｨｪ04 09 ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｬ0706ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ. 06ｨｰ06ｨｰ ｨ ｨｺｨｰ 09 ｨｺ06ｨｪ0 ﾂｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｰ ｨｨ0ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｨｨｬ 09060ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪｨｮ06 00ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ. 0308ｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｬ, ｨ ｨｮ0ｨｮ ﾂｨｨ 09ｨ 03ｨｪ0ｨｦ03ｨｨｨｬ ｨｺ06ｨｬ0706ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｨ 0708ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 09 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ ｨｰｨｮ07ｨ 0ｨｰ 09 ｨｺｨ ﾂ009ｨｰ ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨ04 ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ09ｨｨ0ｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040 0ｨ ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ ｨｨｨｰｨｹ0907, ﾂｨｰ ｨ 0605ｨｹ0306ｨｬｨｮ 09 ﾂ0ｨｰｨｮ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ040 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ06ｨｬ, ｨｪ ｨｬ0ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨ 09ｨｰ0607ｨｴ00006 ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ0907 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06 ｨｰｨ ｨｨ0 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｹ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ0608ｨ 07 ｨｪ ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨ 0708ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0, ｨｺｨｮ ｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰｨｮ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ

3 ｨ ｨｺｨｰ008ｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨｨｺ ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｬｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨ0 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ ｨｨ00ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ060, 09ｨｮ00ｨｮｨ 06 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｪ060 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｺ 06ｨｺ08ｨｮ03ｨ 06ｨｴ0ｨｦ 00ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ. 06ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ 06ｨ 08ｨ 0406ｨｬ, 06ｨ 08ｨ ｨｴｨ 0709ｨｹ ｨｺ 0708ｨ ｨｬｨｮ 08000ｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ06 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨｪｨｨｨｺｨ 06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｨ 09 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ06ｨｬ, ｨｪｨ 0609ｨｪ ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨｬ06ｨｪ09ｨｰ08ｨｨ08ｨｮ0ｨｰ ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｺ ﾂ ｨｺｨｮ ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 0005ｨｨ ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ﾂ008ｨｺｨｨ09ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ09ｨｨ0ｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ060ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ06 04ｨ ｨｺ ｨｰ 00 00ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｮ ｨｪ0609ｨｮ ｨｬ0 ｨｰ060006, 09ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 0708ｨ 09ｨ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮ 0909ｨｨ00ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ0ｨｰ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 04ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｰｨ ｨｴ0ｨｦ 0708ｨｨ ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｪ06 09ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰｨｹ, ﾂｨｰ06 ｨｬ04 09ｨｰｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｬ ﾂ009ｨｨ00ｨ ｨｬｨｨ 09ｨｬ0ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨ ｨｺ00ｨｪｨｰｨ 0708ｨ ｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ0ｨｰｨｪ ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨｰ006080ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｮ06, ｨｪｨ 09ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪｨｮ06 09ｨｰ060806ｨｪｨｮ ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｪｨ ｨｨｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪｨｮ06 ｨｨ 09ｨ 03ｨｪｨｮ ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0ｨｦ ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨ ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨ 050ｨｬ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ030 09ｨｪｨｮｨｰ08ｨｨ000609ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 050ｨｬ04 ｨｺｨ ｨｰ0005ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 0909ｨｨ00ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｰ 06 ｨｪ006ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06ｨｦ 0609ｨｪ06090, 09 ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ06ｨｬｨｮ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ06 ｨｮ000507ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｨ0ｨｪｨｰｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｰ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ, 0608ｨｨ00ｨｨｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｪ0 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨ, ｨｰ0ｨｬ 09ｨｨ0ｨ ｨｬ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｮ ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ06, ﾂｨｰ06 ｨｨ 00ｨｬ06ｨｪ09ｨｰ08ｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ. 00ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06 06 ﾂ009ｨｨ0ｨｪ06, ﾂｨｰ06 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ 0708ｨｨｨｪ009 ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ09ｨｮ ｨｪ0 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06 ｨ 05ｨ ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ ｨ, 00 ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ0906 ｪ ｨ 04ｨｦ ｨ ｨｨ ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨｨｦ 09ｨｨ0, ｨｺ06ｨｰ060804ｨｦ 09ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨｮ0ｨｰ, ｨ 09ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ06 ｨｮ ｨｨ ｨｮｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｰ06030ｨｪｨｨ07, 0904ｨｬｨｨ08ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07. 06ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ ｨｨ07 ｪ 06ｨｰ ｨｨ04ｨｪ00007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ ｨｺｨ 09 09ｨ ｨｬ06ｨｬ 03ｨｨ0806ｨｺ06ｨｬ 09ｨｬ ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ 05ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｮ ｨ ｨｰｨｮ07ｨ 05ｨ 09060ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 00ｨｮｨｪｨｺ0ｨｨ0ｨｦ ｨｮ ｨｰ0ｨｬ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ0907, ｨｨ0906ｨｺ ｨｮ ｨｨｨｦ ｨ ｨｬ06ｨｮｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｰ06030ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪ0 ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨ 0ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｨ 08004ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ04 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ00, ｨｰ09ｨｨ07 ｨｨ0 09ｨｪ00080ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ0ｨｮ ｨｰ ｨｰ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｰｨｨ0005ｨ 0708ｨ ｨ 07 04ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰｨ ｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｰｨ ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ ｨ 06ｨ 08ｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｪ0 0904ｨ ｨｨｨｬ0606ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨ, 0708ｨ 09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ06 09 ｨｪｨ 09ｨｰ0607ｨｴ ｨｬ ｨｨ06ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｨｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｮ06 ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｬｨｨｨｪｨ 06ｨｰ ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｰｨ 06 ｨｰ06ｨｬ, ﾂｨｰ ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 0906ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬ 08ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬ06ｨｬ ｨ ｨｪ06 ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ ｨ 060ｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06 06ｨｪ ｨｨｨｬ ｨ 00ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｮｨｬ060408ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｨ03: , ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0, 06ｨｰ08ｨ 03ｨ 06ｨｴ00 ｨ 04ｨｰｨｨ0; ｨｰ , ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0, ｨｰ ｨｴ00 09ｨ ｨｬ ｨ 07; 09-ｨｰ080ｨｰｨｹｨｨ0, ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0, ｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｮ06ｨｴ00 ｨ 04ｨｰｨｨ ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ06, ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ06 00 ﾂ ｨｰ060806ｨｦ "090506ｨｦ" ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ09ｨｨ0 06ｨ 080ｨｰｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ, ｨ 0ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｰ060806ｨｦ 06ｨｰ05ｨｨ ﾂｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｰ 008ｨｮ00ｨｨ0 ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ09ｨｨ (09ｨｬ.: 08008ｨｨｨｬ ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨ 09ｨ ｨｬ0ｨｰ, 00ｨｮｨｪｨｺ0ｨｨｨｨ, ｨ 050ｨｬ04 00ｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ 0708ｨ 09ｨ. -0 ｨｨ , ). 000ｨｪ ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 0708ｨ 09ｨ. 00., ｪ79. 6

4 , ｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ06030ｨｰ 0ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ. 006 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｪ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 08ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬ06ｨｬ ｨｪ00800ｨｺ ｨｪ06 ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ 06 ﾂ0ｨｪｨｹ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪ06, ｨｪ06 ｨｰｨ ｨｺ, ﾂｨｰ06ｨ ｨ 0ｨｪｨｪ06 ｨｪ ｨｰ09ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ04ｨｬ 0708ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ 0906ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｰ 0706ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ 05 00ｨｰｨ ｨｺ060, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ ｨｰ0907 ｨｺ0ｨｬ-ｨｰ06 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｦ ﾂｨｨｨｰｨ 06ｨｴ0ｨｦ 07ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨｨｺ06ｨｦ03, ｨ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｰ06, 00ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ ｨｰ0907 ﾂ ｨｺ06ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ 0ｨｬｨｮ 0008ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｺ06ｨｬ ｨｰｨｮ ｨｨ05ｨｨ 0905ｨｮ03ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｺ06ｨｰ , 04ｨ ｨｰ08ｨ 00ｨｨ09ｨ 06ｨｴｨｨ0 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｪ 06ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 05 ｨｪ0ｨｬ00ｨｺｨｨｨｦ 00ｨｨ , ｪ ｨｪ006ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ ｨｬ00ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨｬ, 0708ｨｨ 0706ｨｬ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｰ0 ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪ040 ﾂ050ｨｪ04 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨ 0405ｨｨ ｨ ｨｰｨｨ 090ｨ 07 07ｨ 0909ｨｨ09ｨｪ06, ﾂｨｰ06ｨ ｨ 09ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ0906 ｨ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｰ0906ｨｬ ｨｨ09ｨｺｨｮ0909ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨｨｪ060ｨｮ03ｨｨ07 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ0 ｨｪｨ 0609ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ09050ｨｪｨｨ0 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｦ ｨｨ05ｨｨ 0706 ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｦｨｪ0ｨｦ ｨｬ0080 ｨｮ000803ｨｨ09ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ0 06ｨｰ ｨｮｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｰ06030ｨｪｨｨ07 05ｨｰｨｨ ｨｦ ｨｹ, ｨｺ06ｨｪ0 ﾂｨｪ06, ｨｪ ｨｪ06 08ｨ 0909ｨｮ030ｨ ｨｰｨｹ, ｨｹ ｨｮ0ｨｰ ｨｨｨｪ0609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺｨｮ 05ｨｰｨ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｹ ｨｬ00ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨｬｨ 08ｨ 0909ｨｬｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ09ｨ 0ｨｰ 090ｨ 07 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ﾂ050ｨｪｨ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 0ｨ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ 0008ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪ ｨｬｨｨ08ｨ, ｨ 09ｨｰｨ 0506 ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ, 09 ｨｺｨ ﾂ009ｨｰ090 ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪ , ｨｺ06ｨｰ060804ｨｦ 06ｨ ｨｴｨ 0ｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ 09ｨｬ ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨｨｺ06ｨｦ 0708ｨｨ 0706ｨｬ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨｰ06, ｨｺ06ｨｪ0 ﾂｨｪ06, ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｬ06030ｨｰ 08ｨ 0909ｨｮ030ｨ ｨｰｨｹ, ｨｪ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｪ ｨｮｨｴ008ｨ ｨ 0005ｨ ｨｬ, 04ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｰｨｹ0907 ｨｺ06ｨｰ060804ｨｬｨｨ 0ｨｬｨｮ ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪ06 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 07ｨ 0909ｨｨ09ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｮ ﾂ050ｨｪｨｮ ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ 06ｨ 08ｨ 0406ｨｬ, 0ｨｴ0 09 ｨｺ06ｨｪ00 XVIII 09. ｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪ06 09ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｪ006ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ09ｨｨ0ｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬ 08ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬ06ｨｬ 09 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ008009ｨ 0 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｬ, 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ008009ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｺ06ｨｪｨｺ080ｨｰｨｪ ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ09ｨｨ0ｨ (ｨｰ ｨ 00 ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｪ ｨｪｨｪ06050ｨｰｨｨ07, 09 ｨｺ06ｨｰ060806ｨｬ 06ｨｪ ｨｪｨ 0060ｨｨｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｨｨｪ003, 0604ｨｪｨ ﾂｨ 06ｨｴ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨｨｬ 08ｨ 0909ｨｮ0ｨｺ06ｨｬ ｨ ｨｮｨｺ ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｰ060806ｨｪ04 ｨｺ ｨｰ06 008ｨｮ ) ｨｰｨ ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ06 ｨｪ009ｨｬ06ｨｰ0807 ｨｪｨ ｨｬｨ ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ 00ｨｬ06ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 00ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰ0ｨｦ, ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ07 09ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨ ｨ, ｨｬ040905ｨｨ, ｨｰ ﾂ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ (070807ｨｬ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨ ) ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨ ﾂ ﾂｨ ｨｴ ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬ009ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｰｨ 09ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ00505ｨｨ000ｨｪ0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨｨｬ008ｨｮ, 08ｨｪ0080ｨｦ 00ｨ ｨｺ09ｨｨｨｬ ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 0ｨｰ, ﾂｨｰ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ 07ｨｨｨ ｨｨ0ｨｪｨｰｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ08ｨ 0906ｨｰｨｮ, ｨ ｨｪ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｬ ｨｪ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｰｨｮ ｨｺ08ｨ 0906ｨｰｨｮ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ0608ｨ ｨ 090ｨｰ ｨｬｨｨ08, ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰｨｮ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ0608ｨ ｨ ｨｮ0ｨｨｨｰ ｨｪ0 0709ｨｪ ｨｬ0ｨｪ07 ﾂｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｰ ｨｨｨｰ ｨ ｨｪ0 09 ｨｪｨ 03ｨｨ0 09ｨｨ05ｨ ｨｨ0ｨｪｨｰｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ 07ｨｨｨ 08? 0605ｨｨ ｨｰ ｨｨ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｬ060005ｨｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｰ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨｨｦ , ｨ ｨｬ ｨｨ 05ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨ ｨｪｨｰ 0706ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ 0ｨｰ 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ09050 ｨｨ 0600ｨｨ0008ｨ, ｨｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｪｨｨｨｺｨ, ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｰ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｪ ｨ ｨｬ ｨ ｨｺ09ｨｨｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｪ // ｨ (5406). 7

5 ｨ 04 05ｨｰ ｨ ｨｰｨｹ, 04ｨ ｨｪ07ｨｰ04 ｨｺｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬｨｨ-ｨｰ06 ｨｨｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨｨｬｨｨ 0005ｨ ｨｬｨｨ?03 ｪ ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｰ ｨｬｨｮ 09ｨｰ0608ｨｨｨｰ 0708ｨｨｨｦ ｨｬ , 06ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 06ｨｴｨｨｨｦ, ﾂｨｰ "070603ｨｨｨ 06ｨｬ 006ｨｬｨ ｨｰ00807ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ" ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨ 03ｨｨ0 ｨｰ0050ｨｺｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨ ｨｺ003, ｨｨ ｨ 00ｨ 06ｨｴｨｨｨｦ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ0 06ｨ ｨ ｨｰ0050ｨｪ00005ｨｨ 06ｨｰ0 ﾂ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｺｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ06ｨｦ 0006ｨｰ060806ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｨ00ｨ 05ｨ ｨｪ009ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｪｨ 0408 ｪ 00ｨｺ ｨｪｨ ｨｺｨ ﾂｨ ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ ｨｬ04030ｨ ｨｬｨｨ, ｨ ｨｨｨｦ 09090ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｰｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ 09ｨｨ ｨｬｨｨ 00ｨｨｨｪ06ｨ ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ ｨｮ090080ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ 09 09ｨｮ0ｨｹｨ 06ｨｪ0609ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｬｨｨ0909ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨｨｦ09ｨｺ ｨｪｨ ｨｰ07030ｨｪｨｨｨｨ 09090ｨｦ ｨｨ09ｨｰ0608ｨｨｨｨ ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｬ ｨｬｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ06 ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｰ060806ｨ 06ｨｰｨ ｨｬ04 06ｨ 0704ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｪ0 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｬ ｨｬｨ ｨｦ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ, ｨｪ06 ｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨｮ (ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｺｨ ｨｺ ｨｬ0ｨｰ06ｨｬ 06ｨ 09ｨｮ0300ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｪｨ ｨｰ090ｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｴ0ｨｦ ｨｰ0050ｨｪ ｨ 09ｨｹ 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ ｨ 08ｨ ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪｨ ｨｬｨ ). 00ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06 ｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ04 06ｨ 08ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨ 06ｨｬ 0905ｨｮ ﾂｨ 0 ｨｺ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｨ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｪ06 ｨｺ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ080ｨｰｨ ｨｰ07 ｨ ｨｨ0ｨｮ ｨｰ060006, ﾂｨｰ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰ09 ｨｬｨ ｨｦ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨ ﾂ ｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｰｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ0906ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0060ｨｨｨｰ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬ 09ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ ｨｰｨｹ 0ｨｴ0 ｨ ｨｨ0806ｨｺ060 ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｰ0906, ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｨｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｮ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ0 ｨｪ0 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040 03ｨｮ08ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｰ04, 07ｨｨ09ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｨ, 0900ｨｮｨｴｨｨ0 ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｰ ｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ 05ｨｨｨｰ008ｨ ｨｰｨｮ0804, ｨｨ09ｨｺｨｮ0909ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｬｨ ｨｺ06ｨｬｨｬｨｮｨｪｨｨｨｺｨ 0ｨｨｨｦ ｪ 06ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ ｨｹ ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ ｨ 06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｺｨ 03004ｨｦ ｨｬ06030ｨｰ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｬ, ｨｺ06ｨｬｨｬ0ｨｪｨｰｨ ｨｰ060806ｨｬ, ｨ ｨｰ0050ｨｬ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｬ ﾂ009ｨｨ00ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ ｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｴ00006 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ-06ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ07 09ｨ ｨｬ040 08ｨ 04ｨｪ0606ｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｪ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰ0050ｨｦ ｨｺｨｰ0806ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｨ040ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 (09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ09050 ｨｰ08ｨ 0ｨｨ0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ09 ｨｬｨ ｨｦ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ) ｨｮ ﾂｨ 06ｨｰ ｨ 0605ｨｹ03ｨｮ ｨｮ050708ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ 03ｨｨ0806ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｮ0ｨｨｨｰ0608ｨｨｨｨ ｨｬｨｮ 08070ｨｮ 0708ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ. ﾁｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｰ005ｨｨ ｨｬ0600ｨｮｨｰ ｨｪ0 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｬｨ ｨｰ008ｨｨｨ 050, ｨｪ06 ｨｨ 09ｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｰｨｮ07ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨｨｺｨ 0ｨｨｨｦ ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｺ06 ｨｨ ｨｰ06 ｨｪｨ ｨｦｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ 06ｨ 09ｨｮ0ｨｨｨｰｨｹ 0708ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ 0506ｨ ｨｮ06 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ008009ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｮ06 09ｨ 09 ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06, ｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｺｨ ﾂ009ｨｰ090 ｨｨ 0905ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰ0050ｨｦ ｨｮ ﾂｨ ｨｰｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｰｨｺ0804ｨｰ04ｨｬ. 06ｨ ｨｺ, ｨｺ 0708ｨｨｨｬ008ｨｮ, ｨ ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨｰｨ 09050ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｪｨ ｨｮｨｬ0 ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨｬ 00ｨ ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰ0ｨｰｨ 0709ｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨ ｨｰ060906ｨｦ, ｨｺｨ 03004ｨｦ 0707ｨｰ04ｨｦ 080ｨ 0ｨｪ06ｨｺ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ060804ｨｦ ｨｹ04ｨｮ0ｨｰ ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｨ, ｨｰ ｨｰ0906ｨｦ ｨｮｨｪｨｨ030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｨｨｨ. 0ｨ 06ｨ ｨｲ0ｨｬｨ 0 ｨｪｨ 08ｨｮ030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ 09 06ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｰ ｨ ｨ 0005ｨｹ0009 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0906ｨ 09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 09ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｪ06 ｨｮ030 09ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06, ﾂｨｰ ｨｰ060807ｨｰｨｹ0907 ｨｪ0 ｨｨｨｬ00ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪｨ 07 ｨｨ0ｨｨ0505ｨｨ0703 // ｨ (5407). 05ｨｬ.: 0ｨ 008ｨｨｨｪｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ ｨｨ03 // ｨ (540)

6 , ｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ040905ｨ ｨ ｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｨ 08ｨ 0ｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｰｨｬ0ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｹ, ﾂｨｰ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨｰｨ 0ｨｰ0907 ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨｪ0ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｨ05ｨ 03ｨｨ04ｨｪｨｨ 09 ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｰ090, 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｹ 0708ｨ 09ｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ ｨｨ 06ｨ ﾂｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ 06ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰｨ, 0708ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｺ0506 ﾂ ｨｮ ｨｨ07 ｪ ｨ ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰｨ ｨ 06ｨｬ 0905ｨｮ- ﾂｨ ｨｰ06ｨｨｨｰ 0ｨｴ0 ｨｬｨｪ ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰ04. 00ｨｪｨ ｨｺ06 ｨｪｨ 08070ｨｮ ﾂ009ｨｨ0ｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ ｨｪｨ 08ｨｮ030ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 09 ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪ, 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0ｨｴｨ 0ｨｬ ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ0 ｨｬｨ ｨｰ008ｨｨｨ 0504 ｨｰｨ 07ｨｰ ｨｨ 09ｨｺ0804ｨｰ040 ｨｮ , 05ｨｰ06 ｨｺｨ 09ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｰ ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨ 060ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨ 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ, ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ030 ﾂｨ 09ｨｰ ｨｰ080 ﾂｨ 06ｨｴｨ ｨ ｨｪ06ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ, ｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｪ04, ｨｨ 06ｨｰ09ｨｮｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｺｨ ｨｺｨｨ0-ｨｰ06 00ｨｨ05ｨｹｨｰ ｪ ｨｮ0006ｨｦ, ｨｬ0600ｨｮｨｰ 05000ｨｺ ｨｰｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰ ｨ ｨ 05ｨｮ0300ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ0 ｨｰ060006, 06 ﾂ009ｨｨ0ｨｪ06, ﾂｨｰ06 0ｨ 050ｨｺ06 ｨｪ ｨｺ ｨｪｨｨ0 ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｺ ｨ 04ｨｮｨｬｨ ｨｰ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｪ04ｨｬ (ｨｪ ｨｮ030 06ｨ 06ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｬｨｪ0600ｨｨ0 090ｨｴ0ｨｦ). 006 ｨｪｨ ｨｪ0703ｨｪｨｨｨｦ 00ｨｪｨｹ ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ ｨｰ0907 ｨｪｨ ｨｨｨ ｨｰｨｮ07ｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｰ0906ｨｬ ｨ 04ｨｬ0ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｮｨｺｨｰ ｨｰ , ｨｪ0ｨｬｨ ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｨ ｨ 09ｨｰ060809ｨｺ ｨｬ050ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 09ｨ 0ｨｬ ｨｬｨ ｨｰ008ｨｨｨ 05ｨ ﾂｨｹ ｨｨ00ｨｰ 0ｨ 030 ｨｪ0 06ｨ 0600ｨｪｨｺ0 08ｨ 04ｨｬ0ｨｴｨ 0ｨｬ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ 09ｨ ｨｬｨｨｨｬ ｨ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｬ (ｨｪｨｨｨｺｨｰ06 ｨｪ0 006 ﾂ0ｨｰ 0706ｨｺｨｮ03ｨ ｨｰｨｹ0907 ｨｪｨ ｨ 060ｨｮ ｨ, ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨ 0708.) (006ｨｰ07 ｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｦ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹ ｨｬ06030ｨｰ ﾂｨｨｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨ 09ｨｰ0608ｨ 00ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 09ｨｨ05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｰ ｨｨ0ｨｮ ｨｪ004ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 008ｨｮ00ｨｨ0 ｨｰ06 ﾂ0ｨｺ 04080ｨｪｨｨ07), ｨ ｨｰ06 06 ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨｮ ﾂｨｨ, ｨ ｨｬ06ｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰ06ｨｬ 0705ｨ ｨｪ0 ｨ 09ｨｰ060809ｨｺｨｨ ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ07 04ｨ ﾂｨ 09ｨｰｨｮ ｨｰ0907 ｨｪｨ ｨｪ04ｨｬ 06ｨｰ08ｨ 030ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ ｨｪ0ｨ 05ｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨｮ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ ｨｮ ﾂｨ 0ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹ 06ｨｺｨ ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｨｨｪ ｨｪｨ 060ｨｨｨｪ 09 ｨｪｨ 030ｨｦ 00ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ06 (09009ｨｹｨｬｨ 0ｨ 050ｨｺ06ｨｦ 06ｨｰ 0708ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｪ040 06ｨ 08ｨ ), ｨｨ ｨｪ0ｨｰ ｨｪｨｨｨｺｨ ｨｺｨｨ0 0800ｨ ｨｺｨｰ , ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040 03ｨｮ08ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｰ0609 ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｦ (04ｨ 00ｨｦ09ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｪｨｪ040, ｨｺ 0708ｨｨｨｬ008ｨｮ, ｨｰ0609ｨｺｨｨ ｨｺｨｪｨｨ ﾂｨ ｨｰｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｮｨｺ0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨ05ｨｨ 07008ｨｨ060ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 070 ﾂｨ ｨｰｨｪ040 ｨｨ040ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ, ｨｨｨｪ ｨｮｨｺｨｰ ｨｰ09 ｨｬｨ ｨｦ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ) ｨｨ 05ｨｰ06 06ｨ 09ｨｰ0607ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ ｨ 09ｨｰ09ｨｮ0ｨｰ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ06 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ0ｨｪ0ｨｨｨ 05ｨ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨｮ08ｨｪ040 00ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰ0ｨｦ. 00-ｨｰ080ｨｰｨｹｨｨ0, ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ 06ｨｰｨｺ0804ｨｰ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｨ04ｨ 003ｨｪ ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｰ080ｨｬ050ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｺ 09ｨ ｨｬ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｬｨｨ 0904ｨｰ0ｨｺｨ 06ｨｴｨｨｨｬｨｨ ｨｰ09ｨｨ07ｨｬｨｨ. 00ｨｮ09ｨｰ06ｨｦ ﾂｨｨ090609ｨｰｨｹ, ｨｬｨｪ ｨ 08ｨｨｨ ｨｪｨｰｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ07, 0905ｨｮ ﾂｨ ｨｦｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ 0904ｨ 0608ｨ ｨｨ ﾂｨｨ0 ｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨｨ ｨｮｨｰ ｨｪ040 ｨｪ008ｨ 09ｨｪ ｨｪ040 09ｨｨ09ｨｰ0ｨｬ ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｰｨｪ ｨｨｨｬ ｨｬｨ 0903ｨｰｨ ｨ 06ｨｬ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｰ0906, 06ｨｰｨｺ0804ｨｰ ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨ, 04ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｰ, ｨｨｨｬ006ｨｴ ｨｨ ｨ 060ｨｪ04ｨｦ 00609ｨｰｨｮ07 ｨｺ 0506ｨ 06ｨｬｨｮ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｰ00506 ( ｨｬｨｪｨｨｨｬ 006ｨｰ07 ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｬｨ ｨｬ ｨｨ07ｨｰｨｨｨｦ 0708ｨｨ 0706ｨｬ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ008ｨｪ0ｨｰ-08009ｨｮ ) ｨｰ06ｨｬ, ｨｬ06030ｨｰ 05ｨｨ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ ｨｬ ｨｨ05ｨｨ 06ｨｰ0005ｨｹｨｪ ﾂ050ｨｪ ｨｰ06ｨｦｨｪ ｨｰ080ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪ- 9

7 ｨｪ06ｨｦ 05ｨ 09ｨｨｨｪ06ｨｦ? 0ｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ ｨｪｨ 03ｨ ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ? 00 ｨ ｨｮ00ｨｰ 05ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ 060ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰ 008ｨｮ00ｨｨ0? 03ｨｴ0 060ｨｨｨｪ 0708ｨｨｨｬ ｨｰ080ｨｰｨｹ0ｨｬ ｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｮ08ｨｪｨ 05ｨ 00New Scientist03 04ｨ ｨ Beyond03 (04ｨ 0008ｨ ｨｪｨｹ06 ｪ ｨ ｨｪ0005.) ｨ 0405ｨ 0607ｨｮｨ 05ｨｨｨｺ0609ｨ ｨｪｨ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮｨｰ06ｨｪｨ ｨｨ ｨｨ050906ｨｪ 06 ｨｪ0ｨｦ0806ｨｬｨ 08ｨｺ0ｨｰｨｨｨｪ ﾂｨｹ 09 ｨｪ0ｨｦ ｨｨ00ｨｰ 06 ｨｬ0ｨｰ060ｨｨｨｺ0, 0708ｨｨ 0706ｨｬ06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｺ06ｨｰ060806ｨｦ ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪ ｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｪｨｨｨｰｨｹ, ﾂｨｰ ｨ ｨｮ030ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｪｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰ06 ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪ060 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｨｨｰｨｹ ｨｨｨｪ000608ｨｬｨ 0ｨｨ06 06 ｨｪｨ 03ｨｨ0 09ｨｺ0804ｨｰ ｨｰ080ｨ ｨｪ0609ｨｰ070 ｨｨ 03005ｨ ｨｪｨｨ070, 0706 ｨｬｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｨ09ｨｰ ｨｪ0ｨｦ0806ｨｬｨ 08ｨｺ0ｨｰｨｨｨｪ00ｨｮ, ｨｬ0603ｨｪ ｨｰ0906ｨｬ 05050ｨｺｨｰ080605ｨｪ0000ｨ ｨ 00ｨｨｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0609ｨｪ06090 ｨ ｨｪｨ 05ｨｨ04ｨ ｨ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｬ060400ｨ ｨｨ ｨｨ04ｨｬ0080ｨｪｨｨ07 05ｨｬ060ｨｨ06ｨｪｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰｨｺ05ｨｨｨｺｨ ｨｨ090704ｨｰｨｮ0ｨｬ ｨｰ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06, ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 0ｨｴ0 ｨｪ0 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ ﾂ0ｨｪ04, ｨｨ 0ｨ ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｪ ｨ ｨｪ04 03ｨｨ0806ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ 09ｨｺ0. 00ｨｪｨ ｨｺ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ0 06ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 0ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｨ 0706ｨｰ080ｨ ｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｺｨｨ0 ｨｰ0609ｨ , 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ09050 Procter & Gamble, ｨｮ030 ｨｨ ｨｹ04ｨｮ06ｨｰ ｨｰ090ｨｰ09ｨｰ09ｨｮ06ｨｴｨｮ06 ｨｬ0ｨｰ060ｨｨｨｺｨｮ. 00 ｨｨ09ｨｺ0506 ﾂ0ｨｪ ｨｺ ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｨ ｨｬ ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 0904ｨ ｨ 05ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｪ0 ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｪ0ｨｦ0806ｨｬｨ 08ｨｺ0ｨｰｨｨｨｪ00ｨ 0706ｨｺｨ 0609ｨｰｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｰｨｺ0804ｨｰ04ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 05: 0000 ｨｬ0ｨｪ00 09ｨ 03ｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｰ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ ｨ, ｨ 0ｨｪｨｪ06 09 ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨ0 06ｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｰ070, ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 000ｨｪ0ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ, ｨｬ00ｨｨ0ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｺｨ 07 ｨ ｨｨ ｨｨ07 ｨｨ ｨｬｨｨ08ｨｮ0ｨｰ0907 ｨｪ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ060 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨ0 ｪ ｨ ｨｨ0605ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ, ｨ ｨｪｨｪｨ ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ090705ｨ ｨｪｨｰｨ 0ｨｨ0ｨｦ ｨ ｨｪ0609 ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｨ04ｨｬ0ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ , ｨｨ09ｨｺｨｮ0909ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ04ｨｬ ｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ, ｨｪｨｨｨｺｨ 06ｨｰ ｨ 050ｨｬ ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨ 04ｨｨｨｨ. 06 ｨ 004 ｨｺ06ｨｪｨｰ080605ｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｴ00006 ｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｰｨｨ08ｨｮ06ｨｴ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｬ003ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨ 09 05ｨｰｨｮ 06ｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ030 ｨｪ0 06ｨ 06ｨｦｨｰｨｨ09ｨｹ ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｮ09ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｰ0908ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ0603ｨｪ040 ｨｪ000ｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｦ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ. 06ｨｰ ｨ ｨｪ06 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ 09 ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨｪｨｨ0ｨｬ 06ｨ ｨｴｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｨ 04ｨ 07080ｨｰ0609 ｨｪｨ 08ｨｮ030ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 09 ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｰｨ ｨｺ ｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ0005ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬｨｨ ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ070 0ｨｴ ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｦ 00ｨｺ05ｨ 08ｨ 0ｨｨ0ｨｦ 0708ｨ 09 ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｪ06, ﾂｨｰ ｨｨ 0609ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ09050ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｨ0 0708ｨ 09 ｨｨ ｨ 060 ｨｺｨ 03004ｨｦ ﾂ ｨｺ ｨｪ ｨ ｨｰｨｹ0907 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06 ｨｰｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ07ｨｬ, ｨｺｨ ｨｺｨｨ0 ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ｨｪ ｨｪ04 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｨ09ｨｺ0506 ﾂｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ ｨｹ06 06ｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪ ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨ ｨｮ09ｨ 030ｨｪｨｨ ｨ 09 ｨｨ ｨ ｨｮ00ｨｨ0 ｨｨ ｨｮ ｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｨ09040 ｨｰ080ｨ 0609ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｬ0608ｨ 05ｨｨ, 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ 06ｨ ｨｴ00006 ｨ 05ｨ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ06ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｬ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09003 (09ｨｰ. 9) ｨｮｨｪｨ 08060ｨｪ04ｨｦ 07ｨ ｨｺｨｰ 06ｨ 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 0708ｨ 09ｨ 0, 09060ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040 ｨｨ ｨｺｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨｮ08ｨｪ ｨ 09ｨ ｨｮ09ｨｺｨ 0ｨｰ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺｨｮ, ｨｺ0605ｨｹｨｺｨｮ 05ｨｰ ｨｬ009ｨｰｨｨｨｬ ｨｨ ｨｦ ｨｮｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 09, ｨｨ ｨｨ09ｨｺ0506 ﾂｨｨｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ ｨｹ ｨ 09ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ 06ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｬｨｮ ｨ 05ｨ ｨｰ0607ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ06ｨｺ08ｨ ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｬ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ090 (09ｨｰ. 4). 05ｨｬ.: 0906ｨｮｨｰ06ｨｪ 0., 07ｨｨ050906ｨｪ ｨｮ07ｨｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪ07!03 // New Scientist ｪ0. 000ｨｪ ｨｺｨ ﾂ

8 , ｨｨ ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮ0ｨｨｨｨ 0408 ｨｰｨ ｨｺ030 06ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 0ｨｰ, ﾂｨｰ ｨ 09ｨ ｨｨ ｨ ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ 0008ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｪｨ ｨｬ0600ｨｮｨｰ ｨ 04ｨｰｨｹ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪ ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｬ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬ ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ06 09 ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｬ0080, 09 ｨｺｨ ｨｺ06ｨｦ 05ｨｰ06 ｨｪ006ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰ ｨｪ0609 ｨｺ06ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮ0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨｰ080607, ｨｪ08ｨ 0909ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｹ07, 0708ｨ 09 ｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ ｨｮ00ｨｨ0 05ｨｨ0, 06ｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ07 06ｨ ｨｪ04 09ｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｨ ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｺｨ 09ｨ 06ｨｴｨｨ ｨｰ0005ｨｹｨｪ040 09ｨｨ00609 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ. 06ｨ ｨｺ, ｨｪｨ 0708ｨｨｨｬ008, ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ04ｨｦ 08ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰｨｪｨｨｨｺ 06ｨ 0704ｨ ｨｪ 0609ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ090507ｨｰｨｹ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪｨｮ06, ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｮ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｨ (ｨｨ05ｨｨ) 05ｨｺ ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪｨｰｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040 08ｨ 0408ｨ ｨ 06ｨｰｨｺｨｨ, ｨｪ0 ｨｪｨ 08ｨｮ03ｨ ｨ 09ｨ ｨｨ ｨ ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｪ0 0708ｨｨ ﾂｨｨｨｪ ｨ ｨｨ04ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｹ06, ｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｺ030 06ｨｺ08ｨｮ03ｨ 06ｨｴ0ｨｦ ( ｨｰ ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪｨ 06ｨｰ 3 ｨ 0900ｨｮ09ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｮｨｺ0 ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺ003 ) ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ 06ｨｰ 5 ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ 08000ｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ 09 06ｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ 000ｨｪｨｪ06-ｨｨｨｪ030ｨｪ008ｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ03, ｨｮ0ｨｰ 09 ｨｰ06ｨｬ ﾂｨｨ ｨ 0ｨ ﾂｨｮ 06ｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ07 05ｨｺ ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨ 09ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 0708ｨｨ 0609ｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ09050ｨｪｨｨｨｨ 000ｨｪｨｪ06-ｨｨｨｪ030ｨｪ008ｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ (09ｨｰ. ) , ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪ0ｨｨ ｨｮ09ｨ 030ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ｨｺｨ, 0708ｨｨ04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 00ｨｪｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ 05ｨｨ ﾂｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｪ006ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｰ ｨ 09 ｨｨ ｨ 060 ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｨｨｰ0409ｨ 07 ｨｪ000609ｨｰｨ ｨｰ06 ﾂｨｪ06 ｨｨ04ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨ ｨｨ ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 ｨｨ 09060ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ09ｨｨ07 ｨｺ0506ｨｪｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨ ｨｨｨｪ07ｨｰ ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ04ｨｦ 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ 06ｨｰ 0 ｨｬｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｬ 04ｨ 07080ｨｰ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｺ0506ｨｪｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ 05ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨ ｨｬｨ ｨｮ050 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪｨ 06ｨｰｨｬ0 ﾂｨ 0ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ06 09 ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｰ06ｨｬ ｨｺｨｰｨｨ0904 ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨｨｬ006ｨｴｨｨ00907 ｨｨ 08ｨ 0408ｨ ｨ ｨ ｨｰ0409ｨ 0ｨｬ040 ｨｰ00ｨｪ ｨｨｨｦ ｨｺ0506ｨｪｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ04ｨｬ ｨｮ09ｨｬｨ ｨｰ08ｨｨ09ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｬ0603ｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ ｨｪｨｨ07 04ｨ 07080ｨｰｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｺ0506ｨｪｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 ﾂ ｨｺｨ ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｰｨｬ0ｨｪ ｨｬ0080 ｨｪｨ ｨｺ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ040 04ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｦ 09 0ｨ ｨｪｨｪ06ｨｦ 06ｨ 05ｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｬ0608ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040, 09060ｨｨｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ040 ｨｨ 05ｨｰｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ0 ｨｪ0608ｨｬ 0708ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨｨｨ ｨｰ00ｨｪ ｨｨｨｦ ｨｺ0506ｨｪｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07 ﾂ ｨｺｨ. 06ｨ ｨｺｨｨｨｬ 06ｨ 08ｨ 0406ｨｬ, 09 ｨｪｨ 09ｨｰ0607ｨｴ ｨｬ07 ｨｬ04 ｨｪｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ 080ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｬ ｨｪ ｨ 06 ｨｰ06ｨｬ, ﾂｨｰ ｨｪｨ 00ｨｮｨｪｨｺ0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 06ｨｺｨ ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｴ ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ060, ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ060 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ｨｦ 0ｨｨ09ｨｨ05ｨｨ04ｨ 0ｨｨｨｨ. 08ｨｮｨｪｨｺ0ｨｨｨｨ , ｨ 004 ｨｨ09ｨｺ0506 ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨ06 ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ ｨｺｨ. 0308ｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｬ 05ｨｰ ｨｦ09ｨｰ09ｨｨ ｨｺ ｨｪ06ｨｦ 09ｨｰ060806ｨｪ04, ｨｰ ｨｨ04ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｪ06 09ｨ 03ｨｪ060 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨ0 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ : ｨｺｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｮｨｺｨｨ, ｨ 0ｨｪｨｪ06 00ｨｮｨｪ0ｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｰｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ, ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ0609, 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ0 ｨｨ 06ｨ 0600ｨ ｨｴ0ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ0ｨｪ0ｨｨｨ 05ｨ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｮ0006ｨｦ ｪ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ0 0607ｨ 09ｨｪ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ060ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｰ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ060ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｰ ｨ 08ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 04ｨ ｨｺ06ｨｪ060ｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹ09ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｰ. 97.

9 ｨｰｨｨ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ0608ｨ ｨｨ09ｨｰ0ｨｺｨ 0ｨｰ 06ｨｰ ｨｪ0ｨｺ06ｨｪｨｰ080605ｨｨ08ｨｮ0ｨｬ ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｹ040609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｪｨ ｨｮ ﾂｨｪ06-ｨｰ00ｨｪｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨｨ ｨｰｨｨ030ｨｪｨｨｨｦ. 06ｨｰ ｨ 0ｨｪｨｪ06 ｨｺｨ 09ｨ 0ｨｰ ｨｪ040 ｨｰ00ｨｪ ｨｨｨｦ, 000ｨｪ0ｨｰｨｨｨｺｨｨ, ｨｬ00ｨｨ0ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｺ06ｨｦ ｨ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｰ ｨｰ06ｨｦ ｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ ｨｨ0ｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺｨ 07 ｨｪｨ ｨｮｨｺｨ ｨｪ0 ｨｬ06030ｨｰ 0609ｨｰｨ 09ｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｰ060806ｨｪ0 06ｨｰ 06ｨ 0604ｨｪｨ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 050ｨｬ. 0006ｨ 0060ｨｨｨｬ06 ｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 0905ｨｨ07ｨｪｨｨ07 ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ0609 ｨｪｨ 00ｨｮｨｪｨｺ0ｨｨｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｨ 0708ｨ ｨｮ05ｨｨ080609ｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｰ0907, ﾂｨｰ06 ｨｨｨｬ0ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 0906 ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ ｨｰ0907 ｨｰ0ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮｨｰｨ ｨｬｨｨ 06ｨ ｨｴ009ｨｰ09ｨ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｪ04 ｨｪ0 ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨｦ09ｨｰ090609ｨ ｨｰｨｹ 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨｰ0ｨｪ0ｨｨｨ 05ｨ, ｨｪ06 ｨｨ 04ｨ ｨｴｨｨｨｴｨ ｨｰｨｹ 06ｨｰ ｨｪ000ｨ ｨｰｨｨ09ｨｪ ｨｰ09ｨｨｨｦ 09ｨｪ00080ｨｪｨｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰ0609, 06ｨ ﾂｨｨ09ｨ ｨ ｨｪ0ｨｪｨｨ0 03ｨｨ04ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪｨ ﾂｨｨｨｬ0609ｨｰｨｹ 05ｨｰｨｨ0 ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ 09 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ0ｨｬ ﾂ ﾂ009ｨｰ09ｨ ｨ ｨｮ00ｨｰ ｨｰ0605ｨｹｨｺ ｨ 09ｨｰｨ ｨｰｨｹ ｨｮ ｨｰ0ｨｬ ｨｪ005ｨｹ ｨｺｨ 04ｨ ｨｰｨｹ, ﾂｨｰ ｨ ｨｮ0005ｨｨ05ｨｨ ｨｪ060 09ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 ｨｨ04ｨｮ ﾂ0ｨｪｨｨ06 05ｨｰ ｨｪｨ 0708ｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨ ｨｪｨ 09ｨｰ0607ｨｴ ｨｬ0ｨｪｨｨ 09 00ｨｪｨｰ080 09ｨｪｨｨｨｬｨ ｨｪｨｨ ｨｰｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｨｨｬｨｮｨｴ009ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ06 06ｨｰｨｪ06030ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨ ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮ05ｨｹｨｰｨ ｨｰｨ ｨｬｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨｮｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ06ｨｦ 0007ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｨ ｨｨ0 0008ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪ09ｨｺ ｨ ｨｰｨ, ｨｺ06ｨｰ ｨｪ0 ｨｨ09- ﾂ ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨ 050ｨｬｨｮ ｨｨ ｨｪ0 0ｨ 06ｨｰ ｨｪ ｨｰｨ 09050ｨｪｨｨ ｨｨ ｨｨｨｪｨｰ005050ｨｺｨｰｨ ｨｨｨｨ 0708ｨ 09ｨ ｨｨ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ09ｨ ｨｪ00609 * : , , ﾂ ｨ : ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪｨ ｨｨｨｰｨｨｨｺｨ, ｨｺ06ｨｪ09ｨｰｨｨｨｰｨｮ0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪ ｨ 0906, 0708ｨ ｨｪｨ ｨｪｨｨ0 0008ｨ 030ｨ ｨｪ, ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ040 ｨｨ ｨｬｨｮｨｪｨｨ0ｨｨ07ｨ 05ｨｹｨｪ ｨ ｨｪ ｨ 09ｨｰｨｨ, 0708ｨ 09ｨ ｨｨ ｨ ﾂ ｨｺｨ, ｨｨｨｪｨｰ00008ｨ 0ｨｨ07 ｨｪｨ ｨｮｨｺｨｨ ｨｨ 06ｨ 08ｨ ｨ ｨｪｨｨ07, ｨｨｨｪｨｪ0609ｨ 0ｨｨ06ｨｪｨｪｨ ｨｰ005ｨｹｨｪ0609ｨｰｨｹ, 05ｨｺ06ｨｪ06ｨｬｨｨ ﾂ009ｨｺ060 08ｨ 0409ｨｨｨｰｨｨ0. D.F. Vorontsov. State policy: concept, types, harmony of the right end justice, as if element solve a problems maket economy The absence of special constitutional and legal research of the State politics concept, of its kinds, elements, of the entities forming it and of the ways of its implementation are discussed in the article. ru] 000ｨｪ ｨｺｨ ﾂ ｪ78. *0ｨｨ080ｨｺｨｰ0608 ｨ ｨｨ04ｨｪ009-00ｨｪｨｰ08ｨ ｨｪ00309ｨｺ ｨｮ0ｨ 0809ｨｰ090ｨｪｨｪ ｨｮｨｪｨｨ ｨｨｨｰ0ｨｰｨ. [Pravouni@ mail.