橡9.PDF
|
|
- さなえ しげまつ
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 1 Lecture 9 The neutralist - selectionist controversy Looking back, I think that it is a curious human nature, that if a certain doctrine is constantly being spoken of favorably by the majority, endorsed by top authorities in their books and taught in classes, then a belief is gradually built up in one's mind, eventually becoming the guiding principle and the basis of value judgement. At any rate, this was the time when the panselectionist or 'neo-darwinian' position was most secure in the history of biology: the heyday of the traditional 'synthetic theory' of evolution. (p22) The neutral theory of molecular evolution by Motoo Kimura, Cambridge University Press, 1983, reprinted 1986 (paperback), 367 pages Contents: 1. From Lamarck to population genetics Overdevelopment of the synthetic theory and the proposal of the neutral theory The neutral mutation-random drift hypothesis as an evolutionary paradigm Molecular evolutionary rates contrasted with phenotypic evolutionary rates Some features of molecular evolution Definition, types and action of natural selection Molecular structure, selective constraint and the rate of evolution Population genetics at the molecular level Summary and conclusion References Kimura s work will show that a critique of Darwinism is possible, without being ridiculed or ignored by the scientific community. His Neutral Theory got a firm place in the standard textbooks on evolution and population-genetics, despite being clearly anti-selectionist. In the beginning orthodox Darwinists did not exactly like Kimura s theory, because he was telling the scientific community that all powerful Natural Selection was not so powerful after all. Natural selection had its limitations. On the molecular level the power of Natural Selection was greatly minimized, if not banished at all. Randomness took its place. Molecular variation in proteins and DNA was uncovered that had no influence on the fitness of the individual organism: in other words: is selectively neutral. On could even doubt if Natural Selection was of any importance in the traditional areas of morphology and anatomy. Why did Kimura find its place in evolution textbooks, unlike other anti-darwinists? The growing evidence supporting the Neutral Theory The Neutral Theory made a lasting contribution to population genetics theory Kimura built his theory on accepted knowledge in genetics and population genetics and at the same criticized it and extended it Kimura did not deny the existence of natural selection on morphological levels Kimura shows that critique of neo-darwinism can be incorporated into neo-darwinism if there is evidence and a good theory which contributes to the progress of science. Were neo-darwinists really opposed to neutralism around 1970? Consider Ernst Mayr s Populations, Species, and Evolution (1971). After summarizing the evidence for genetic drift ( King and Jukes(1969), Kimura(1969), Fitch and Margoliash(1970).), Mayr notes that a number of considerations largely deprive the evidence of its cogency: There are several other properties of populations that, when only superficially analyzed, appear to have no obvious selective advantage. However, the mere fact that such traits have become established makes it highly probable that they are the result of selection. More and more sites even in the largest molecules are found to have specific functions. A functionless site is simply one the function of which has not yet been determined. Available observations on allele polymorphism are not consistent with the neutrality theory.
2 2 A random replacement of amino acids unquestionably occurs occasionally in evolution, but it appears at present that it does not anywhere near approach selection in importance as an evolutionary factor. Chance causes disorder, selection causes order. It is clear from the first two points that Mayr treats function and natural selection virtually as an axiom. So neutralism is almost excluded by definition. The other points concern evidence. Much evidence has been produced since 1970, but in 1982 Mayr still concludes: My own feeling is that selection is far more important than admitted by the promoters of non-darwinian evolution, but that indeed there is a random component in much of the variation at some gene loci. So according to Mayr(1982) selection is still more important than neutral mutations or Random-Walk Evolution as he calls it. Notes. 1. This book is not available anymore from the publisher, but there is a collection of papers by Kimura: Population Genetics, Molecular Evolution, and the Neutral Theory: Selected Papers, University of Chicago Press, (The essays cover 40 years of Kimura's contributions to the understanding of how genetic variation affects evolutionary change). 2. There are 15 publications of Kimura listed in the bibliography of Hartl and Clark s Principles of Population Genetics(1997). 3. Second printing 1971, pages 117 and 127,128. This is the abridgement of Animal Species and Evolution,1963, Ernst Mayr: The Growth of Biological Thought. Diversity, Evolution and Inheritance., 1982, page 593. NEUTRALIST* SELECTIONIST ELECTROMORPHS / ALLOZYMES (ALLELES) ARE MOSTLY SELECTIVELY NEUTRAL TRAITS OF NO SELECTIVE OR PHENOTYPIC CONSEQUENCE This means that variation is irrelevant to a population's capacity to respond to new forces of selection. Genetic variants do not differ in fitness and do not constitute raw material for adaptation to new selective regimes. GENETIC DRIFT IS IMPORTANT IN DETERMINING FREQUENCIES OF NEUTRAL ALLELES AMONG GENERATIONS. This means sampling errors occur generation to generation because alternate alleles have identical (relatively neutral) fitnesses. Molecular evolution is mostly caused by drift. ALLELES HAVE PHENOTYPIC CONSEQUENCE S UPON WHICH SELECTION MAY ACT, EVEN IF EFFECTS ARE SMALL SELECTION IS IMPORTANT IN DETERMINING ALLELIC FREQUENCIES This means most evolution occurs via natural selection; selection is more important than drift in determining gene frequencies. VARIATION IS NEUTRAL VARIATION IS BENEFICIAL (Fisher's Fundamental Theorem of Natural Selection) The Neutral Theory In the 1960 s Kimura made the claim that most molecular evolution was the result of genetic drift, not selection. He based this assertion on four main observations that he felt could not be explained by natural selection, but could be explained by genetic drift of neutral mutations 1. The rate of evolution of proteins is too high, ~1 x 10-9 aa changes/aa/year 2. The rate is constant in different lineages 3. Different proteins, and different parts of the same protein, evolve at different rates with the least important evolving faster 4. The amount of heterozygosity and polymorphism is higher than would be predicted for directional selection If Kimura is correct then most changes at the molecular level are neutral and the rate of neutral mutations is high, if the selectionist are correct than most changes have a selective advantage and neutral mutations are rare The Rate is too High Haldane and the cost of selection also known as the substitutional load o The genetic load is the reduction in fitness caused by carrying deleterious alleles o If this effect is summed over the whole genome than there can only be a few such substitutions taking place at any
3 one time. 3 o Haldane calculated the top rate to be one substitution/300 generations Kimura estimated that at 3 x 10-9 aa changes/aa/year a new allele was being fixed every 2-3 years - 100x the rate Haldane had predicted o For the neutral theory the rate of evolution of neutral alleles is u, thus neutral mutation rates between 10-6 to 10-7 would explain the observed rate of mutation In addition, the neutral theory predicts the constant rate of evolution that is observed One problem - the rate should be constant over generations, not years (maybe the mutations are only slightly deleterious?) The Rate of Evolution is to Constant The molecular evolution rate is much more constant than the rate of morphological evolution Important Parts of Proteins (Active Sites, etc.) Evolve Slower than the less Important Parts Neutralist explanation: fewer neutral mutations in important areas Selectionist explanation: mutations in active sites are more likely to have a large effect, get fine tuning in less important areas o Kimura - while small s is more common they are also less likely to be fixed - cancels out Not true if the mutations can keep recurring Silent sites and pseudogenes evolve 5x faster than coding sequence o However, rates at silent sites do vary in different proteins o Also effected by codon bias The fact that there are mutations fixed at silent sites w/o a change in the protein suggest that the alleles are not identical by descent - uniformity is due to selection Silent sites do show a generation effect There is Too Much Heterozygosity The selectionist explanation for heterozygotes was heterozygous advantage Kimura showed that this could not be true because of the segregational load o In Drosophila 30% of loci are polymorphic and the ave. H is 10%, thus the polymorphic loci have an ave. H of.33 o If heterozygous advanatage is maintaining this than,for an average s of 0.1, the average fitness per loci is o If Drosophila has 10,000 genes than 3,000 will be polymorphic and the combined effect will reduce the average W to (1-(.33)(.1)) 300 = o This is ridiculous, therefore heterozygous advantage is not responsible for the observed heterozygosity For neutral mutations, u = 10-7 and N = 250,000 gives the 10% heterozygosty o The value for N seems too lo w (only 250,000 fruit flies?) and u seems to be too high - there should be more heterozygosity o Slightly deleterious mutations? The selectionist response o Kimura is confused about the difference between hard and soft selection hard selection increases the mortality in the population while soft selection only effects who is going to survive not how many
4 o Loci are not all independent 4 o Frequency dependent selection has no load Kimura was correct about heterozygous advantage not explaining the amount of observed heterozygosity. However, the connection between mutation rates and heterozygosity is still unclear Darwin Darwin 2 Fisher-Wright Fisher Mendel Wright Fisher Wright 2 1 Darwin Darwin A A Darwin Darwin Darwinian fitness
5 Darwin DNA
6 Hamilton H(q 1,...,q s ) Hilbert Hilbert Linear Operator dynamical state and property state Hamilton ultrafilter a map S t : X X (= a transformation of X into itself) (1) S 0 (x) = x, (2) S t (S t (x)) = S t+t (x) for t, t R. Markov 6
7 7 A a A a x y x y iff x y A a x x = {y y x} x A = {y & x A }, x a = {y y x & x a } x A x a = x A T(A) A a T(a) a A a x y iff x y AA Aa aa T(X) = X, X = AA X = Aa X = aa A a AA aa Coarse Graining (realization)
8 Gödel Leibniz (F)(Fx Fy) x = y x = y (F)(Fx Fy) x = y (F)(Fx Fy) x y iff x y x = {y y x} F( x ) Fy & x = y (F)(F( x ) F( y )) (intrinsic) (extrinsic) Ceteris paribus Ceteris Paribus Ceteris paribus
9 1 2 9 Ceteris paribus (special sciences) A. Ceteris paribus Ceteris paribus Ceteris paribus Ceteris paribus B. C. Ceteris paribus D. Ceteris paribus E : Rosenberg 2 :
10 One closed system Actual frequency Expected frequency Natural selection Drift Migration Fluctuation or deviation
11 1 Hardy -Weinberg Mendel A. B. Simpson C. 11
untitled
総研大文化科学研究第 6 号 (2010) 65 ... 66 佐貫 丘浅次郎の 進化論講話 における変化の構造 67 68 佐貫丘浅次郎の 進化論講話 における変化の構造 69 E 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 70 佐貫 丘浅次郎の 進化論講話 における変化の構造 71 72 佐貫丘浅次郎の 進化論講話 における変化の構造 73 74 佐貫丘浅次郎の 進化論講話
More informationJAPANESE SHIP-OWNERS AND WORLD BULK MARKET BETWEEN THE TWO WORLD WARS Mariko Tatsuki Keisen University After World War I, Japanese shipping suffered for a long time from an excess of tonnage and severe
More informationL1 What Can You Blood Type Tell Us? Part 1 Can you guess/ my blood type? Well,/ you re very serious person/ so/ I think/ your blood type is A. Wow!/ G
L1 What Can You Blood Type Tell Us? Part 1 Can you guess/ my blood type? 当ててみて / 私の血液型を Well,/ you re very serious person/ so/ I think/ your blood type is A. えーと / あなたはとっても真面目な人 / だから / 私は ~ と思います / あなたの血液型は
More information840 Geographical Review of Japan 73A-12 835-854 2000 The Mechanism of Household Reproduction in the Fishing Community on Oro Island Masakazu YAMAUCHI (Graduate Student, Tokyo University) This
More information鹿大広報149号
No.149 Feb/1999 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Learned From Japanese Life and Experiences in Kagoshima When I first came to Japan I was really surprised by almost everything, the weather,
More information2
2011 8 6 2011 5 7 [1] 1 2 i ii iii i 3 [2] 4 5 ii 6 7 iii 8 [3] 9 10 11 cf. Abstracts in English In terms of democracy, the patience and the kindness Tohoku people have shown will be dealt with as an exception.
More information4 8 6 1 1 4 8 2001, 3 2 Marshall [1890]1920, 240 19 1 2001 2008 1990 1997 2007 2 Marshall [1890]1920
8 2011. 3 199 213 D. H. D. H. 1877-1953 The Evolution of Industry 1911 1904 1908 1919 1922 45 1906 Industrial Combination 2009 20 4 8 6 1 1 4 8 2001, 3 2 Marshall [1890]1920, 240 19 1 2001 2008 1990 1997
More informationABSTRACT The "After War Phenomena" of the Japanese Literature after the War: Has It Really Come to an End? When we consider past theses concerning criticism and arguments about the theme of "Japanese Literature
More information\615L\625\761\621\745\615\750\617\743\623\6075\614\616\615\606.PS
osakikamijima HIGH SCHOOL REPORT Hello everyone! I hope you are enjoying spring and all of the fun activities that come with warmer weather! Similar to Judy, my time here on Osakikamijima is
More information,, 2024 2024 Web ,, ID ID. ID. ID. ID. must ID. ID. . ... BETWEENNo., - ESPNo. Works Impact of the Recruitment System of New Graduates as Temporary Staff on Transition from College to Work Naoyuki
More informationTitle 社 会 化 教 育 における 公 民 的 資 質 : 法 教 育 における 憲 法 的 価 値 原 理 ( fulltext ) Author(s) 中 平, 一 義 Citation 学 校 教 育 学 研 究 論 集 (21): 113-126 Issue Date 2010-03 URL http://hdl.handle.net/2309/107543 Publisher 東 京
More informationuntitled
() 2006 i Foundationpowdermakeup No.1 ii iii iv Research on selection criterion of cosmetics that use the consumer's Eras analysis Consideration change by bringing up child Fukuda Eri 1.Background, purpose,
More information-March N ~......... : National Statistical Office,n.d., Population & Housing Census Whole Kingdom National Statistical Office,, Population & Housing C
joint family : -March N ~......... : National Statistical Office,n.d., Population & Housing Census Whole Kingdom National Statistical Office,, Population & Housing Census Whole Kingdom National Statistical
More informationNO.80 2012.9.30 3
Fukuoka Women s University NO.80 2O12.9.30 CONTENTS 2 2 3 3 4 6 7 8 8 8 9 10 11 11 11 12 NO.80 2012.9.30 3 4 Fukuoka Women s University NO.80 2012.9.30 5 My Life in Japan Widchayapon SASISAKULPON (Ing)
More information;~ (Summary) The Study on the Effects of Foot Bathing on Urination Kumiko Toyoda School of Human Nursing, University of Shiga Prefecture Background Foot bathing is one of the important nursing care for
More informationThe Key Questions about Today's "Experience Loss": Focusing on Provision Issues Gerald ARGENTON These last years, the educational discourse has been focusing on the "experience loss" problem and its consequences.
More informationA comparison of abdominal versus vaginal hysterectomy for leiomyoma and adenomyosis Kenji ARAHORI, Hisasi KATAYAMA, Suminori NIOKA Department of Obstetrics and Gnecology, National Maizuru Hospital,Kyoto,
More informationR R S K K S K S K S K S K S Study of Samuhara Belief : Transformation from Protection against Injuries to Protection against Bullets WATANABE Kazuhiro Samuhara, which is a group of letters like unfamiliar
More informationAuthor Workshop 20111124 Henry Cavendish 1731-1810 Biot-Savart 26 (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) Priority Proceeding Impact factor Full paper impact factor Peter Drucker 1890-1971 1903-1989 Title) Abstract
More information[Abstactl Tennoh (Emperor), Courtiers, and Warriors MURAI Yasuhiko Tennoh (Emperor), courtiers, and the warriors have formed the ruling class of the Japanese society over a long history. In ancient history
More informationC. S2 X D. E.. (1) X S1 10 S2 X+S1 3 X+S S1S2 X+S1+S2 X S1 X+S S X+S2 X A. S1 2 a. b. c. d. e. 2
I. 200 2 II. ( 2001) 30 1992 Do X for S2 because S1(is not desirable) XS S2 A. S1 S2 B. S S2 S2 X 1 C. S2 X D. E.. (1) X 12 15 S1 10 S2 X+S1 3 X+S2 4 13 S1S2 X+S1+S2 X S1 X+S2. 2. 3.. S X+S2 X A. S1 2
More informationTitle 生活年令による学級の等質化に関する研究 (1) - 生活年令と学業成績について - Author(s) 与那嶺, 松助 ; 東江, 康治 Citation 研究集録 (5): 33-47 Issue Date 1961-12 URL http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12000/ Rights 46 STUDIES ON HOMOGENEOUS
More information先端社会研究 ★5★号/4.山崎
71 72 5 1 2005 7 8 47 14 2,379 2,440 1 2 3 2 73 4 3 1 4 1 5 1 5 8 3 2002 79 232 2 1999 249 265 74 5 3 5. 1 1 3. 1 1 2004 4. 1 23 2 75 52 5,000 2 500 250 250 125 3 1995 1998 76 5 1 2 1 100 2004 4 100 200
More information平成29年度英語力調査結果(中学3年生)の概要
1 2 3 1 そう思う 2 どちらかといえば そう思う 3 どちらかといえば そう思わない 4 そう思わない 4 5 楽しめるようになりたい 6 1 そう思う 2 どちらかといえば そう思う 3 どちらかといえば そう思わない 4 そう思わない 7 1 そう思う 2 どちらかといえば そう思う 3 どちらかといえば そう思わない 4 そう思わない 8 1 そう思う 2 どちらかといえば そう思う
More information1..FEM FEM 3. 4.
008 stress behavior at the joint of stringer to cross beam of the steel railway bridge 1115117 1..FEM FEM 3. 4. ABSTRACT 1. BackgroundPurpose The occurrence of fatigue crack is reported in the joint of
More information千葉県における温泉地の地域的展開
1) 1999 11 50 1948 23) 2 2519 9 3) 2006 4) 151 47 37 1.2 l 40 3.6 15 240 21 9.2 l 7. 210 1972 5) 1.9 l 5 1 0.2 l 6 1 1972 1.9 0.4 210 40-17- 292006 34 6 l/min.42 6) 2006 1 1 2006 42 60% 5060 4050 3040
More information„h‹¤.05.07
Japanese Civilian Control in the Cold War Era Takeo MIYAMOTO In European and American democratic countries, the predominance of politics over military, i.e. civilian control, has been assumed as an axiom.
More information10-渡部芳栄.indd
COE GCOE GP ) b a b ) () ) () () ) ) .. () ) ) ) ) () ........... / / /.... 交付税額 / 経常費 : 右軸交付税額 /( 経常費 授業料 ): 右軸 . ) ()... /.. 自治体負担額 / 交付税額 : 右軸 ()......... / 自治体負担額 / 経常費 : 右軸 - No. - Vol. No. - IDE
More informationOctober October October October Geoffrey M. White, White October Edward Relph,, Place and Placelessness, Pion limited October Geoffrey M. White,, National subjects September and Pearl Harbor, American
More informationOn the Wireless Beam of Short Electric Waves. (VII) (A New Electric Wave Projector.) By S. UDA, Member (Tohoku Imperial University.) Abstract. A new e
On the Wireless Beam of Short Electric Waves. (VII) (A New Electric Wave Projector.) By S. UDA, Member (Tohoku Imperial University.) Abstract. A new electric wave projector is proposed in this paper. The
More informationThe Effect of the Circumferential Temperature Change on the Change in the Strain Energy of Carbon Steel during the Rotatory Bending Fatigue Test by Ch
The Effect of the Circumferential Temperature Change on the Change in the Strain Energy of Carbon Steel during the Rotatory Bending Fatigue Test by Chikara MINAMISAWA, Nozomu AOKI (Department of Mechanical
More informationlagged behind social progress. During the wartime Chonaikai did cooperate with military activities. But it was not Chonaikai alone that cooperated. Al
The Development of Chonaikai in Tokyo before The Last War Hachiro Nakamura The urban neighborhood association in Japan called Chonaikai has been more often than not criticized by many social scientists.
More informationp _08森.qxd
Foster care is a system to provide a new home and family to an abused child or to a child with no parents. Most foster children are youngsters who could not deepen the sense of attachment and relationship
More informationA5 PDF.pwd
Kwansei Gakuin University Rep Title Author(s) 家 族 にとっての 労 働 法 制 のあり 方 : 子 どもにとっての 親 の 非 正 規 労 働 を 中 心 に Hasegawa, Junko, 長 谷 川, 淳 子 Citation 法 と 政 治, 65(3): 193(825)-236(868) Issue Date 2014-11-30 URL
More informationII
No. 19 January 19 2013 19 Regionalism at the 19 th National Assembly Elections Focusing on the Yeongnam and Honam Region Yasurou Mori As the biggest issue of contemporary politics at South Korea, there
More informationsoturon.dvi
12 Exploration Method of Various Routes with Genetic Algorithm 1010369 2001 2 5 ( Genetic Algorithm: GA ) GA 2 3 Dijkstra Dijkstra i Abstract Exploration Method of Various Routes with Genetic Algorithm
More informationPage 1 of 6 B (The World of Mathematics) November 20, 2006 Final Exam 2006 Division: ID#: Name: 1. p, q, r (Let p, q, r are propositions. ) (10pts) (a
Page 1 of 6 B (The World of Mathematics) November 0, 006 Final Exam 006 Division: ID#: Name: 1. p, q, r (Let p, q, r are propositions. ) (a) (Decide whether the following holds by completing the truth
More information16_.....E...._.I.v2006
55 1 18 Bull. Nara Univ. Educ., Vol. 55, No.1 (Cult. & Soc.), 2006 165 2002 * 18 Collaboration Between a School Athletic Club and a Community Sports Club A Case Study of SOLESTRELLA NARA 2002 Rie TAKAMURA
More information2 ( ) i
25 Study on Rating System in Multi-player Games with Imperfect Information 1165069 2014 2 28 2 ( ) i ii Abstract Study on Rating System in Multi-player Games with Imperfect Information Shigehiko MORITA
More informationSport and the Media: The Close Relationship between Sport and Broadcasting SUDO, Haruo1) Abstract This report tries to demonstrate the relationship be
Sport and the Media: The Close Relationship between Sport and Broadcasting SUDO, Haruo1) Abstract This report tries to demonstrate the relationship between broadcasting and sport (major sport and professional
More information220 28;29) 30 35) 26;27) % 8.0% 9 36) 8) 14) 37) O O 13 2 E S % % 2 6 1fl 2fl 3fl 3 4
Vol. 12 No. 2 2002 219 239 Λ1 Λ1 729 1 2 29 4 3 4 5 1) 2) 3) 4 6) 7 27) Λ1 701-0193 288 219 220 28;29) 30 35) 26;27) 0 6 7 12 13 18 59.9% 8.0% 9 36) 8) 14) 37) 1 1 1 13 6 7 O O 13 2 E S 1 1 17 0 6 1 585
More informationZ B- B- PHP - - [ ] PHP New York Times, December,,. The origins of the Japan-U.S. War and Adm. Isoroku Yamamoto Katsuhiko MATSUKAWA Abstract There are huge amount of studies concerning the origins
More informationuntitled
A Consideration on Studies of English Literature in Japan This paper attempts to formulate the significance of English literary studies in present-day Japan, and to carve out new horizons of them. First,
More information19 OUR EXPERIENCE IN COMBINED BALNEO AND CHRYSOTHERAPY FOR RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS by Hidemitsu EZAWA (Director: Prof. Hiroshi MORI NAG A), Department ofinternal Medicine, Institute for Thermal Spring Research,
More informationBull. of Nippon Sport Sci. Univ. 47 (1) Devising musical expression in teaching methods for elementary music An attempt at shared teaching
Bull. of Nippon Sport Sci. Univ. 47 (1) 45 70 2017 Devising musical expression in teaching methods for elementary music An attempt at shared teaching materials for singing and arrangements for piano accompaniment
More informationABSTRACT The Social Function of Boys' Secondary Schools in Modern Japan: From the Perspectives of Repeating and Withdrawal TERASAKI, Satomi (Graduate School, Ochanomizu University) 1-4-29-13-212, Miyamaedaira,
More informationAdams, B.N.,1979. "Mate selection in the United States:A theoretical summarization," in W.R.Burr et.al., eds., Contemporary Theories about the Family, Vol.1 Reserch - Based Theories, The Free Press, 259-265.
More informationA5 PDF.pwd
DV DV DV DV DV DV 67 1 2016 5 383 DV DV DV DV DV DV DV DV DV 384 67 1 2016 5 DV DV DV NPO DV NPO NPO 67 1 2016 5 385 DV DV DV 386 67 1 2016 5 DV DV DV DV DV WHO Edleson, J. L. 1999. The overlap between
More informationON A FEW INFLUENCES OF THE DENTAL CARIES IN THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL PUPIL BY Teruko KASAKURA, Naonobu IWAI, Sachio TAKADA Department of Hygiene, Nippon Dental College (Director: Prof. T. Niwa) The relationship
More information大学論集第42号本文.indb
42 2010 2011 3 279 295 COSO 281 COSO 1990 1 internal control 1 19962007, Internal Control Integrated Framework COSO COSO 282 42 2 2) the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway committee
More information井手友里子.indd
I goal of movement Banno 1999 60 61 65 12 2006 1978 1979 2005 1 2004 8 7 10 2005 54 66 Around 40 Around 40 2008 4 6 45 11 2007 4 6 45 9 2 Around 40 A 30A B 30 K C 30 P D 30 S 50 2007 2004 1979 2005 100
More informationSPSS
The aging of residents who moved suburban new town in young is progressing. However, such residents tend to consider the service life of their houses only in terms of the time they will be occupying it.
More informationSafety Performance of Steel Deck Plate (Flat Decks) Used for Concrete Slab Moulding CONTENTS 1. Introduction ---------------------------------------------------------------- (2) 2. Flat Decks ------------------------------------------------------------------
More information外国語科 ( 英語 Ⅱ) 学習指導案 A TOUR OF THE BRAIN ( 高等学校第 2 学年 ) 神奈川県立総合教育センター 平成 20 年度研究指定校共同研究事業 ( 高等学校 ) 授業改善の組織的な取組に向けて 平成 21 年 3 月 平成 20 年度研究指定校である光陵高等学校において 授業改善に向けた組織的な取組として授業実践を行った学習指導案です 生徒主体の活動を多く取り入れ 生徒の学習活動に変化をもたせるとともに
More information人文地理62巻4号
4 4 4 4 4 4 An Examination of the Agglomeration Economies Reinforcing Creativity in the Cultural Industry HANZAWA Seiji Meiji Gakuin University The recent rise of the cultural industry, resulting
More information総研大文化科学研究第 11 号 (2015)
栄 元 総研大文化科学研究第 11 号 (2015) 45 ..... 46 総研大文化科学研究第 11 号 (2015) 栄 租借地都市大連における 満洲日日新聞 の役割に関する一考察 総研大文化科学研究第 11 号 (2015) 47 48 総研大文化科学研究第 11 号 (2015) 栄 租借地都市大連における 満洲日日新聞 の役割に関する一考察 総研大文化科学研究第 11 号 (2015)
More informationVol.57 No
Title 合併と企業統治 : 大正期東洋紡と大日本紡の比較 Author(s) 川井, 充 Citation 大阪大学経済学. 57(3) P.38-P.72 Issue 2007-12 Date Text Version publisher URL http://hdl.handle.net/11094/17848 DOI Rights Osaka University Vol.57 No.3
More informationCain & Abel
Cain & Abel: False Religion vs. The Gospel Now Adam knew Eve his wife, and she conceived and bore Cain, saying, I have gotten a man with the help of the LORD. And again, she bore his brother Abel. Now
More information24 Depth scaling of binocular stereopsis by observer s own movements
24 Depth scaling of binocular stereopsis by observer s own movements 1130313 2013 3 1 3D 3D 3D 2 2 i Abstract Depth scaling of binocular stereopsis by observer s own movements It will become more usual
More information外国文学論集14号.indd
1876 1880 1 1930 1 1868 1930 1931 1945 1945 1989 1990 1868 1930 1930 1945 1945 1969 1970 1989 1990 1900 1901 1920 1946 1969 35 29 8.3 0.4 1908 1945 24 1951 1970 1931 1945 1951 5.6 27 0.8 1969 0.2 1910
More informationA Nutritional Study of Anemia in Pregnancy Hematologic Characteristics in Pregnancy (Part 1) Keizo Shiraki, Fumiko Hisaoka Department of Nutrition, Sc
A Nutritional Study of Anemia in Pregnancy Hematologic Characteristics in Pregnancy (Part 1) Keizo Shiraki, Fumiko Hisaoka Department of Nutrition, School of Medicine, Tokushima University, Tokushima Fetal
More informationJOURNAL OF THE JAPANESE ASSOCIATION FOR PETROLEUM TECHNOLOGY VOL. 66, NO. 6 (Nov., 2001) (Received August 10, 2001; accepted November 9, 2001) Alterna
JOURNAL OF THE JAPANESE ASSOCIATION FOR PETROLEUM TECHNOLOGY VOL. 66, NO. 6 (Nov., 2001) (Received August 10, 2001; accepted November 9, 2001) Alternative approach using the Monte Carlo simulation to evaluate
More information2015 8 65 87. J. Osaka Aoyama University. 2015, vol. 8, 65-87. 20 * Recollections of the Pacific War in the eyes of a school kid Hisao NAGAOKA Osaka Aoyama Gakuen Summary Seventy years have passed since
More information自分の天職をつかめ
Hiroshi Kawasaki / / 13 4 10 18 35 50 600 4 350 400 074 2011 autumn / No.389 5 5 I 1 4 1 11 90 20 22 22 352 325 27 81 9 3 7 370 2 400 377 23 83 12 3 2 410 3 415 391 24 82 9 3 6 470 4 389 362 27 78 9 5
More information{.w._.p7_.....\.. (Page 6)
1 1 2 1 2 3 3 1 1 8000 75007000 4 2 1493 1 15 26 5 6 2 3 5 7 17 8 1614 4 9 7000 2 5 1 1542 10 11 1592 12 1614 1596 1614 13 15691615 16 16 14 15 6 2 16 1697 17 7 1811 18 19 20 1820 21 1697 22 1 8 23 3 100
More information九州大学学術情報リポジトリ Kyushu University Institutional Repository 看護師の勤務体制による睡眠実態についての調査 岩下, 智香九州大学医学部保健学科看護学専攻 出版情報 : 九州大学医学部保健学
九州大学学術情報リポジトリ Kyushu University Institutional Repository 看護師の勤務体制による睡眠実態についての調査 岩下, 智香九州大学医学部保健学科看護学専攻 https://doi.org/10.15017/4055 出版情報 : 九州大学医学部保健学科紀要. 8, pp.59-68, 2007-03-12. 九州大学医学部保健学科バージョン : 権利関係
More information03Ÿ_-“L’£
G H 1913 35 2 2006 1903 1904 1916 1905 1908 Mrs. Louisa Nistrom Hamilton 1989 65-66 1906 1995 1911 9 1912 12 36 1913 1 1914 12 1913. 1 1920 1 7 1913 1 1911 Havelock Ellis 3 4 1914 1 1915 10 1913 5 1915
More informationAn Aspect of Development in Clothing Education in Japan (Part 2) The Method of Teaching Sewing in the Meiji Era ( 2 ) Tetsuko HIGUCHI 1. Following Part 1, here I have analyzed and discussed some characteristic
More information;-~-: からなだらかな水深 15-20 ~mmature 及び乙の水域で量的に少ない種は, 各混群内の個体数の 20~ ぢ以下の乙とが多かった また, ある混群で多 全長 11-15cm のクラスは, 全長 16-30cm のクラスと重複するが, 全長 31cm~ のクラスとは重複しなかっ T~ta!_~equ_ency + ヱ n~ 120 SUMMARY 1) The
More informationI II
: 21 2013 1 6 ACF 5 4 2013 2 4 1 2 3 4 4 3 4 2 3 1 2 3 8 15 3 4 5 6 22 23 2016 6 7 8 9 I 1. 2013 3 3 2. 2014 2015 2014 22 2015 28 1 2014 II 1. 1 5 10 5 31 7 5 8 21 23 2 3 2014 10 18 11 15 2015 5 16 6 27
More information(2001)(2001)(2001)(2001)(2001)
No.42 2007 pp.27 38 Redevelopment in Surrounding Railway Stations and Change of Urban Structure Mainly with Reutilization of the Sites where Factories were Located Yukio NAGANO Received September 30, 2006
More information浜松医科大学紀要
On the Statistical Bias Found in the Horse Racing Data (1) Akio NODA Mathematics Abstract: The purpose of the present paper is to report what type of statistical bias the author has found in the horse
More information1 ( 8:12) Eccles. 1:8 2 2
1 http://www.hyuki.com/imit/ 1 1 ( 8:12) Eccles. 1:8 2 2 3 He to whom it becomes everything, who traces all things to it and who sees all things in it, may ease his heart and remain at peace with God.
More information地域共同体を基盤とした渇水管理システムの持続可能性
I 1994 1994 1994 1,176 1,377 1995, p.21; 1999 Kazuki Kagohashi / 10 1 1 1991 drought water bank 2013 466-8673 18 E-mail:kagohashi@gmail.com 1 355 10 2 Kondo 2013 136 2015 spring / No.403 2 1 1994 1995,
More information[Abstract] Rituals of the Tokugawa Shogunate and Confucianism WATANABE Hiroshi The University of Tokyo According to Confucianists, "Li" means proper patterns of behaviour of civilized people, such as manners,
More informationThe Indirect Support to Faculty Advisers of die Individual Learning Support System for Underachieving Student The Indirect Support to Faculty Advisers of the Individual Learning Support System for Underachieving
More informationuntitled
Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism IATA 996 9 96 96 1180 11 11 80 80 27231 27 27231 231 H19.12.5 10 200612 20076 200710 20076 20086 11 20061192008630 12 20088 20045 13 113 20084
More informationTitle < 論文 > 公立学校における在日韓国 朝鮮人教育の位置に関する社会学的考察 : 大阪と京都における 民族学級 の事例から Author(s) 金, 兌恩 Citation 京都社会学年報 : KJS = Kyoto journal of so 14: 21-41 Issue Date 2006-12-25 URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/192679 Right
More informationTitle 泌尿器科領域に於ける17-Ketosteroidの研究 17-Ketosteroidの臨床的研究 第 III 篇 : 尿 Author(s) 卜部, 敏入 Citation 泌尿器科紀要 (1958), 4(1): 3-31 Issue Date URL
Title 泌尿器科領域に於ける17-Ketosteroidの研究 17-Ketosteroidの臨床的研究 第 III 篇 : 尿 Author(s) 卜部, 敏入 Citation 泌尿器科紀要 (1958), 4(1): 3-31 Issue Date 1958-01 URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/111559 Right Type Departmental Bulletin
More informationWebster's New World Dictionary of the American Language, College Edition. N. Y. : The World Publishing Co., 1966. [WNWD) Webster 's Third New International Dictionary of the English Language-Unabridged.
More informationHousing Purchase by Single Women in Tokyo Yoshilehl YUI* Recently some single women purchase their houses and the number of houses owned by single women are increasing in Tokyo. And their housing demands
More informationMotivation and Purpose There is no definition about whether seatbelt anchorage should be fixed or not. We tested the same test conditions except for t
Review of Seatbelt Anchorage and Dimensions of Test Bench Seat Cushion JASIC Motivation and Purpose There is no definition about whether seatbelt anchorage should be fixed or not. We tested the same test
More information005 1571 1630 17 1546 1601 16 1642 1727
I Takamitsu Sawa / 1561~1626 004 2010 / No.384 005 1571 1630 17 1546 1601 16 1642 1727 006 2010 / No.384 confirm refute verify significant 1902 1994 piecemeal engineering 1958 historicism 20 007 1990 90
More informationLevel 3 Japanese (90570) 2011
90570 905700 3SUPERVISOR S Level 3 Japanese, 2011 90570 Listen to and understand complex spoken Japanese in less familiar contexts 2.00 pm riday Friday 1 November 2011 Credits: Six Check that the National
More information在日外国人高齢者福祉給付金制度の創設とその課題
Establishment and Challenges of the Welfare Benefits System for Elderly Foreign Residents In the Case of Higashihiroshima City Naoe KAWAMOTO Graduate School of Integrated Arts and Sciences, Hiroshima University
More informationALT : Hello. May I help you? Student : Yes, please. I m looking for a white T-shirt. ALT : How about this one? Student : Well, this size is good. But do you have a cheaper one? ALT : All right. How about
More information,
, The Big Change of Life Insurance Companies in Japan Hisayoshi TAKEDA Although the most important role of the life insurance system is to secure economic life of the insureds and their
More informationWASEDA RILAS JOURNAL
27 200 WASEDA RILAS JOURNAL NO. 1 (2013. 10) WASEDA RILAS JOURNAL 28 199 29 198 WASEDA RILAS JOURNAL 30 197 31 196 WASEDA RILAS JOURNAL 32 195 1 3 12 6 23 No 1 3 0 13 3 4 3 2 7 0 5 1 6 6 3 12 0 47 23 12
More information123-099_Y05…X…`…‘…“†[…h…•
1. 2 1993 2001 2 1 2 1 2 1 99 2009. 1982 250 251 1991 112 115 1988 75 2004 132 2006 73 3 100 3 4 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.. 3.1 1991 2002 2004 3 4 101 2009 3 4 4 5 1 5 6 1 102 5 6 3.2 2 7 8 2 X Y Z Z X 103 2009
More information山陰研究横組み/論文廣嶋
p b b y b y y a p y y y y y b b b b RYOMA EAP B p p p p p p a Word, PDF EAPRYOMA IWAMI xls y a p No C a b Migration and employment in late Edo period in Iwami Silver Mine Territory
More information44 2012 2013 3 35 48 法人化後の国立大学の収入変動 37 法人化後の国立大学の収入変動 2009 2005 2010 2012 2012 2008 2009a 2010 16 18 17 20 2 4 2012 38 44 2012 17 22 (1) (2) 2012 5 GP COE 30 WPI 1 2012 17 22 16 17 22 17 17 19 2012 2012
More informationñ{ï 01-65
191252005.2 19 *1 *2 *3 19562000 45 10 10 Abstract A review of annual change in leading rice varieties for the 45 years between 1956 and 2000 in Japan yielded 10 leading varieties of non-glutinous lowland
More informationuntitled
SUMMARY Although the situation where sufficient food was not supplied for the victims occurred in the Great East Japan Earthquake, this is a serious problem at the time of catastrophic disasters like the
More information(43) Vol.33, No.6(1977) T-239 MUTUAL DIFFUSION AND CHANGE OF THE FINE STRUCTURE OF WET SPUN ANTI-PILLING ACRYLIC FIBER DURING COAGULATION, DRAWING AND
(43) Vol.33, No.6(1977) T-239 MUTUAL DIFFUSION AND CHANGE OF THE FINE STRUCTURE OF WET SPUN ANTI-PILLING ACRYLIC FIBER DURING COAGULATION, DRAWING AND DRYING PROCESSES* By Hiroshi Aotani, Katsumi Yamazaki
More informationOda
No.53 pp.2334, 2017 Komazawa Journal of Geography Distribution of Christianity and the Division of the Region in Prewar Japan ODA Masayasu Oda1999 1. 18991939 1 2. 18991939 1918 3. 190019391939 4. 5. 6.
More informationSecurity of Leasehold Interest -in cases of the False Housing Registries by Other Than the Lessee by Shin ISHIKAWA The House Protection Act 1909 in Japan, under which many lessees can be protected from
More information32 東和知財研究第 5 巻第 2 号 ( 通巻第 7 号 ) Journal of Towa Institute of Intellectual Property Vol.5, No.1 33 発明の単一性の要件 シフト補正の制限の審査基準改訂のご紹介 東和国際特許事務所 加藤 弁理士 2013
32 東和知財研究第 5 巻第 2 号 ( 通巻第 7 号 ) Journal of Towa Institute of Intellectual Property Vol.5, No.1 33 発明の単一性の要件 シフト補正の制限の審査基準改訂のご紹介 東和国際特許事務所 加藤 弁理士 2013 年 7 月 1 日以降の日本の審査では 2007 年 4 月 1 日以降の出願について 審査基準が改訂され
More information0
Speedy & Simple Kenji, Yoshio, and Goro are good at English. They have their ways of learning. Kenji often listens to English songs and tries to remember all the words. Yoshio reads one English book every
More informationVisual Evaluation of Polka-dot Patterns Yoojin LEE and Nobuko NARUSE * Granduate School of Bunka Women's University, and * Faculty of Fashion Science,
Visual Evaluation of Polka-dot Patterns Yoojin LEE and Nobuko NARUSE * Granduate School of Bunka Women's University, and * Faculty of Fashion Science, Bunka Women's University, Shibuya-ku, Tokyo 151-8523
More information<96DA8E9F82D982A95F944E95F1906C8AD489C88A775F33332E696E6464>
33 27-42 2012 27 4 4 4 1 4 4 4 4 1993:6 1910 1920 1993 1) 28 1987; 2004 2000; 2001 1997; 2000Heath and Cleaver 2003; 2008; 2009a DINKS 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
More information