Microsoft Word - PowerEdge_M-Series_Competitive_Power_Study_-_August_2010[1]_j.docx

Transcription

1 : John Beckett Robert Bradfield

2 2010 Dell Inc All rights reserved. Dell DELL DELL PowerEdge Dell Inc. Microsoft Windows Windows Server Microsoft Corporation SPEC SPECpower_ssj Standard Performance Evaluation Corporation (SPEC) HP IBM SPECpower_ssj Dell Inc. Dell

3 (ssj_ops/watt) A SPECpower_ssj BIOS OS SPECpower_ssj B C D E SPECpower_ssj Dell M1000e / 16 PowerEdge M HP BladeSystem c7000 / 16 ProLiant BL460c G IBM BladeCenter 8852 H / 14 BladeCenter HS

4 4

5 Dell Inc. ( ) SPECpower_ssj2008 HP IBM 3 1 RAM 16 M610 Dell M1000e 14 HS22 IBM BladeCenter H 16 BL460C G6 Hewlett-Packard C7000 Dell M 電力 16 M610 Dell M1000e ( ) 16 BL460C G6 HP C HS22 IBM BladeCenter H ( 4) CPU (40 60%) 16 BL460C G6 HP C M610 Dell M1000e 13 17% 14 HS22 IBM BladeCenter H 19 20% ( 4) 14 HS22 IBM BladeCenter H 16 M610 Dell M1000e 2 63% ( 2) 16 BL460C G6 HP C M610 Dell M1000e 24% CPU 100% 13% ( 2 3) IBM HS22 Dell PowerEdge M610 87% ( 7) CPU 100% IBM HS22 Dell PowerEdge M % ( 7) 1 IDC Worldwide Quarterly Server Tracker

6 パフォーマンス 16 M610 Dell M1000e 16 BL460C G6 HP C HS22 IBM BladeCenter H ( 5) CPU 100% 16 M610 Dell M1000e 14 HS22 IBM BladeCenter H 13.9% ( 6) 16 M610 Dell M1000e 16 BL460C G6 HP C % 14 HS22 IBM BladeCenter H 22% ( 8) Standard Performance Evaluation Corp. (SPEC) SPECpower_ssj2008 A B D E 1 3 SPECpower_ssj2008 (2,530 ssj_ops/watt) HP (2,197 ssj_ops/watt) 15% IBM (2,068 ssj_ops/watt) 22% IBM 14 IBM HP HP 6

7 1. 7

8 SPECpower_ssj Dell PowerEdge M610 HP 24.1% 14 IBM HS % 1, HP ProLiant BL460c 1, IBM HS22 2,

9 SPECpower_ssj % 3 100% 16 Dell PowerEdge M610 HP 11.5% HS22 14 IBM BladeCenter H 1.6% 100% 4, HP ProLiant BL460c 4, IBM HS22 4,444 (IBM HP 2 ) % 9

10 4 SPECpower_ssj2008 ( ) 100% 10% 10% 16 Dell PowerEdge M610 SPECpower_ssj HP ProLiant BL460c G6 14 IBM HS22 HP (60% 100%) HP 13% 18% IBM 1.6% 5.4% SPECpower_ssj2008 (50% 10%) HP 11.8% 14.2% IBM 4.2% 11.6% 4. 10

11 5 (%) ( ) 16 HP ProLiant BL460c G6 100% 16 Dell PowerEdge M610 HP 14 IBM BladeCenter HS22 14% IBM 5. 11

12 SPECpower_ssj % 6 16 Hewlett-Packard BL460c HP Dell PowerEdge M 100% 14 IBM HS % 100% 16 Dell PowerEdge M610 14,785,342 ssj_ops 16 HP ProLiant BL460c 14,774,218 ssj_ops 14 IBM HS22 12,979,356 ssj_ops % HP 16 IBM 14 1 SPECpower HP IBM IBM IBM 1 87% (1 ) 81W IBM 151W HP 24.1% HP 100W 81W 12

13 100% 1 IBM 16.2% (1 ) 273W IBM 317W 100% HP 309W (273W) 13% ( 7) 7. 13

14 SPECpower_ssj ( ) 100% (ssj_ops) 100% 10% (5 ) ( ssj_ops) SPEcpower_ssj2008 SPECpower_ssj2008 ssj_ops/watt 8 HP IBM ssj_ops/watt 8. ssj_ops/watt 14

15 1 Dell PowerEdge SPECpower_ssj SPECpower_ssj2008 Dell PowerEdge M610 ( 16 ) ssj_ops (W) 100% 99.70% 14,785,342 4,372 3,382 90% 90.00% 13,344,934 3,987 3,347 80% 79.90% 11,853,404 3,646 3,251 70% 70.00% 10,380,753 3,359 3,090 60% 60.00% 8,903,133 3,104 2,868 50% 50.00% 7,412,879 2,900 2,556 40% 40.00% 5,928,182 2,692 2,203 30% 30.00% 4,444,109 2,496 1,781 20% 20.00% 2,971,405 2,301 1,292 10% 10.00% 1,481,894 2, ,288 0 ssj_ops / power = 2,530 15

16 2 HP SPECpower_ssj2008 ( ssj_ops ) HP SPECpower_ssj2008 HP ( 16 ) ssj_ops (W) 100% 99.60% 14,774,218 4,940 2,991 90% 90.00% 13,338,325 4,608 2,895 80% 80.00% 11,858,862 4,306 2,754 70% 70.00% 10,377,087 3,977 2,609 60% 60.00% 8,895,651 3,630 2,451 50% 50.00% 7,420,425 3,313 2,240 40% 39.90% 5,922,357 3,038 1,949 30% 30.00% 4,452,479 2,801 1,589 20% 20.00% 2,971,369 2,574 1,154 10% 10.00% 1,479,418 2, ,598 0 ssj_ops / power = 2,197 16

17 3 IBM SPECpower_ssj IBM SPECpower_ssj2008 IBM (14 ) ssj_ops (W) 100% 99.60% 12,979,356 4,444 2,921 90% 89.90% 11,716,988 4,141 2,829 80% 80.10% 10,429,739 3,865 2,698 70% 70.10% 9,128,012 3,566 2,559 60% 60.00% 7,820,687 3,273 2,390 50% 50.00% 6,516,261 3,021 2,157 40% 39.90% 5,202,062 2,813 1,850 30% 30.00% 3,905,546 2,634 1,483 20% 20.00% 2,604,026 2,462 1,058 10% 10.00% 1,302,857 2, ,107 0 ssj_ops / power = 2,068 17

18 Standard Performance Evaluation Corp. (SPEC) SPECpower_ssj2008 SPECpower_ssj2008 Server Side Java (SSJ) SPECpower_ssj2008 ( ssj_ops/watt) 1 SSJ ( ssj_ops) ( W) SPEC (ssj2008 ) SPEcpower_ssj2008 SPECpower_ssj Server Side Java (SSJ) (OS Java ) Java (PTDaemon) (CCS) Java SPECpower_ssj008 SPEC Compliant Runs ( ) SPEC A D E 2 RAID 1 (HP RAID 1 +0) Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise B Dell 3 SPECpower_ssj ssj_ops/watt 18

19 4 4. HP IBM PowerEdge M1000e BladeSystem c7000 BladeCenter H- M610 BL460c HS ( ) CPU Xeon X GHz x 2 Xeon X GHz x 2 Xeon X GHz x 2 4GB 1333MHz DDR3 x 6 4GB 1333MHz DDR3 x 6 4GB 1333MHz DDR3 x 6 HDD 73GB 15,000 RPM SAS x 2 73GB 15,000 RPM SAS x 2 73GB 15,000 RPM SAS x 2 Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise Java IBM J IBM J IBM J AC Redundancy (AC ) DPSE (Dynamic Power Supply Engagement ) Dell PowerEdge M1000e Power Redundancy ( ) AC Redundancy DPSE HP c7000 AC Redundancy Dynamic Power ( ) ( ) 2 IBM BladeCenter H HP Power Management ( ) Basic ( ) Redundant Power Management ( ) BIOS SPECpower_ssj Turbo Mode ( ) Turbo BIOS Processor Prefetcher ( ) SPECpower_ssj2008 Java Dell PowerEdge M610 Turbo Mode Prefetcher Hardware Prefetcher ( ) Adjacent Cache Line Prefetcher ( ) DCU Prefetcher Data Reuse ( ) Power Management (Dell Active Power Controller) 2 Dynamic Power SPECpower_ssj2008 results 19

20 HP ProLiant BL460c G6 HP Dynamic Power Regulator ( ) Slow (HP ) BIOS Hardware Prefetcher Adjacent Cache Line Prefetcher Xeon BIOS ( DCU Prefetch Data Reuse ) BIOS HP 3 HP Support Communication Customer Advisory Document ID: c version 2 conrep IBM BladeCenter HS22 BIOS 2 Processor Prefetcher ( Cache Data Prefetch Data Reuse ) Processor C-States ( C ) HP IBM C ( ) SPECpower_ssj2008 [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] [ ] Java Administrator [ ] [ ] 1 IBM BladeCenter HS22 Dell Active Power Controller ( ) HP Dynamic Power Saver BIOS 5% 0% 75% 100% Xeon 5600 IBM SPECpower SPECpower_ssj2008 ( CCS PTDaemon ) IP 24 JVM SPECpower_ssj2008 IBM J9 Java Virtual Machine (JVM) 4 3 IBM J9 JVM SPECpower_ssj2008 JVM -Xmn1400m -Xms1875m -Xmx1875m -Xaggressive -Xcompressedrefs -Xgcpolicy:gencon -XlockReservation -Xnoloa Xlp 6 JVM 4 start /affinity [F,F0,F00,F000,F0000,F00000] JVM build 2.4, J2RE IBM J9 2.4 Windows Server 2008 amd64-64 jvmwa64 60sr _

21 SPECpower_ssj2008 WT210 2 WT210 1 WT210 1 (PDU) PDU 3 WT210/PDU 208v ( 9) 9. 21

22 HP 2 WT210 1 WT210 1 (PDU) PDU 3 WT210/PDU 208v ( 10) 10. HP 22

23 IBM IBM 3 2 NEMA C20 HP PDU PDU 2 3 PDU 3 WT210 IBM PSU 1,2 2 PSU 3,4 3 Blower (PSU Blower ) PSU 1,2 2 PSU 1,2 1 WT210/PDU Blower 2 WT210/PDU PSU PSU WT210/PDU WT210/PDU 208v 5 ( 11) 11. IBM 5 1,2 3,4 1 WT210/PDU Blower 2 WT210/PDU 2 1,2 3,4 3 WT210/PDU SPECpower ( PDU ) 23

24 5. Dell PowerEdge M1000e HP BladeSystem c7000 IBM BladeCenter H mm 442mm 400mm 447mm 445mm 445mm 754mm 813mm 735mm 10 U 10 U 9 U CMC ( 32) Onboard Administrator 3.00 Advanced Module Management 3.54G ,700 2,450 2,900 G803N B SU 9 10 x 2 I/O Dell 16 x 2 HP 16 x 2 IBM 14 x 2 24

25 6. Dell PowerEdge M610 HP ProLiant BL460c G6 IBM HS HU RAM (GB) Samsung M393B5170FHD-CH9 Micron MT36JSZF51272PY-1G4D1AB Samsung M392B5170EM1-CH9 PC R PC R PC R (MHz) / CAS 9 CAS 9 CAS 9 RAM 4 GB x 6 4 GB x 6 4 GB x 6 Hitachi HUC151473CSS600 Seagate ST973452SS Seagate ST973452SS (GB) (MB) (RPM) 15,000 15,000 15,000 SAS 6 Gbps SAS SAS 6 Gbps RAID RAID 1 RAID RAID 1 PERC H200 SmartArray P410i LSI SAS StorPort 1064E Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise Microsoft Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise NTFS NTFS NTFS Broadcom BCM5709S NetXtreme II Broadcom GbE Broadcom BCM5709S NetXtreme II 25

26 7. Dell PowerEdge M610 HP ProLiant BL460c G6 IBM HS HU / c A HBA A HBA A HDD A

27 SPEC SPECpower_ssj

28 28

29 29

30 30

31 31

32 32

33 33

34 34

35 35

36 36

37 37

38 38

39 39

40 40

41 41

42 42

43 43

44 44

45 45

46 46

47 47