2006 11 5 *1 *2 *3 *4 *5 1 1 2 3 eguchi@kyoto-wu.ac.jp *1 J.S. 3 *2 *3 (2001) (2004) *4 (2003) *5 1
1.1 (1) (2) (3) (4) (Bentham, 1970, Chap. III) * 6 art of legislation ethics private ethics (Bentham, 1970, Chap. XV) 1.2 (1) (2) *7 (3) (4) (Bentham, 1970, Chap. XIII) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 *8 (Bentham, 1970, p. *6 (1967) 11 *7 *8 variablity equability commensurability charactericalness examplarity frugality subseviency to reformation efficacy with respect to disablement subseviency to compensation popularity remissibility 2
185) J. S. *9 1.3 * 10 * 11 (example) gratis (Bentham, 1970, Chap. XIII, Sec. 1, note1) 13 displeasure (Bentham, 1970, p. 164) 5 *9 (Mill, 1984) Mill (1979) *10 Ten (1991) Bedau (Fall 2005) *11 3
(, 1967, p. 515-6)(Mill, 1969, p 249-50) * 12 lex talionis (, 1967, p. 521)(Mill, 1969, p.253) * 13 1.4 * 14 1770 (Bentham, 1830) * 15 1 2 3 4 1 2 3 *12 (1967) (1988) *13 (2003) *14 (1959) *15 1811 4
4 (, 2003; Bedau, 1983;, 2000) terrorum (Bentham, 1830, Book II, Chap. XII, Sec. III) * 16 J. S. 1868 4 (Mill, 1988) (Mill, 1969, p.253)(, 1967, p.521) *16 5
(, 1967, pp. 521-522) 1.5 19 20 * 17 * 18 * 19 20 1 2 3 (, 2000, ) 1970 70 Nothing works R. J. *17 (1997) (2002) *18 *19 (, 2000) 6
(, 2006, p. 575) 1994 * 20 1990 * 21 * 22 2 2.1 (, 1997) * 23 (, 2006, p. 129) immoral amoral *20 *21 10 20 (2003) 90 *22 (, 2003) *23 (2000) (1998) (2003) (2002) (2005) 7
* 24 2.2 * 25 2003 2005 (, 2003) (, 2003, p. 21) (, 2003, p.17) (, 2003, p. 19) (, 2003, p.20) *24 *25 8
(, 2005, p.246) (, 2005, p. 250) R. M. (, 1982, p. 170 ) (, 1982, p. 170)(Hare, 1963, pp. 115-6) 9
5 * 26 2.3 * 27 (, 2000)(, 2004) (, 1999) (Buss, 2005) (, 2006) (2005) 3 *26 (, 1988, p. 202) *27 Tooby and Cosmides (1992) 1920 (Standard Social Science Model 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. (, 2000, ) 10
* 28 * 29 (, 2005, p. 426) * 30, C. R. A. M. (2006) (1959) 1764 Bedau, Hugo Adam (1983) Bentham s Utilitarian Critique of the Death Penalty, The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, Vol. 74, No. 3. (Fall 2005) Punishment, in Edward N. Zalta ed. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Stanford University. Bentham, Jeremy (1830) Rationale of Punishment: Robert Heward. http://www.la.utexas.edu/labyrinth/rp/. *28 (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (, 1978) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (, 1986;, 2005) *29 (1996) (2005) *30 11
, J. (1967) J. S. Bentham, Jeremy (1970) An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation: Oxford University Press. Buss, David M. (2005) The Murderer Next Door: Penguin Books., M. M. (1999), D. C. (2005) NTT Hare, R. M. (1963) Freedom and Reason: Oxford University Press., R. M. (1982), R. D. (2000), F. (1978), J. S. (1967) J. S. Mill, John Stuart (1969) Utilitarianism, Vol. X of Collected Works: Routledge & Kegan Paul. (1979) William Hamilton s Philosophy, in Collected Works, Vol. IX: Routledge & Kagan Paul. (1984) On Punishment, in Collected Works, Vol. XXI: Routledge & Kagan Paul. 1834. (1988) Capital Punishment, in John M. Robson and Bruce L. Kinzer eds. Collected Works of John Stuart Mill, Vol. XXVIII: Routledge, pp. 266 272., S. (2004) NHK Simmons, A. John, Marshall Cohen, Joshua Cohen, and Charles R. Beitz eds. (1995) Punishment: A Philosophy & Public Affairs Reader: Princeton University Press. Ten, C. L. (1991) Crime and Punishment, in Peter Singer ed. A Companion to Ethics: Basil Blackwell., R. C. (2006) Tooby, J. and L. Cosmides (1992) The Psychological Foundations of Culture, in J. Barcow et al. ed. The Adapted Mind: Oxford University Press., H. (2003) (1998) (1986) (1998) (1988) (1996) (2005) (2002) 8 (1999) (2002) (2002) 2 (2004) (2003) (1997) J. S. (2000) http://plaza.umin.ac.jp/%7ekodama/doctor/handout2000may.html (2003) Q&A 12
(2003) 43 1 (2005) 23 2 (2000) 6 (2005) I (1997) (1997) (2005) (2003) (2003) 10 (1997) (2000) (2001) II (1998) (2003) 137 (2003) (1997) 13