EEA ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------5 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6 1 -----------------------------------------------------------------9 A 2 ----------------------------------------------12 A 3 ----------------------------------------13 4 PCS ---------------------------------14 5 -------------------------------------------15 6 -----------------------------------------------------16 7 --------------------------------------------------------17 A 8 --------------------------------------------------------18 9 DBCP ----------------------------------------------------------19 10 A: -----------------------20 M 11DDT 50 -----------------------------------------------------------21 B 1
12 G W 13 ------------------------------------------------------23 14 ------------------------------------------------------24 15 ------------------------------------25 W 16 ------------------------------------------------26 17. ------------------------------------------------------27 C 18 -------28 19 GM -----------------------------------29 A I 20 -----------------30 - H M 21 ------------------31 22 ---------------------------------32 A M D 23 -------------------------------------------------------33 24 -----------------------------------------------------34 25 -----------------------35 2
E 26 --------------------------------------------------------36 27 --------------------------------------------------------37 28 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------28 http://www.eea.europe.eu/publications/late-lessons-2 3
21 1 2011 IARC EMFs 2B 9 IARC 2B IARC 2 IARC 2011 IARC IARC IARC IARC 1 Cnacer-och Allergifonden and Cancerhjälpen 4
2012 10 12 INAIL 12 21.1 2011 5 31 IARC EMFs 2B 9 IARC 2B IARC 2 IARC [ Interphone] [Hardell] NMT 450 MHz 900 MHz 1980 NMT450 1981 2007 12 31 NMT900 1986 2000 900 MHz 1800 MHz GSM 1991 1900/2000 MHz RF 3G UMTS 2003 800/2600MHz 4G TETRA 380 400MHz 5
DECT 1988 800 900MHz 1990 1900MHz http://www.pts.se/upload/rapporter/tele/2011/sv-telemarknad-halvar-2011-pts-er-2 011-21.pdf 1990 RF Cardis 2008 ( ) (ELF) (Hardell,1995) 2002 IARC ELF 2B IARC,2002 Hardell 1995 Carlo Scharm 2001 4 RF IARC RF Hardell 2006d 2009 Myung 2009 Cardis Sadezki,2011;Levis 2011 IARC 1999 Hardell 1999a 6
209 90 425 91 (NMT) 10 (OR) 1.20 95 CI 0.56-2.59 2 3 OR 2.42 95%CI 0.97-6.05 Hardell 1999a 2001 2001 (Inskip 2001) (Trichopoulos Adami, 2001) 782 22 5 1997 2003 1997 1 1 2000 6 30 2000 7 1 2003 12 31 Hardell 2002 2005 2006a 1997 2003 Hardell 2006b 2006c,Hardell Carlberg,2009 2 110 (Cardis 2008) 3 7
21.1 OR OR 1 OR 1 OR 1 OR 1.5 1.5 SIR: SIR SIR 1 SIR 1 SIR 1 CI: OR SIR CI 1.0 95 95 OR/SIR 4 15 45 5 20 80 DECT DECT 6 4 Bradford Hill 1965 26 5 Stein Y., Levy-Nativ, O., Richter, E.D., Eur. J.Oncol.,2011(16/1)21-54.1945 50 (Shibata, Y.. Lancet 1994 344 1 770) 6 20.9 8
50 (CT) (MRI) 50% 50% 1 (Boice McLaughlin,2002) 1997 2003 464 464 463 346 75 343 74 276 60 10 2.4 95%CI 1.4-4.1 2000 OR3.4 95%CI=1.6-7.1 2000 1.7 9
95%CI 0.8-3.4 Hardell 2010 Boice McLaughlin Hardell 1999a Ahlbom Feychting, 1999 (Hardell 1999b) Anders Ahlbom Adami 2001 (Feychting Ahlbom 1993) Maria Feychting (Bjōrkstén, 2006) Bioinitiative Working Group 2007 WHO SCENIHR 2007 (EEA 2001) (EEA) 14 EEA 2007 9 21.2 10
1997 2003 7 21.1 Hardell 2006b Hardell 2006c 4 Hardell 2010 Hardell 2011a 1 5 5 10 10 3 10 2.9 95%CI 1.8-4.7 3.8 95%CI 1.8-8.1 10 21.1 ( 916 ) 10 1.6 95%CI 0.9-2.9 10 3.0 95%CI=1.3-7.2 243 10 2.2 95%CI=1.3-3.7 Söderqvist 2007 2008 RF( ) (Cardis,2008 Christ,2010 Gandhi,2012) Kheifets,2005 20 Dosenbach,2010 RF 20 21.2 7 11
Hardell, Carlberg,2009 20 20-49 50-80 20 3.1 95 CI=1.4-6.7 5.0 95 CI=1.5-1.6 20 1 4.4 95 CI=1.3-1.5 6.8 95 CI=1.4-3.4 CEFALO ( Aydin,2011) EU Mobikids 8 CEFALO Söderqvist (2011) Karolinska Institute, 2011 Boice Tarone, 2011 3 IARC Baan,2011 2011 1.36 95 CI 0.92-2.02 Aydin, 8 ecardis@creal.cat 12
2011 5 62 101 2.8 P=0.001 2.15 95 CI=1.07-4.29 Söderqvist,2011 CEFALO Aydin,2011 2011 5 IARC IARC RF 2B IARC 21.2 EEA 2007-2011 (EEA,2007) 2009 2 (EEA 2009) 1. 9 2. 9 EEA 13
3. 80% 65% 2006 10/11 2007 4. 1970 10 (http://latelessons.ew.eea.europe.eu/fol5272324/sttements/bebefuts of mobile phones and potential hazards of EMF.doc) 2011 2 2011 10 EEA BPA - 14
21.1 OR 95% (CI) 10 10 >1 (1148 ) OR,CI OR,CI OR,CI (916 ) 1.4(0.97-2.0) 1.0(0.9-1.2) 1.6(0.9-2.9) 1.4(0.9-2.1) 1.1(0.9-1.3) 1.6(0.9-2.8) 1.1(0.9-1.4) (243 ) 2.3(0.6-8.8) 1.0(0.3-2.9) 2436 2162 ( ) Hardell,2006b 2006c 2010 2011a 21.2 (OR) (CI) (1148 ) 916 243 OR, (CI) OR, (CI) 1.1(0.9-1.3) OR, (CI) >20 1.9(0.6-5.6) 20-49 1.3(0.99-1.6) 50 1.0 0.8-1.3 1.4(0.9-2.2) 15
2436 2162 ( ) Hardell 2006b 2006c 2010 2011a WHO IARC RF McKinly,1997;Cardis,2007 2000 2004 13 16 2200 550 (IARC, 2010) 11 4 10 IARC Christopher Wild 2010 5 1640 1640 1 30 10 1.40 95 CI=1.03-1.89 Interphone Study 11 410000 Cnacer-och Allergifonden Cancerhjälpen Telia, Fondkistan, 16
Group,2010 1.96 95 CI=1.22-3.16 1.87 95 CI=1.09-3.22 Interphone Study Group, 2010 [Bradford Hill] (Hill,1965) (Saracci Samet, 2010) 10 10 10 2010 5 17 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/7729676/half-an-hour-of-mobile-use-a-day-incre ases-brain-cancer-risk.html BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/8685839.stm 12 12 EEA 17
Elisabeth Cardis 5 17 Bruce Armstrong Siegal Sadezki (http://www.microwavenews.com/interphone.main.html) Feychting 10 http://www.i-sis.org.uk/eea Hihlight Mobile Phone Cancer Risks.php http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tllmrewzdoa RF 7 J/kg 20% 1.91 95 CI=1.05-3.47 Cardis,2011 / Larjavaare 2011 Interphone Study Group,2011 10 1640 3.74 95 CI=1.58-8.83 IARC 18
13 IARC 14 (Lõnn 2006) Sadezki 2008 (Auninen 2002 Hardell 2004 Duan 2011 Sõderqvist 2012a) 50 40 90 88 89 Hardell,2006b,2006c 40 Hardell,2008 Kundi,2009 [Myung] 2009 (2009) RF 13 14 http://interphone.iarc.fr/ 2012 2 19
Hardell,2006d Kundi,2009;Redmayne,2010 Hardell,2006b 2006c Christensen,2005 2 2002 Hardell 2002 [Rowley] [Milligan](2010) 550 7 (IARC,2001) Rowley Milligan 2010 20
Kundi,2009;Myung,2009 Mead, 2009;Cardis Sadetzki,2011;Levis,2011 IARC RF (Cardis Sadetzki,2011,p170) 2011 IARC 8 (5 24 31 ) RF Hardell Interphone Study Group,2010,2011 Cardis,2011 Hardell,2011b 2 IARC 4 30 15 15 EEA IARC ( http://monographs.iarc.fr/eng/preamble/currenta5participants0706.php) 21
RF RF Baan,2011 30 RF 2B IARC IARC WHO 2011 6 http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs193/en Guiliani Soffriti,2010 (MMF) [Michael Milligan] RF IARC (http://www.mmfai/org/public/docs/eng/mmf PR 310511 IARC.pdf) GSMA GSMA [Jack Rowley] IARC IARC [Ahlbom] EEA IARC IARC EEA 22
http://www.gsma.com/articles/gsma-statement-on -the -iarc-classfication/17567 Finnish Technology Industries FFTI [Patrick Fostell] IARC (http://www.technologiateollisuus.fi/en/news/announcements/2011-6/no-chang e-in-international-assessment-of-the-health-effects-of-mobile-phone) STUK IARC [Dariuz Leszczynski] 2B IARC (http://betweemrockandhardplace.wordpress.com/2011/06/29%e2%80%a2viva -confusion) http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2011/06/mobile-phone-and-health IARC ICNIRP ICNIRP ICNIRP. ( ICNIRP ) [Maria Blettner] IARC (http://www.microwavenews.com/icnirp.interphone.html) 23
IARC (http://www,microwavenews.com) IARC IARC 1990 Ong Glantz,2000 16 (Michaels,2008;McGarity Wagner,2008:Oreskes Conwaty.2010) Larjavaara,2011 (2011) 42 10 (2011) (IEI) Rockville The Denmark Mobile Sonafon IEI IEI 2001 2006 2011 Johansen,2001;Schüz,2006,2011;Frei,2011 The Denmark Mobile Sonafon 1982 1 1 1995 12 31 723,421 58 IARC 16 1990 IARC IARC IARC IARC IARC 10 200 1 200 400 (Ong Glanz.2000) 24
(Baan,2011) Frei,2011 200,507 1995 80 (Ahlbom,2007;Söderqvist,2012b) (Frei 2011) (Aydin,2011;Ahlbom Feychting,2011;Deltour,2012;Little,2012) [Frei] (2011) (2011) 1990 Bergenheim,2007 Barlow,2009 [Deltour] 2012 40 2000 2009 +2.7 95 CI=1.1-4.3 +2.9 95 CI=0.7-5.2 NORDCAN 2001 2010 40 29 Sundhedsstyrelsen,2010 10 25
4 http://www.cancer.dk/nyheder/nyhedsartikler/2012kv4/krafting+stigning+i+hjernes vulester.htm 21.3 IARC IARC IARC IARC 40 1000 5 108 64 DDT 272 508 2A 2B IARC IARC 1 2A 2B 4 IARC,2006,p.19-20 26
2B 2B 271 [Little] 2012 1992 2008 2011 (Hardell,2011a) 2010 Interphone Study Group,2010 SEER 60 64 18 12 SEER 1992 2008 SEER +0.64 95 CI 0.33 0.95 2011 (2012) 2012 Hazleton,2005 RF ICNIRP RF 27
[Ramazzini] (ICEMS) 400 (Giuliani Soffritti,2010) EEA 2011 RF (EEA.2011a 2011b) RF RF 2B IARC (Baan,2011) ICNIRP (Swerdlow,2011) IARC 2011 7 1 IARC 28
50 (Balmori,2005,2009;Sharma Kumar,2010) (Everaert Bauwens,2007) RF 1 (EEA,2001) 2007 EEA 12 (INAL) (http://www.applelettrosmog.it/public/news.php?id-44;http://microwavenews.com/new s-center/italian-supreme-court-affirms-tumor-risk) 5 6 5 8 10 Lenart Hardell, Michael Carlberg, David Gee. Mobile phone use and brain tumour risk: early warnings, early actions? Late Lessons from early warnings: science, precaution, innovation.eea(2013)541-559 29
2013.3.25 30