Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌巻号ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌巻号ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI"

せぴあちづ
4 years ago
Views:

Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌巻号ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI

Annex V to the UNCLOS between Timor-Leste and Australia, Decision on Australia s Objections to Competence) 玉田, 大神戸法學雜誌 / Kobe law

1 Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌巻号ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件 ( 東チモール / オーストラリア ) 権限抗弁に関する決定 (2016 年 9 月 19 日 )(In the matter of a Conciliation before a Conciliation Commission Constituted under Annex V to the UNCLOS between Timor-Leste and Australia, Decision on Australia s Objections to Competence) 玉田, 大神戸法學雜誌 / Kobe law journal,66(3/4): Departmental Bulletin Paper / 紀要論文 publisher JaLCDOI / URL PDF issue:

2 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 119 (1) 一. 決定要旨 Ⅰ. 序 (paras.1 29) EEZ UNCLOS UNCLOS a iv PCA Case Nº, In the matter of a Conciliation before a Conciliation Commission Constituted under Annex V to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea between the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste and the Commonwealth of Australia, Decision on Australia s Objections to Competence September. PCA Objections to competence. V competence jurisdictioncompetence

3 120 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 A. 紛争の背景 (paras.5 12) UNTAET JPDA CMATS CMATS a b JPDA cjpda jurisdiction admissibilitypara. H.E. Ambassador Peter Taksøe-Jensen Chairman, Denmark, Dr. Rosalie Balkin Australia, Judge Abdul G. Koroma Sierra Leone, Professor Donald McRae Canada and New Zealand, Judge Rüdiger Wolfrum Germany. Koroma Wolfrum Balkin McRae The United Nations Transitional Administration in East Timor. The Timor Sea Treaty between the Government of East Timor and the Government of Australia, May, UNTS. JPDA: a Joint Petroleum Development Area. CMATS Treaty between Australia and the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste on Certain Maritime Arrangements in the Timor Sea, January, UNTS.

4 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 121 CMATS CMATS CMATS UNCLOS B. 豪の権限抗弁及び決定の射程 (13 29 項 ) CMATS CMATS UNCLOS CMATS UNCLOS UNCLOS CMATS comity CMATS cannot settle the dispute CMATS CMATS UNCLOS UNCLOS UNCLOS CMATS Agreement between the Government of Australia and the Government of the Democratic Republic of Timor-Leste relating to the Unitisation of the Sunrise and Troubadour Fields, March, UNTS.

5 122 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 UNCLOS V Ⅱ. 手続的経緯 (paras.30 41) Ⅲ. 調停委員会の検討 (paras ) CMATS UNCLOS UNCLOS UNCLOS VUNCLOS a later treaty CMATS UNCLOS UNCLOS Article Competence : A disagreement as to whether a conciliation commission acting under this section has competence shall be decided by the commission. Opening Session Transcript August, Chairman, p..

6 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 123 para. A. UNCLOS 281 条 (paras.48 64) UNCLOS para. a legally binding agreement a binding decisionpara. UNCLOS para. CMATS CMATS UNCLOS CMATS CMATS B. UNCLOS 298 条 (paras.65 82) a i UNCLOS. a i

7 124 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 entry into force UNCLOS UNCLOS CMATS a i CMATS CMATS CMATS UNCLOS UNCLOS a i C. UNCLOS 311 条及び UNCLOS と CMATS の関係 (paras.83 85) UNCLOS CMATS CMATS UNCLOS UNCLOS

8 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 125 CMATS D. 権限及び豪の受理可能性抗弁 (paras.86 92) CMATS CMATS CMATS CMATS CMATS CMATS CMATS an established fact UNCLOS E. 調停付託事項の射程 (paras.93 99) UNCLOS matter CMATS UNCLOS a i PCIJ the clean hands doctrine para. see, Case Concerning the Division of Water from the River Meuse Netherlands v. Belgium, Judgment of June, PCIJ Series A/B, No., p..

9 126 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 F. 附属書 V 7 条及び 12 か月期間の適用 (paras ) V V V IV. 決定 (para.111) A. UNCLOS V B. C. UNCLOS V Article : The commission shall report within months of its constitution.

10 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 127 二. 解説 1. 本件の調停付託の背景 UNCLOS V UNCLOS ICJ ITLOS VII B b i ICJ ii UNCLOS ICJ ITLOS iii UNCLOS ICJ ITLOS Case number, available at Case number, available at Opening Session Transcript August, Minister Gusmao, p.. b any dispute concerning or relating to the delimitation of maritime zones, including the territorial sea, the exclusive economic zone and the continental shelf, or arising out of, concerning, or relating to the exploitation of any disputed area of or adjacent to any such maritime zone pending its delimitation. Available at = &p = &p = &code=au htm#australia after ratification

11 128 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 ICJ UNCLOS DS compulsory conciliation 2. 任意調停と強制調停 conciliation V voluntary conciliation UNCLOS V V compulsory conciliation UNCLOS / / -FACT-SHEET- CONCILIATION.pdf Opening Session Transcript August, Minister Gusmao, p.. UNCLOS Sienho Yee, Conciliation and the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, Ocean Development and International Law, vol., p.. compulsory non-binding conciliation

12 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 129 V V voluntary conciliation UNCLOS V compulsory conciliation UNCLOS V J. G. Merrills, International Dispute Settlement th ed., Cambridge University Press,, pp.. consensual conciliation process Opening Session Transcript August, Lowe pp.. Roberto Lavalle, Conciliation under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea: A Critical Overview, Austrian Review of International and European Law, vol., p..

13 130 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 para. 3. 調停手続の特徴 UNCLOS ICJ ITLOS VII V V V V UNCLOS UNCLOS UNCLOS UNCLOS V an V UNCLOS J. G. Merrills, International Dispute Settlement th ed., Cambridge University Press,, p..

14 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 131 amicable settlement V V V V a ii V Roberto Lavalle, supra note, p.. Article a ii : after the conciliation commission has presented its report, which shall state the reason on which it is based. Roberto Lavalle,

15 132 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 UNCLOS 4. 調停の有用性と可能性 UNCLOS a i a i supra note, pp.. Sienho Yee, supra note, p.. Tullio Treves, Compulsory Conciliation in the U.N. Law of the Sea Convention, in Volkmar Götz et al. eds., Liber amicorum Günther Jaenicke- Zum. Geburtstag, pp..

16 神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 3 4 号 133 UNCLOS Opening Session Transcript August, Minister Gusmao, pp.. J. G. Merrills, supra note, p.. Opening Session Transcript August, Chairman, p.. the very collegial atmosphere Opening Session Transcript August, Chairman, p..

17 134 国連海洋法条約附属書 Ⅴ 調停事件権限抗弁に関する決定 UNCLOS VII a i Opening Session Transcript August, Mr. Quinlan, p..

神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 2 号 1 神戸法学雑誌第六十六巻第二号二〇一六年九月 ALAI JAPAN B

神戸法学雑誌 66 巻 2 号 1 神戸法学雑誌第六十六巻第二号二〇一六年九月 ALAI JAPAN B Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌巻号ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI 類似性と二次創作 (Similarity in Copyright Infringement.) 前田,

Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌 巻号 ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI

Kobe University Repository : Kernel タイトル Title 著者 Author(s) 掲載誌巻号ページ Citation 刊行日 Issue date 資源タイプ Resource Type 版区分 Resource Version 権利 Rights DOI