ses2011-tutorial.pptx

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "ses2011-tutorial.pptx"

つかささどひら
9 years ago
Views:

1 目文方大大 ICSE RE SIGSOFT/FSE TSE TOSEM ASE

2 言 Dear Naoyasu, XXX, XXX, and XXX, Thank you for your submission to the 200? International Conference on Software Engineering. We regret to inform you that your submission entitled 文 was not accepted for presentation at the conference. We received XXX submissions this year and were able to accept only XXX % of them. ICSE 2010 Paper Notification [121] Dear Naoyasu, Jun and Tetsuo, Thank you for your submission to ICSE The program committee met on December 4-5 to consider the submissions to the Research Paper track. We are pleased to inform you that your paper, "Archface: A Contract Place Where Architectural Design and Code Meet Together has been accepted for presentation in the technical program and for publication in the conference proceedings. The competition was strong: only 52 of the 380 submissions were accepted, giving an acceptance rate of 13.7%. orz ( 方 )

3 至面白面白文文文力力力力文目文見見文

4 言面白言力力面言文 Motivating Example 言力力言 Evaluation 言文足言言文文

5 日自己工 ICSE 文言 : Queen s 大 SAIL by 亀高大日

6 自己

7 言 AOP Aspect-Oriented Programming COP Context-Oriented Programming Role Model 言MDD Model-Driven Development

8 文 2002 AOSD 2002 * Aspect-Oriented Programming with Model Checking AOP 2004 AOSD 2004 Association Aspects 2005 ICSE 2005 An Adaptive Object Model with Dynamic Role Binding ASE 2005 * A Parameterized Interpreter for Modeling Different AOP Mechanisms 2007 ASE 2007 * An Aspect-oriented Weaving Mechanism Based on Component and Connector Architecture Role AOP AOP 2009 CAiSE 2009 * An Extensible Aspect-oriented Modeling Environment 2010 ICSE 2010 * Archface: A Contract Place Where Architectural Design and Code Meet Together 2011 RE 2011 * A Context Analysis Method for Embedded Systems ---Exploring a Requirement Boundary between a System and Its Context * 一文 MDD 工

9 ICSE % = 44/313 ASE % = 28/291 ASE % = 37/312 CAiSE % = 36/230 ICSE % = 54/380 RE % = 23/138 用文方 G-Index, H-Index 自

10 文文方面

11 一人門工人方一生見見

12 工

13 一日 Tao Xie (North Carolina State University)

14 A B C 工 A AOSD ASE CAiSE CAV CBSE ECOOP ESEM FME FSE The Computing Research and Education Association of Australasia, CORE ICSE ICSM ISSRE ISSTA OOPSLA RE

15 ICSE 2011 文 62/441 PC : 169 : 272 : 112 : 57 : 62 : 50 石, : 33 工 (ICSE2011), IPSJ-SE , 2011.

16 文非文文立立立立文 PC 文

17 ICSE 2011 見見文石, : 33 工 (ICSE2011), IPSJ-SE , 2011.

18 ICSE 見見工 ICSE 工自方工 RE 一方見見 ECOOP 文

19 文

20 文言文文方非文言示

21 文一心一 Web : 文方

22 言面白言力力面言文 Motivating Example 言力力言 Evaluation 言文足言言文文

23 言

24 言力力面面面面力力大文面白方言言文自方示一支方文方見見

25 1999 One day this will be a great paper. But it isn't quite there yet. The paper needs to be streamlined and clarified. You need to make it more clear why this is a good idea. The paper is badly written. There might be good ideas that might be hidden somewhere, but so far as I can read, the paper fails to be a technical paper that crystallizes new ideas. ICSE 2005

26 The combination of technically inaccurate characterizations of others' work, of great overclaiming, and of incomplete discussion of a potentially serious weakness in the proposed approach overwhelm what is otherwise a nice attempt to provide language support for aspect-oriented programming through architectural connection. ASE 2007, ICSE 2010

27 口 The application of AOP to mobile agents is intriguing. The overview on agent applications is most interesting. Unfortunately, the paper is too similar to XXX s paper at. 口 ICSE 2005

28 言文 Motivating Example 文自文文生見見人方工文大文文示 Motivating Example Motivating Example 言文文 Motivating Example 用

29 文目 1. Introduction 2. Motivating Example 3. XXX 4. Evaluation 5. Discussion 6. Related Work 7. Conclusions 文 1. Introduction 2. Related Work 3. XXX 4. Evaluation 5. Discussion 6. Conclusions 文

30 An implementation is described, but the approach is validated only with conceptual examples, no real case studies. If the paper included a compelling case study and solved the presentation issue, I would be convinced to advocate for it; as it is, the paper is premature. ASE 2007

31 言力力力力大力力言文一文示

32 用用用心用用方用用用自用文用用用用

33 1999 One day this will be a great paper. But it isn't quite there yet. The paper needs to be streamlined and clarified. You need to make it more clear why this is a good idea. The paper is badly written. There might be good ideas that might be hidden somewhere, but so far as I can read, the paper fails to be a technical paper that crystallizes new ideas. ICSE 2005

34 While the issue targeted by this paper is interesting, there are some problems with this paper. Originality unclear. XXX is, of course, a new language, but the features it provides don't strike me as original. ASE 2005

35 The biggest problem I have with the paper is that its model of computing is not properly clarified. I don't mean to say give the whole formal semantics, but terminologies such as roles, collaboration, strategies, evolution, etc. remain ill-defined, other than to give a sketchy description using some code fragments in an unfamiliar programming language. ICSE 2005

36 用用 The paper makes one potentially dangerous redefinition of the term XXX. I think the software community needs another definition. While I understand the temptation for this new definition, I suggest the authors adopt the standard definition, and find a new name for the new concept added here. ASE 2007

37 言 Evaluation 工文文 ICSE 文方文一言

38 工用用 GQM Goal, Question, Metric 力力十目見見

39 This paper presents some interesting ideas for structuring aspect specifications. However, further elaboration is needed towards the evaluation of these ideas. ASE 2007

40 言文足文力力比文比心一文面力力心文一見見

41 I think the details of the implementation in terms of XXX add little to this paper. That material probably wants to go in another. ICSE 2005

42 言 Future Work 文足言見見 Future Work 一見見示方力力足高言面白

43 自身大 cf. ICSE influence paperfuture Work 文用力力 Future Work 自身 Future Work 用大

44 言文言方一文文一面白食見見文

45 文面白大文力力言力力面言力力言 Evaluation 言一言見見言方心人面白方力力

46 文一言文文言力力面面行行心文力力

47 文文力力示文用心文人西文見見人心米心西身人文耳言文文文西身大文行行

48 : Queen s 大 SAIL By 亀高大

49 s 文文 Make happy reviewers!! Research Question 2 or 3 RQ 十用 RQ [] [ ] [] [] 1. Introduction RQ 1 行行 2. Related work 3. Experiment Setting 4. Results 4.1 RQ RQ2.

50 s & ICSE20115 月 4 月 6 月 3 月 6 月 6 Posdoc:2 PhD:6 Msc: 2 高 ICSE2011: 14.4% (=1/6) :14.1% (=62/441) ICSM2010: 22.5% (=2/8) : 27.1% (=36/133)

51 日

52 日文力力方

54 文 ICSE's Most Influential Paper Award: Show, M.: Writing Good Software Engineering Research, Proceedings of the 25th International Conference on Software Engineering, IEEE Computer Society, 2003, pp 石, : 33 工 (ICSE2011), IPSJ-SE , : 文方 : 文,, Vol.26, No.4, pp.17-29, 2009.

紀要1444＿大扉＆目次＿初.indd

紀要1444＿大扉＆目次＿初.indd 1. Hi, How are you? / What s up? / How s it going? A / Nice talking to you. 2. Oh really? / That s great! / That s A, B interesting! / Are you serious? / Sounds good. / You too! / That s too bad. 3. Sorry?