Kwansei Gakuin University Rep Title Author(s) Citation 明治時代における女性と 不幸の共同体 : 婦人雑誌の投書から検討する Yazaki, Chika, 矢﨑, 千華 関西学院大学先端社会研究所紀要 = Annual review of advanced social research, 13: 17-34 Issue Date 2016-03-31 URL http://hdl.handle.net/10236/14347 Right http://kgur.kawansei.ac.jp/dspace
Annual Review of the Institute for Advanced Social Research vol.13! " " " " 1 17
2005 1991!!!!!!! 2. 3 4 5 6. 2 2.1 1985 1 18
2 1982 : 127-30 33 1900 80 33 1900 1 38 1905 3 1981 : 29 2 3 2004 : 194 1982 : 129 27 5 2004 : 161 39 23 6,500 1997 : 33-4 2 1977 1991 1977 1991 : 14 1985 19
1977 1991 1977 1991 1977 1991 4 1999 2.2 1965 2005 : 6 5 6 1986 1994 Riessman 2008 2014 20
Riessman 2008 2014 : 149 Mattingly 1998 : xi 6 7 8 3 2 2000 ECF Extreme Case Formulation Pomerantz 1986 ECF 1 2 3 Pomerantz 1986 : 227 2001 21
3.1 9 3 "! "! "! 10, 11 41 10 3 5 7 "! "! "!!!! 2 2 1500 22
2 3.2 3.2.1 41 3 1 3 3 4 23
41 4 1 3 4 41 4 1 3 4 24
!!! 12 3.2.2 13 41 11 1 3 13 5 2000 : 2118 25
2 3.3 41 12 3 14 14 26
42 2 1 4 2 3 7 3 14 4 4 4 7 15 16 2005 27
4 4.1 41 5 1 3 5!! 2001 Epston 1998 2005 28
3 8 3 8 3 9 17 4.2 29
20 30 1996 18 5 Anderson 1991 1997 : 63-4 30
19 6 20 1973 2001 31
21 2014 Anderson, B. 1991 Imagined Communities : Reflection on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism 2nd.ed Verso 1997 NTT 2001 2004 2000 1977 1991 100 1997 1991 1999 Madigan, S. & Epston, D. 1995, From Spy-chiatric gaze to communities of concern, Friedman, S. ed. The Reflecting Team In Action The Guilford Press 2005 Mattingly, C. 1998, Healing dramas and clinical plots : The narrative structure of experience CAMBRIDGE UNI- VERSITY PRESS. 1973 2001 1965 1996 1982 2005 1981 Pomerantz, A. 1986, Extreme Case Formations : A way of legitimizing claims Human Studies 9 : 219-229. Riessman, C. 2008, Narrative Method for the Human Science, SAGE Publications 2014 2001 54 : 112-102 4 7 32
2005 38 4 53-63 2005 1994 1986 9 2000 1985 3 1 7 14 1 2 6 8 2015.11.26 2016.2.17 33
Women and the Community of Misfortunes in the Meiji Era : Cases of Women s Magazines YAZAKI, Chika Kwansei Gakuin University Abstract This paper examines how people accepted their misfortunes. Previous works focused on people who identified themselves with model stories such as success in life or dutiful wife and devoted mother. In contrast, this paper aims to focus on women who couldn t identify themselves with them. How the social solidity created among women empowered them under situations which placed them into poverties, sickness and other difficulties in the late Meiji era? The one answer to this question can be traced in their practices of accepting their misfortunes. Therefore, this paper analyses narratives from correspondence columns on women s magazines. Women accepted their misfortunes through sharing voices in magazines, and they shared and compared their misfortunes with others in magazines. They firstly exchange the sympathy to other s misfortunes, and then they compare their situations with others. They were connected with others by the articulation of narratives about misfortunes and could imagine we who shared same realties through these practices. Women narrated their different misfortunes by creating and sharing a common format. The image of we indicates the acquisition of the common languages and ways of the representation. It implies that we can understand this creation of social solidity as the community of misfortunes. Key words : correspondence columns, narrative, misfortune, community 34