Microsoft Word vesalli.doc

13129 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912 171912101019 1719 101619 1519151211 1914 121217 2 1 10121411101711:6 1 15.141911121411 12 19.11121419 1912191419:6 1 1119101910 1213191814 1417141711 191410 1916191811 1019 1719 101619 1519151210 1919111412 12 101612 161218 1011 13121912 161218 19171210191914 1711 1719 101612 1613121314 1011 151219 171912101019 161816 1914121217126 1 1011 1019191114 1114191112 161218141914161917191017.6 1 1719 151918 15191419 1712 19171210 15171914 12141217 1719191017 1711 161218 1919 191218141914 171912101019 1719 101619 19141514191017:6 1 141714 1910 191410 1917191210126 1 3 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1719 191612131917 17181910 101919141711 1914121217 12 1714151914126 1 171417151911 1714101014 161218 6 1(10191017)6 1 171912101019 191112.6 1 191410 1916191811 1910121719 1011 1019191114 1215181418 1114191112 16121814 1719 191718 191612131917 17181910 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1914161917191017126 1 1711 1019 1019191114 12191314191518191914 1114191112 16121814 1719 1215181418 1918171219 1710101918 1914121217.6 1 111611 171417151911 1714101014 1719 16131213 161218 1011 1910101811 1417 1912181419 171912101019 19121917 101513 16191919 191415141917 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 1719 1114191112 16121814 17191210101914 1714101014 1711 12191918 1910151314 1719 16131213 1911171915 12 1910101919111914 1114191112 16121814 191112 1019191114 191415191717.6 1 1 - Philip Arestis 2 - Malcolm Sawyer 3 - New Consensus

13130 19121017 1510161110101714 E5, E52 :JEL 1-1916171911 121912151910 1718141714:6 1 1114191112 101916 10111911126 1 6 1"1212191516 14171417"126 1 161218 171912101019126 1 101612 1114191112 16121814 191410 1916191811 1019 1719 101619 1519151210 161218 1011 13121912 161218 19171210191914 1711 1719 101612 1613121314 1011 151219 171912101019 6 1(12121115 1114111219 1019101714)6 1 161816 1914121217126 1 1011 1019191114 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 1914161917191017.6 1 1215181418 191612131917 17181910 1011 151219 1211141714(121814 1011 1011 151219 17191918)6 1 1019 191410 1915111219 101019 121711 191112 1711 1019 161218 191412121910 1011 1910101811 1417 1912181419 101912101019 1915121919 121217 12 17191411 161218 1719 15191712 6 1(1419 6 1"17191411"6 1 161218)6 1 1919 6 1(1011 13121912 191112161419 1419 181419 191112161419)126 1 121512 1710121918 10191017 1919171014 6 1(1011 1710121910 17191915101919 17121812)6 1 1719 101619 15191512.6 1 1011 1710101918 191015151915 1612181519191414 6 1(1711 161217 1019 171417151911 101912101019 10121710 161218 191112121919 101217)6 1 12 191217181912 141217191914 1711 10191017111914 1919171014 1719 12181912 10191914 1117151518191914 191217 17191411 161218 1719 15191712 1719 1514 171111 1980 1019 1410 1912191411 12171017126 1 1917101210126 1 1719 101114191914 1910 171212191119 1114191112 16121814 1019 1210161419 6 1(1419 1117151518191914)6 1 1 1417 101916 10111911 1718141714126 1 1919101017 101916 1210101418 10191017 1919171014 101019 121711 191112.6 1 1719 191410 15191812 1916171919 161218 1912141217126 1 1019 12121411 1011 121619141914 10151117191914 161218 1419 16191919 17191710 161218 1719 10191017 12 1219191418 101910171119 1011 1917151914 12111114181912126 1 1910 1217191918 101410 101612 1613121314 12 101910171119 1914141917 1914121217.6 1 1719 15191815191419 1712 19171210 1719171115171914 12141217 1719191017 1711 17191411161218 1919 171912101019 191416101719191017.6 1 1417 191712101215121710121910 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1719 19161213191717181910101919 1519151211191112 6 1(1011 1710121910 19131918Meyer,20016 0 ( 12 1714151914 10151912 161218 6 1(10191017)6 1 17191210101914 1714101014 191112 ) Howells,1996, Arestis & 12 Lavoie, 2003 1712 1019121011 1111121017).6 1 1-12191211 1719121914 101916 1210101418 10191017 1919171014 1719 19121917 10191611191414 10161419 101916 repo 6 1(10191017 1919171014 1919121619)126 1 101916 12141211 1517191918 (USA) 12 18141911 1011 171919 1519151211 1914 121217.6 1 191410 101916126 1 101916 10111911 1914 191112 1711 1719 1410 10191017 1919171014 1219191418 1011 17191411 1816191419 1011 1114111219 19191814 17191917.6 1

13131 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1712 1215191212 191119 101410 6 1(12 1719 191210)6 1 191410 1712 10151912 12141217 17191917:6 1 1719 1914101419 19111912191410 191410 12151912121119 1919101215 1914121217 1011 1914101711 1415121011 1011 171912101019 10121710 161218 10151914111211 1914121217.6 1 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 191612131917 17181910 (NCM) 1019 161218 1011 1910101811 1417 1912181419 171912101019 1915121919 1914171017 6 1(15191411 12191211 1719121010191414 1011 10171912 19121917 19111215191711 16191919 1519151211 191112)126 1 1011 1410 19171014 1711 17191411 161218 1719 15191712126 1 6 1"1019161419191017111914"6 1 191112 1711 1910121014 1019 1216191419 10191914 161218 191410191217.6 1 1719 171417151911 17141010141217191411 161218 1719 15191712 1417 101916141919101711 191112 121814 1215181418 1918171219126 1 1910191014 10161914 17191210101914 161816 12 1910 101410 19151210 161218(1613121319156 1 12121115 10191017)6 1 1919 101410 1519191119 1412191711 191112.6 1 10191017 1919171014126 1 101916 1210101418 1919 1210161419 1019121711 12 101019 1011 17191612191112 10191017111914 1214191914126 1 1816191419 1919 1719 191612141919 14101910 16191919 1914171117.6 1 10191017111914 1214191914 12111114181912 1919 1019 101916 10111911 1914 1711 1710191912 191112 1910 101916 10111911 10191017 1919171014 10111718191211 1417 1519121411 111217 19171519 1914101919141017 6 1(1519121411 111217 1019 1910101914 12191414151912 10161714101514 101910171119126 1 16171912 1019101919 14101119126 1 12 171417151911121910 10111012 1011 19141117 1217141410 1914121217).6 1 1119 1712 19171210 15171914 19141015121011 1212161413 191417111017 1711 1114191112 16121814 1011 13121912 1114191112 101916 10111911 161217 1919 10121910 1914171117126 1 191919 1719 171417151911 14101119 171916131213 1219131419 12181414191912 101916 10111911 1019 191214 1911171915 1114191112 12 11191419 1910101919111914 1114191112 16121814126 1 1215191212111914 16191018 1212141114 12141217 17191917.6 1 191719191119161918111011 19141013121912 1210161419151917141711191112:6 1 1719 101612 2 101612111419111216121814 1719 191718 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 191612131917 1718191012191217191610 14101719101612 312 171919191414 111419111216121814 1719 19171210 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 19121917 1019191114 16191919 19141514191017.6 1 101612 4 6 1121011 101513 1719 19121917 171417151911 1714101014 1719 16131213 161218 1011 1910101811 1417 1912181419 171912101019 1914161917191017.6 1 1719 101612 12 5 101612111419111216121814 1719 12151814181114191112 16121814 17191210101914 1714101014 1917 101619 16191919 1519151211 191112.6 1 1719 101612 6 1618191311 12 1012141411 15141914 191410 1910191513 191919141411 151917141711 191112.6 1

13132 19121017 2-6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1719 191612131917 17181910 2-1- 16191810 171814 191718 1212191516 14171417 1719 16191810 1417 191718 11191711 1111 1917191718111914 1618191311 1914121217 6 1(19111216191914 121711 1910 1999. Clarida 12 1119171919191017 2001 12 McCallum 17 2001 12 1.(Meyer Y g t = a 0 + a 1 Y g t-1 + a 2 E t (Y g t+1) ｨC a 3 [R t -E t (p t+1 )] +S 1 (1) (2) 6 1(1019121915 = 1 3 P t = b 1 Y g t + b 2 P t -1 + b 3 E t (p t-1 ) +S 2, (b 2 + b R t = RR * + E t (p t+1 ) + C 1 (Y g t-1) + C 2 (p t-1 ｨC P T ) (3) 1711 1719 1410 Y g 12171915 1212181417126 1 R 101916 10111911 19111914126 1 P 101916 12121919126 1 P T 101916 12121919 111715126 1 * RR 101916 10111911 1219161714 6 1"121719171814"6 1 19141019121017.6 1 101916 10111911 121719171814 1710191912 191112 1910 101916 101119111914 1711 1019 12171915 1212181417 131519 111910151919 191112 1711 1719 191410 15191812 1910 191719171811 (2)12 1019 1417 101916 12121919 13191012 1718191812 17191917.6 1 (1,2=i) S i 101219101711101711 121217111914 121319171514 19141019121017 12 E t 1910121619191912 1719 10191910 t 1919 10121910 1914171117.6 1 191719171811 (1)12 191719171811 121619141914 1718 191112 1711 1719 1410 12171915 1212181417126 1 1019 19111215191711 1910 12171915 1212181417 1518121211 12 19101216191914 12 101916 10111911 1219161714 1217141410 1914121217.6 1 191410 191719171811126 1 1519181214 1919 10121910 1914171117 1711 NCM 6 1(1212191516 14171417 191612131917 17181910)6 1 1011 10171912 1912181419 19191814 1419 101916 1219161714 191910 1919 1719 191719171811 (1) 1719 101619 191415141917.6 1 191719171811 (2) 1910151014 151418141611 191112 1711 1719 1410 12121919 1910121014 1019 12171915 1212181417 15171814 12 12121919 1518121211 12 19101216191914 191410191217.6 1 191719171811 (3) 1619171711 191419191414 1114191112 16121814 2 6 1(1019 19111215191711 1910 1619171711 1214181219)6 1-1 10191914 101513 151112191711 1219 171910191911 191410 191718126 1 19141217 121217 1011 (2004c).Arestis and Sawyer 2 - Taylor's Rule

13133 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 191112 1711 1719 1410 101916 10111911 19111914 101919111911 12121919 19101216191914126 1 12171915 1212181417126 1 191015191915 12121919 1910 111715 12 101916 10111911 1219161714 6 1"121719171814"6 1 1217141410 1914121217.6 1 1417 1214121514 14191810 191719171811 (3) 191410 191112 1711 10191914 1019 13101912 10121710 1410126 1 14191410 12121919 10191417 1011 151219 1917191218 101019151219 1910 1417 10191217.6 1 1119141017 191519 C 1 1011 161719 17191514 10101915 10191217126 1 10191914 17111214191014 1011 13101912126 1 1014191014 1011 101019151219 10121710 + 1 2 C 1910 1417 101612191117 101217.6 1 1719 12191617126 1 (2005) Fair 19141015121011 1012141411 15141914 1914 171017 1711 1011 151219 1214191014126 1 101019151219 1910 1417 10121710 14191410 1011 16121714 161217 1911191412 1017191917126 1 10181711 1719 191718 19121917 191519181711 1214126 1 14191410 171214171219 1910 1417 101410 19141212191017 1011 1417 191719171811 1019 13101912 10141014191917.6 1 191719171811 (3) 1210161419 101916 10111911 12121115 10191017 1919171014 1919 1019 19111911 1619101210 1214181219 1011 12141215 171912101019 1719 101619 1519151211 12 1011 13121912 171814 1910 1417 12191017 1110141011 17191411 171219 1711 12191918 12121919 6 1(10111012 1011 111715)6 1 12 12171915 1212181417 191410191217 19111216191914 151917141711 191112(6 16 019936 0.(Taylor, 1911191412 6 1"1619101210 1214181219"6 1 1719 1410 191112 1711 101916 10111911 1019 19111911 171711 191817191814 1711 10111012 1011 12171915 1212181417 10121910 1914171117 ) 12 1019 19111911 1219171012 1410 10111012 1011 12121919126 1 1711 1011 10121011 161217 1011 12171915 1212181417 121910111211 191112)6 1 1217171418 121711 191112.6 1 12171915 1212181417 131519126 1 1019 12121919 13191012 111910151919 191112 ) 1910 191719171811 2). 1410151911 191719171811 (3) 1718191812 1019 1417 101916 10111911 19111914 17191917 1711 191519 1410 1919 1011 101916 1219161714 1210171418 17101419126 1 1019 101916 121719171814 * RR 1019191019 1914121217126 1 1711 1019 12171915 1212181417 131519 12 12121919 13191012 191519101612 17191917126 1 12 1910 191719171811 (1)12 1019191019 1019 a 0 a/ 3 1612191117 101217.6 1 1019 151914 1914101711 10191017 1919171014 1216191410 1716141614 1910 * RR 1719 171112 1719121211 10191217126 1 1011 101619 1914191117 1711 191412121910 191612131917 1919 1011 111912 121719171814 1711 1719 1410 12171915 1212181417 131519 12 12121919 13191012 6 1(1019 10191614 1019191019 111715)6 1 10191217 1117191412 10191217.6 1 1719 1410 13121912 191719171811 (1) 10121910 1914171117 1711 121619141914 1718126 1 1019 12171915 1212181417 131519 111910151919 191112.6 1 1719 1417 191612131917 101612 1613121314126 1 191410 1912141217 1718191812 1019 191410 17191917 1711 101916 10111911 1219161714 * RR 19101419 1011 101919101914 1611 1910171910 12 111919191411 1518191914 1719 1414101711 1914121217.6 1

1313 ) 134 19121017 2-2- 1114191112 16121814 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1011 1910161219 1710121918 12121919 10191214 1910 15121919 1216191419126 1 1019 101612 1114191112 16121814 6 1(1011 121718 101916111914 10111911)6 1 1219171417 1914171017.6 1 11191910151219 1711 (1997) Gordon 1912191911 171917 ) 1119 141017 1719 1019141011 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1010121711 191112)126 1 6 1"1719 10181017 191712126 1 12121919 1119141211 12 111911 1419 16171417111914 191112 1711 1011 17181418 1919101917 GDP 19111914 1912151916 191419151217.6 1 121217111914 151915 17191411 151911 1011 151911 1011 12161217 191416141210171017.6 1 191919 14101411 111010 1914 121217 12121919 10181017191712 111914101910 161914171919 10191217126 1 191217 1917191219 GDP 19111914 1915101210 1019 191217 1510141714 1419 101918161211 1212181417 1219161714 191112."6 1 17). 1212191516 14171417 191410 19141711 1919 17191917 1711 121217111914 151915 17191411 121319171514 10121711 12 1719191914 19141910151410 131519 19141019121017 12 101916 12121919 1912141217 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 101914 1711101717 111914101410 14101119 121913141914 1019 101916 12121919 19101216191914 101719191017 6 1(10191914 19131918 191919141711 121217 1011 Clarida 12 11191719191910 12.(1999 1212191516 14171417 1011 151219 141714 1212131411 1914171017 1711 12121919 1919 191412121910 1910 15191416 1114191112 101916 10111911 6 1(1019 19111215191711 1910 12121919 1017191414 10191214 1910 1216191419)6 1 19111919 10191217:6 1 101916111914 10111911 1019 1216191419 1219131419 1914151819191017 6 1(191719171811 1) 1711 1011 10121011 161217 12121919 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 1914171117 6 1(191719171811 2). 10111718191211 10141910 1914121217 1711 1417 101916 121719171814 6 1(1419 6 1"101916 1510141714")6 1 10111911 12141217 17191917 1711 19141212191017 19141910 1216191419 12 17191411 1718 1212191010 1914141917 171017 6 1(1010191019191410 12171915 1212181417 1719 1214171412 121719171814126 1 131519 10121711)6 1 12 15131218 1011 1410 191917191016181419 191410191217 6 1(1011 191410 19171014 1711 12191918 101916111914 19101514 10111911 19111914 101914121217 12 1019 19181915161912 101916 191910 1719 1210191614 10141112).6 1 191410 101916 10111911 121719171814 1011101219 1912191011 1915111219 6 1"101916 1510141714"6 1 10111911 191112 1711 12121115 Wicksell 19121917 1215181418 16191919 15191512.6 1 3-191012161917 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1910 101612 1114191112 16121814 3-1. 1216191419 12 12121919 12121411 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1011 12121919 10191214 1910 15121919 1216191419 1111 1912141217 1919 19121917 16191112 16191919

13135 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1914171117.6 1 191218 1914101711126 1 1114191112 16121814 1011 1411 1914101910 1019 121619141914 1718 12 1011 1710101918 1410 1019 12121919 19121319 19111211 121219111714 1711 12121115Arestis 12 2004) (A Sawyer 191919141411 121711 12 10121910 1914171117 1711 1114191112 16121814 1719 191410 16131213 1011101219156 1 17191919 10141112.6 1 1919 1219131419 12181414191912 101916 10111911 1019 191612131917 1919 1711 12121115 11191419 191516161910 1910 15191416 171918141912 1210141111191014 19121917 191519181711 16191919 1519151211 12 1510191912 121711 101217 1019191114 101912171419.6 1 191410 171919 1019 19111215191711 1910 191718111914 19161213191711101414 17181910 12ECB 10191017 1919171014 1910151811121910 12 1114111219 1517191918 19101912 1711 10191914 1214101411 12 1215181418 111419111214 1011 171919 1519151211 191412121017 13121912 16181419151211 191112.6 1 1919 1719 191519181711 161217 1719141915121419 1711 12181414191912 101916 10111911 191319 1417141514 1019 12121919 17191917 6 1(1417 1218141419 1 1719131714 1719 101916 1210101418126 1 15171217 0,2 1219 0,3 17191317 1019 12121919 19121319 191112)126 1 1719 15191814 1711 12191314191912 191119 101412121914 1019 1912181419111914 1219161714126 1 1613121319156 1 1119191914111518191914 17191917 1711 1719 1012141411 1916171919 1816141911 111919191411 1414101711 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 1914171117.6 1 141019101411 1219131419 19101717 101916 10111911 1019 12121919 16191018 16141210141014 12 121217111914 1219191711 191216191910 1019121017126 1 191410 1012191414 1719191914 1911191412 161219111017 101217.6 1 141919 1711 1719 1410 13121912 191412121910 12181414191912 101019151219 1719 101916111914 10111911 1919 1011 171919 15191512.6 1 191919126 1 1019 1410 1914101910 121913141914 1711 12181414191912 101916 10111911 1019 1916171919 1816191419 111919191411 1019 141914 1914151819191017126 1 141714 1910 19181019191912 191119 1212191516 14171417 191612131917 17181910 101916191919 10191415191717.6 1 12 1918101211 19121210 191112 1711 19121718 171919 10161714101514 1011 1119151918 12141217 1612191117 17191212126 1 191919 1719 181419 191410 13121912 101916 111914 10111911 1914121219101017 141112 1219191410 13101912126 1 1219 111015191914 1711 16141210141014 14101119 1019 191612131917 121913141915181919 191112 1011 1517 17191514 1218141419 1419101017.6 1 1919 1212131411 1914 17101419 1711 1219131419 12181414191912 101916 10111911 1011 12101119 17121417 191112126 1 10181711 181419 16191018 161412 10141014 101410 191410191217.6 1 1017141114 191112 1711 1210141111191014 1510191912 121711 1719 151216 1019 191410 151914 1917191218 1911121619191414 191112121919 191112 1711 6 1"11191419 1219191415 13191012 1019121017".6 1 181710 1719 1710141914 1219161714126 1 11191419 1219191415 111414 121612 13191012 101411121017:6 1 12181414191912 101916111914 10111911 1011 1916181918111914 15121019151210 1219171012 10121910 191417111017 12 1219131419 1410 1119 1011 1919111412 1916181918 191712101919 1114191112 16121814126 1 1914101711 141419 12121115 171919181910 19161213191714 16141210141014 121711 101217 12 1419 101114191914 1910 1712191918 17141519 1011121514

1313 ) 136 19121017 17191917 1711 10191614 1910 14101119 1719191819 181419 191012161911 12 181419 16191018 16141210141014 1111121017 6 1(15131810191911 10191017 1919171014 1910151811121910126 1 2004). 10111718191211126 1 11191910151219 1711 Chick12 (2002) Dow 19151915 1019121711191017126 1 6 1"1011 151219 171814 1114191112 16121814 12191918 121917141014 1910 14131919 191617191914 12 1614191214 191112126 1 1711 1114141417 1011 151219 16151714 1619101819151911101110141112.6 1 15121011 16171912 10191017 1919171014 10191914 141810 191410 12191314191912126 1 12121115 1214171412 1910121619191912126 1 191810191919121011191714 1711 191012161918 12191314191912 101916 10111911 1910 15191416 1410 1916 1914171117126 1 12 1619151412 101910171119 10191914 1218141419 191417171719 111916121919 161219121512181412 1011191016121914181215141914 1910 1219131419191219161719191419151712171914121217"6 1.(605 10111718191211126 1 12191314191114191112161218141011121917141014 1910 1214171412191619191412171212101916 10111911 141011191011121514 1612191117 17191212.6 1 191519 12121919 6 1"16171417111914 10191214 1910 15121919 1216191419"6 1 10191217126 1 1410151911 191410 16191112 19151915 191415191717 1711 141419 1114191112 16121814 1912131912191410 191911 10191914 12191314191518191914 1019 121619141914 1718 191112 6 1(12 1719 12151614161912 Arestis 12 122004B12Sawyer 1919 1012141411 19141514191419 1711 19141015121011 10141112)126 1 12 1114191112 19191814 1417 1910101919 111419111214 191112 1711 14191415101410 1215191514 10191914 1114191112 16121814 191410191217.6 1 111914101410 1619111214 12141217 17191917 19101014 1019 1914101711 141419 1919171910 16191417191914 12121919 10191214 1910 15121919 1110141011 12 11191419 1712191918 181419 1216191419126 1 19141212191017 1011 1410 1119171514 1711 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1410 1919 1917 1914171017 10191217.6 1 191719171811 (2) 1011 121712 17191112 1419151211 6 1[1618191311 121711]6 1 191112 1711 1711121910171119126 1 1110141011 19121917 12 16141912111914 12191917 121711 1919 1011 151219 1412171919 12191918 101914121217.6 1 15121919 161914171919 171112191017 16121814 1719 191719171811 1918171219 16191119 101914 121217126 1 12 111414 1012191011 141217191914 1910 14101410 1512191914 12141217 1017191917.6 1 1011 151219 19131918126 1 191510191412 1719 1219191418 17191915191910 1011 171112191017 1014121219 1419 15121919 10191914 1519121411 111217 101918191219 1719 191719171811 18151916 10121711 191112126 1 1119141017 1711 191412121910 191410 101513 1919 19151915 171917 1711 191410 1712191918 1719 141013 1916181918 121319171514 1910171711 191412121017.6 1 191410 191919 1019191014 16191018 1618141912 1612191117 101217 1711 15121919 10191914 1711121910171119 12 1519121411 111217 101918191219 1011 13121912 121319171514 12 10171210 11191011121514 111914191814 1218141419 17101017 12 19141910151410 14101119 131519 10191217.6 1

13137 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 191919 151214 1719 17121911111914 1019191014 191212191814 1711 1719 1410 15121919111914 171112191017 1419 1519121411 111217 19131012 1012171017126 1 12 13121912 141013 1916181918 19131012 1719 191719171811 (2) 1910171711 121711 101217126 1 1719191914 14131919 151218191014 19171214 10121711 141919 1711 12121919 1417 17121911 10191713 1914141917 12121919 1719 17121911111914 10171714 1914121217 6 1(1910 15191416 1912181419 12121919 1019 12161511 1719 191719171811 6 1(6 16 026 06 1)).1011 151219 1912191011126 1 191519 1910121619191912 1212191914 ) 1011 1119 17181418 19191710 ( 191510191412 14191017126 1 12121919 101410 151016 191719171811 (2) 191510191412 16141719 1914 171017 12 12121919 141214 101918191219 1910 1519181214 1612191117 101217 1711 191012161919 1212191914 12141217 101719121211 10191217.6 1 1719 15191812 12141217 191510191412 1917191219 1719 12121919 ) 1011 17181418 15121919 1110141011126 1 141019101711 1011 101619 1914191117 1719 1514 171111 1970 12141217 1719121211 191112)126 1 1719 141919141210 191919141411 121711 12101119 191412121910 1019 191510191412 101916111914 10111911 12 1119171210 12121919 1011 16141912 17191112 1216191419 12 101417191914 1916171919 171917.6 1 3-2- 1114191112 101916 10111911 12 1217191718 171417151911 1212191516 14171417 191410 191112 1711 101916 10111911 19141212191017 6 1(12121115 10191017 1919171014)6 1 1217171418 121217 1011 15121914 1711 191612131917 1011 111912 1217191718126 1 14171014 101615111914 1711 1719 1410 1216191419 12 17191411 1718 1719 1217191718 1111121017126 1 15191712 171017 6 1(191410 1011 1410 191710191112 1711 121619141914 1718 1019 12171915 1212181417 131519 1910151016 1914121217)6 1 12 12121919 13191012 6 1(12 1019191019 1019 101916 12121919 111715)6 1 10191217.6 1 191919 6 1(1517191618)6 1 1719 14111919 15191812 191410 101214141115141914 19151616 101914121217.6 1 15191812 191218126 1 1519181214 191112 1711 101916 10111911 19111914 1910151016 1019 101916 10111911 1219161714 121719171814 13 10111718191211 101916 12121919 111715126 1 1411 19101514 10121711 12 1411 19131012126 1 191919 1410161719 17121417 10191217 1711 16191018 15131218 1015191717.6 1 1719 191410 101513 101916 10111911 19121917 101619126 1 11191910 101916 10191017 1919171014 191112126 1 1019 191410 151914 1711 101916 13 10111911 1219191119 1710191912 191112 1910 101916 10111911 10191017 1919171014 10111718191211 1417 1519121411 111217126 1 12 1918101211 10191417 1719 101619 17191212 101916 10111911 121919 191112 1711 1719 121319141915141914111914 1119191914111518191914 1917 101619 16191919 191415141917.6 1 1019 18151916 1019121710 1914111714 1711 1910 1917151914 1219191119 10191214 1914121217126 1 191412121910 151914 171917 1711 1417 101916 10111911 1517191618 12141217 17191917 1711 1719 101916111914 16191414101219 1910 1410126 1 101910171119 15191419 1011 1917151914 121919 10161219111017 101217.6 1

13138 19121017 171219126 1 101916111914 10111911 19191710 191112 1219131419 1910171714 1019 11151215 1119191914111518191914 12 16111910171910 1719121211 1019121017 1910 1914101912 12181414191912 101916 10111911 1719 1914141917 191912101915 101410 16111910171910 12 1119191914111518191914 121913141915181919 101612191117 101217.6 1 101513111914 13121912 1519151211 1719 16131213 1910111919 1719 1718191912 1919101511 101410 16111910171910 12 101916 10111911 1917191215 191112.6 1 191710141912 17191910191714 1711 1719 16131213 1119191914111518191914 1012121211 121711 191112126 1 1219131419 101916 10111911 1019 1119191914111518191914 1919 19121917 1217 12 1219171417 1619191917191711 191112 12 1019 101612 11121714121914 12 10111911 101917191914 12 19111215191711 1910 1619151412 1219171417 17191711 191112(6 16 019996 0 Bernanke 12 171415191910).6 1 111219126 1 101916 10111911 1719161814 19191710 191112 1019 101916111914 101119111914 1711 1719 111515 101410191819181814 1210161419 121711191017 1019111910151919 10191217.6 1 191410 1912141217 19191710 191112 1012191414 1019 191518121014 171916131213 15111910 111919191411 1419 101916 191910 1914141917 171017.6 1 1719 191410 1916191811 191410 1912141217 1014121219 19121917 101513 16191919 1612191117 15191512.6 1 1411191919126 1 10191017 1919171014 1011 171819141814 10161419 1719101217 19151819171912126 1 1912151917 10121710 101916 10111911 121719171814 1011 1710121910 1417 111715126 1 1419 10191212191014 1719 121319141915141914126 1 1019141212191017 101916 10111911 121719171814 1919 191519111011 12 1011 1410 17111216141719 171017.6 1 1719 19171917181912 151216 191412121910 191219111711 10191217 111015191914 1711 0= g Y 191112126 1 101916 10111911 6 1(1219161714)6 1 6 1"121719171814"126 1 a 0 a/ 3 191112 12 191410 16191919191219111914 191119 1719 151218 10191910 1218141419 191417101017.6 1 10191017 1919171014126 1 19151819171912 1019161314 1719 19121917 101916 10111911 121719171814 1219161714 * RR 17191917 6 1(151214 191519 14101410 10191614 12141217 1719121211 10191217)126 1 12 19191710 191112 10191614 1711 1011 1710121910 111715 1217141410 1914171017126 1 1019191019 1019 1010191217.6 1 1216191410 111515 19121017 a 0 /a 3 1 1212181417 ) 12 1010191019191410 12171915 1212181417)126 1 1419 11191910 12NAIRU 101410 1019 19121718 1119191911 191112.6 1 12(Dalziel,2002) 1711 191410 1912141217 19151911101110191610111911 121719171814 1919 17141919 16151914 101412121914 1914171017.6 1 10111718191211 191412121910 191012161919 17191212 1711 12181414191912 1719 191418 1011 16111910171910 6 1(1119191015121011 1711 1011151219 19131918 1719 1514171111 1990 1719 1910151811121910 12 1914191819121912151711 1912191117111217)126 1 12181414191912 1719 191418 1011 1119191914111518191914126 1 12 1719 1216191419 10191914 131917191912 12 1719 1214171412 19191814126 1 111911 1914121219101017 19101419 1011 1218141419 1 - Trend Level

13139 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1719 a 0 /a 3 12121017.6 1 3-3- 1719101918111914 1114191112 16121814 1111 191719171811 1011101219156 1 11191711 10191819 10141910 19141719191017 1711 1114191112 16121814 1910 15191416 1219131419 101916 10111911 1019 121619141914 1718 171918 1914171017 6 1(191719171811 1). 1918101211126 1 10121411101715191014 1711 1719 16191810 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 191519181014 1914101214111017126 1 1011 1719101918111914 1014191714 1912191911 17191711191017 1711 1114191112 16121814 1910 15191416 14101119 121619141914 1718 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 1914171117.6 1 1719 1916191811 1012121211 121711 12121115 Arestis 12 12(2004 A) Sawyer 1212 19121917 1910 14101410 171910191811191414 1711 12101911191414 121711191017 19121917 101513 16191919 19141514191017.6 1 1712 1719101918 19171210191914 1711 2 1 17101919121017 1910 1719101918 19171210191914 1019191417 12 1719101918 19171210191914 12111417 12 191911111914 19141019 12 1719 171410 151918 19171918 141717141519 1111121017 1711 1910 15191416 14101119 101619141413 1019101919111914 19191814 19191710 191112 1019 191619171419 1219161714 191612131917 1219131419 1518191917.6 1 1712 1719101918 19121917 101513 1011 191410 1912141217 1919101215 191412121017 1711 12181414191912 1719 1214171412 19191814 16191417111017151910 12 1619141514191017151910126 1 1019 151914 12141217 191315171917 1719 1019101919111914 19171210191914126 1 1415121011 19141212191017 121619141914 1718 191612131917 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 171117.6 1 1719101918 19171210191914 1019191417 6 1(1711 1719101918 161914171114 12121115 3 10191017 101410 101919141711 121711 191112)6 1 1019 101612 101910171119 1011 1710121910 1219191711101711 1219191710 17191917.6 1 1719101918 19171210191914 12111417 4 6 1(1711 1719101918 1219191010191911 101410 101919141711 1914 121217)126 1 191410 1912141217 1919 1212131415 1914171017 1711 1118191912 19191814 1219191514191017151910126 1 1415121011 19141212191017 17191411 1917121019191912 12 1719 1011191412 121619141914 1718 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 171117.6 1 6 5 1712 19121917 10171714126 1 1719101918 101916 10111911 12 1719101918 161218141210 101919 17191917.6 1 191410 1712 1719101918 1011 121712 1011121514 1011 151914 18151916 121711 1719 16131213 1914101910 161910181412 14191012141014 101410 161218 12 11191419 1719191914141119 1719191017.6 1 12181414191912 1 - The Narrow Credit Channel 2 - The Broad Credit Chanel 3 - Bank Lending Channel 4 - Balance Sheet Channel 5 - Interest Rate Channel 6 - Monetarist Channel

13140 19121017 1 1719 16141912 1719191914141119126 1 1719 13121912 12141217 1719101918 1219131419 13191212 12 191119 1019121017.6 1 1719 191410 15191812126 1 11191012171919 1910 15191416 1916191914 191319151710101711 171918 1914171017 12 151016 151914126 1 12191017 19131915 1011 13191212 191319151710101711 1011121514 17191917.6 1 2 1719101918 121219 10191914 1219131419 1114191112 16121814126 1 1719101918 101916 191910 191112 1711 1910 15191416 16141912111914 121919171912 12 121619141914 16191813 1619191414 171918 1914171017.6 1 19191710191112 19111215191711 1910 191410 1719101918111914 1916121815 10191914 191012161918 111419111216121814 1011 1910101811 1212191415 19111419141011 15111910141417 1711 1016151112191217 1410 1218141419 17191019161210101418 12 101615111619141910 1410 1218141419 1719 121619141914 1718 1915111210 191415191717.6 1 171814191819 191410 1912141217126 1 18151916 1019121710 191410 17191019181119 19141212191017 171917 12 19111210101915 19121519121214 1910 111419111216121814 12 101612 1410 1011171112171117126 1 1711 10141910 1914171017 191012161918 111419111216121814 1011 1910121619191912126 1 1915121919 12 18141911 1910 1712191918 17191915101919 1916121815 12111417 1011121514 17191917126 1 12 1914101711 16171912 12 161910181412 16141210141014 1219131419 1417 1218141419 1719 111419111216121814 19191710191112 1011101219156 1 1510151219101119 10191217121613121319156 1 111015191914 1711 1410 1919 1019 1219131419 19121613 12 1716141614 1711 1719 191719171811 (1) 10191914 101916 10111911 1719 101619 1519151211121711191112 191619141111 1914101919141419.6 1 111419111216121814 19191710 191112 1019 121717191714 1910 1912181419111914 19161213191714 10161419 171112191114 10111917121019191912126 1 16141912 1719191914141119 12 101916 191910126 1 1219131419191214 171912121110191217.6 1 10191614 1910 191410 19121814191119 19191710191112 1011 10121011 161217 1011141919 1519141410 1911191412 1218161412121017 6 1(1913181915126 1 101916 1219161714 191910 1910 191410 171417151911 1711 1919101511 191019171811 1417 17121219 1919 1217141410 1914171017 1912181419 19111914 1915111210 1914121217)6 1 12 11191419 19121814191119 1011 17181418 121913141914 1711 1914121219101017 1019 1912181419111914 17141519 17191212111019121017 191119 1011 15111910 191414141017 6 1(1910 101910 19131918126 1 171112191114 1011 1917121019191912 10191914 1119191914111518191914 12 1010191019191410 10111911121914 101918161211 1719 1414101711126 1 16141912 1719191914141119 1019 121619141914 1718 12 12191314191912 121210141714 1410).6 1 151915 1912141217 151216 191410 16191112 1919 19151915 1914171017 1711 141419 1114191112 101916 10111911 10191417 101410 101916 12121919 1019 19111419 1019191014 1912181419111914 17141519 1919121015 10191217 1419 161419.6 1 1 - Wealth Effect Channel 2 - Exchange Rate Channel

13141 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 3-4- 101916111914 10111911 12 101916 191910 101513111914 19161419 1719 19121917 1210161419 101916111914 10111911 17191210 141919141210 12NCM 12101119 1019 19181915161912 1719161814 12121919 12 1212181417 1219191710 1719121211 191112.6 1 121414121914 101919101914 101916 10111911 1718191812 1914171017 1711 1215191212 101410 101916 10111911 1719161814 12 101916 111914 10111911 1619191414126 1 1019191019 1612191117 101217 1019 101916 19121917 191012161919 12181414191912 101916 191910.6 1 1010191019191410 101916 10111911 1719161814 1011101219156 1 10191819 6 1(1619141410)6 1 1019 1910121619191912 1214171415 1419 1216121412 161218 1119191911 1612191117 101217.6 1 1915191411 19181810126 1 1012141411 101919101914 101916 10111911 181419 1612121214 1011 13121912 1214191014 101916191919 10141112126 1 111914101910 1914 12121910 191012161919 17191212 1711 101410 101916111914 10111911 1719161814(10111012 1011 101916111914 101410 191819181814)6 1 12 121519171912 101916 191910126 1 19191015111914 101916191919 10191217.1719 1914101419 16191112 191119 191410 10141112 1711 141419 1016191411 101919101914 101916 10111911 1910 191712101919 1019161219171919 191112 10181711 141419 1417 1218141419 16141210141014 10121711 1719 101916 10111911126 1 121913141914 1019 101916 191910 1612191117 17191212126 1 12 1010191019191410126 1 1414191114191112 16121814 1910 15191416 101916 191910 1219131419 161217 1919 1019 141914 19141518191917 12 141419 1719 1210161419 1114191112 16121814 10191417 12191314191912 101916 10111911 1919 18151916 10191217 1419 16141911 1719 1914101419 10191417 1011 141017 10171211 1912191911 121217.6 1 191218 1914101711 101916 101910171114 1711 1719 19171919181912 19191014 1011 171919 1914191217 6 1(1719 15111910 111919191411)126 1 101916 1210101418 10191017 1919171014 1010121711126 1 10181711 101916111914 101910171114 19121917 191012161919 171919191414 111914 19191814 191410191217.6 1 191410 101916 111914 101910171114 19101216191914 1914121219101017 12191918 101916 10111911 1116191711111914 1019101714126 1 1912191916 16191411 12 1011 151219 171814126 1 101916 171814 101910171114 11111919126 1 12 101916 19101216191914 12181414191912 16141912111914 11111919 191410191217.6 1 171219 1914101711 1016191411 101919101914 101916 10111911 1019 191410 1912141217 1718191812 17191917 1711 1417 101916 10111911 6 1(1719161814)6 1 10191819126 1 1019 191012161919 17191112 19191012 161218 19191414 11191011121514 17191917.6 1 191919 191510191412 1719 101916111914 10111911 1719161814126 1 1014121219 10191914 191510191412 101916 191910 6 1(1419 1517191618 14181215141914 1910 17191112 101916 191910)6 1 19111215191711 1914121217.6 1 191410 1016191912 1019 101513 1719 19121917 10121119101912 121714171219 101916 191910 1719 1712121911 191712 16191018 1215101416

13142 19121017 1 191112 12 14101914101711 1915101914121719 101916111914101119111719161814 ) 1110 171814181419141910111919191411111914 19191814 1011 17191618)126 1 111010 191510191412 101916 191910 1914121217 191919 10191819 1219 1919101710 161914171919 101916 10111911126 1 10141910 1011 17191112 14171012191612 101916 191910 17191917.6 1 10171211 111219 191410 191112 1711 141419 101916 111914 10111911 1919 191412121910 1011 1718191418 13191519156 1 1719161814 10191914 1117151518191914 101916 12121919 6 1(12 19151219191819 11191419 1911171915)6 1 1210161419 1719171711 191410 1912141217 1719191914 1712 101717 191112:6 1 191218 1914101711 1719 1712121911 191712126 1 19191710 191112 1019 12121411 1011 1911171915 1916121815 1114191112 16121814126 1 121019161411191414 1719 1210161419 101916 111914 10111911 12141217 1719121211 10191217.6 1 171219 1914101711126 1 101916 10111911 1219161714 6 1"121719171814"6 1 1719161814 19121917 10141910 10191914 1914141917 1217191718 101410 121619141914 1718 12 6 1"19121017 1212181417"6 1 ) 12 1010191019191410 1019 101916 13191012 12121919)6 1 19191710 191112 1011 10151214 1019 101916 111914 10111911 1219161714 121719171814 11191419 171212191119 1215191212 1719121211 10191217.6 1 191410 1912141217 10121910 1914171117 6 1(121512 1016191411 101919101914 101916 10111911)6 1 1417 1218141419 161412111211 1719 19191012 1219161714 101916 191910 1011121514 1011 1215191212 101916 191910 17191917.6 1 1910 14101419 1711 12131219 1914121217 19191012 1219161714 101916 191910 1719 191719171811 (1) 1619 1911191412 10191217126 1 1010191019191410 1218141419 161412111211 1719 19191012 1219161714 101916 10111911 1914 1212191017 14131919 19111914 1019 101612 1219161714 191612131917 1719121211 10191217.6 1 4-1214101411 12 1215181418 1714101014 1910 161218 171912101019 1719 191619141111 1019 6 1"1212191516 14171417"1210151912 16121814 17191210101914 1714101014 15191214 171917 19121519121214 1910 191612131917 17181910 191410191217.6 1 191218 1914101711126 1 1915191411 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 12121919 1919 10191214 1910 1919101917 1216191419 12 1910121619191912 1212191914 191417191017126 1 151016 1918151214 1714101014 161218 171912101019 12 12121919 19141212191017 1910 1712191918 191217171714 10161419 15121919 1110141011 6 1(171112191017126 1 16141912111914 12191917191214 12...) 12 19141917181912 1019 1119 111119 171112191017 12 1619151412 10111911121914 101917191514 6 1(10111012 1011 1014191214 171919 101918161211)6 1 10191214 121217.6 1 171219 1914101711126 1 191612131917 17181910 1910 171417151911 191410 19181512 1910 1119 1712 151915 1216191419 12 17191411126 1 1719 19171914 1219131419 121217111914 19161213191714 16191919 1519151211 12 1719 1514 11141718 1 - Overshooting argument

13143 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1 1214191914 12181414191912 16191018 1212141114 1719 111515 151719181412 19161213191714 1914141917 1914121217.6 1 10111718191211126 1 12181414191912 1719 111515 1216191419 191719121819156 1 10191214 1910 12181414191912 1719 1916191914 1119191914111518191914 191112 1711 1011 10121011 161217 1910 1910121917 19171910141019111914 121219101711101711 12 111914101410 1218141419 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514 12 1214171412 1910121619191912 111914121911 191415141917.6 1 101612 19191814126 1 1910 15191416 1212191019141412 1719 1917151914 121919 1011 1910161219 1219191410 1916191914 19191814126 1 12141217 10121119101912 1719 1214171412 10161714101514 101910171119 12 11191419 191211111912 19191814126 1 12 1911191219 1910 1410126 1 12181414191912 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514 14101119126 1 191912101915 1210151912101514 1019 1914141917 11141718111914 1214191914 17191917.6 1 1417 121718 11191711 1910 10151912 1714101014 161218 171912101019 1910 101916 10111911 1718141714 1711 12121115 10191017 1919171014 1210161419 121711 14181910 1914121217126 1 1711 10191017 1919171014 1816191419 19121917 10141910 101910171119 1919 1219191410 1914171017.6 1 101910171119 1019 101916 10111911 1914 1711 1910 191510121710 101916 1519121411 1011 101916 10111911 10191017 1919171014 1011 171112 1914141417126 1 1916171919 1011 1917151914 121919 191417101017 12 1219191914 12161914191119 10191914 171914191512 1917121019191912 1919 10191412191711 1914101919141017(1019 12121411 1011 19181019191912 191112191017191917 19171210191914).6 1 1519121411 111217 19141212191017 1019 12121411 1011 12191414151912 12 1214171412 10161714101514 101910171119126 1 16171912 1019101919 12 10151912 1011 19141117126 1 1912181419 10191217.6 1 1219191119 1719 1219171012 1011 121619141910191914 14101119 1917151913 191412121017 12 10191914 191410 1910161219 1116191711111914 1019101714 121718 19141514191017.6 1 101910161917191612 1219191119 161218 1919 1910 101410 1914101917 2 12 12 151419 161218 101916141919101711 1912141217 1011 111515 1216191419 10191914 10151117191914 161218 1011121514 17191917.6 1 101910171119 1519121411 111217 161217 1919 1019 151110 1914101910 191712101919 121919 1514191017151910 1218141419 191417111017.6 1 1719 1516141612126 1 101910171119 1719 1219191415 1916121815126 1 1719191914 1719141912 19121519121214 1910 12191414151912 10161714101514 1111121017.6 1 Dow,2002).(Chick and 101612 181419 1019101714 101410 1019 1719141912 191215191212 12191414151912 10161714101514 1912191411 191112.6 1 191410 1218141419 1719 111515 19151816 101916 10111911 10141112 10181711 12181414191912 1719 101916 10111911 19111914 191112 1711 1917191014101914 1919 1519191119 1914171017 1711 1719 1410-11191910151219 1711 1719 19171917181912 (1) 12 (2) 191819151611 1217126 1 1719 19171210 NCM 101410 121217 12141217 17191917.6 1 1215191212 1219161714 191410 1 1712 19171210 1919101215 1011 161217 11191011121514 19101216191914 191410 1212171119 1914 10191217.6 1 2-11191910151219 1711 171914191512 121919 19121410 161816 161218 1914 121217126 1 101910161917191612 121919 19121410 171711 191410 1214171412 121711 12 161218 1914141917 121711 1719 111515 191612131917 1919 17191112 1914 171117-6 1 1912191419.6 1

13144 19121017 12191414151912 1219191514191017151910 1019 1219191418 14101119 1011 10151117191914 11161917111119 1218191614 19141019191417 (1996 Howells,.(Arestis and 161218 1719 1417 151914141017 1212191914 1914141917 1914121217126 1 12 101916 12121919 1019 101916 191510191412 1719 1816141911 161218 1219131419 19141518191917126 1 191919 161218 1011 16121714 161217 1719 111414 121919141514 19121410 12121919 10141112 6 1(151214 191519 161218 12 161419121119 1019 101916111914 141711191014 191217 17101017)6 1 1910 101910 19131918126 1 1011 (2003) Arestis 12 Sawyer 191919141711 101919141417.6 1 101910171919171014 1011 15121919171919 101916101119111718141714 1919 12181414191914171117126 1 1711 19101419 1011 191410 16191112 1914121217 1711 1719 10181017191712126 1 1411 1014191211191414 1019 101916 10111911101910171919171014 1219131419151819121211 1419 1410 1919 1217141410 19141019191417.6 1 191410 141719121412171718141714 1719 1215181418 111419111216121814 1910 171417151911171912101019 10121710161218191112 1711 1011 151219 171814 1719 191710141912 161218 17191210101914 1714101014 1910 1410 18151812 121711 191112.6 1 191410 101513 6 1[171417151911 1714101014]6 1 191719121819 1912191911 1011 1114191112111914 1910121014 1019 13181915171417 10191017 1919171014 12 19181915161912 1919101215 1011 101916 191910 1719121211 191112.6 1 1912181419 1718141714 121319141915141914 10191914 1417 10191017 1919171014 1719 151218 1712191910 11141718 1214191914 12 1910101919 19131814 1710121918 10191914 1114191112 16121814 16141912 19111914 17191411 1719 121919141514 191112 1711 1816191419 1914191514 1519191119 1019191417.6 1 10191017 1919171014 1719 111515 12111417 19141212191017 1011 151219 101912101019 16141912 17191411 1919 1719 121417141214 1711 10161714101514 1011 1114111219 19191814 19171519 1914171017 1217141410 1019191417 (1989 (Moore 12 13151511 27. 191519 10191017 1919171014 101212191017 101916 1210101418 161217 1919 1719 1417 6 1"101916 121719171814"6 1 1210161419 171017126 1 1011 101512 1912131914 191412121910 1910 19171418 1719101217 1216191419 191119 1217.6 1 1919 1914121219101419 1719 1910121719 191912101915 101410 101916 1210101418 1210161419 121711 12121115 10191017 1919171014 12 11191419 101916111914 10111911 1919 1719 101619 101514191419126 1 12 1910 14101419 1011 191410 16191112 1019111419 1711 141419 101916 1210101418 1914 1212191017 10191914 18181011 10191719101217 1216191419 1011 171919 1519151211 12121711 10151912 1714101014 161218 171912101019 1011 1911191412 101916 10111911 10191017 1919171014 1719 1217141410 111515 1719121914 101916111914 10111911 1614 10191711126 1 12 1914101711 10191017 1919171014 101916 1210101418 1718141714 1919 1217141410 12 19141212191017 1410 1919 1917191918

13145 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1019191417 1919 1011 1911191412 121019161211 191112.6 1 191410 1912141217 1011 1410 19171019 10141112 1711 1417 1919101511 1417 1011 1417 101410 101916 10111911 10191017 1919171014 12 11191419 101916111914 10111911 12141211 12141217 17191917 6 1(12 1011 151219 161913126 1 12181414191912 101916 10111911 10181017191712 1912191916 16191411 19191710 191112 1011141919 17191219 1910 1218141419 101916 10111911 10191017 1919171014 10191217).6 1 191912101915 101410 1119 101916 10111911 19121613 12 101916 10191017 1919171014 19141212191017 121512 1219131419 1914191217111914 1910 1712191918 10191217126 1 1711 12191918 1914101910 16171912 1019101919 1114111219 1019101714 12 14101411 1711 12191414151912 10161714101514 101919141711 1914121217126 1 191415191717.6 1 1919101511 1718141214 1711 1910 1916191914 1119191914111518191914 1011 111214 1611 19101719101119 1419141910 17191917 10141910191017 1719 1711121911 10121710 1910191017 19191814 10191914 19191710 1119161210 12161217 1119191914111518191914 191112 1711 1719 12191617 161412 1910 1914141917 1611 19101719101119 13121912 191415141917.6 1 161119101719101119 1910 1518121211 10191914 1219191410 1119191914111518191914 1719 1711121911 16191919 19141514191017126 1 191919 10191914 1414101711 12141217 101719191017.6 1 111515 17191419171119 1019 191510191412 1719 1916191914 111919191411 1518191914 1217171418 1914 121217.6 1 1915111219 161218 171912101019 6 1(10191017)126 1 1711 101910171119 1019 1910101914 1410 16191719 1011 161816 121919 10191914 1219191410 19191814 1119191914111518191914 1111121017126 1 17181417 1212141415 15191414101714 191112 1711 1719 1410 191510191412 1119191914111518191914 19101419 1011 1511121912 1611 19101719101119 12 17191419171119 1914121217.6 1 1919 19126 1 101916 10111911 1219191119 1919101511 1210151912101514 1019 101916 10111911 1210161419 121711 1910 111214 10191017 1919171014 17191917.6 1 171219191814 1711 1210161419 12 1218141419 101916 10111911 12121115 10191017 1919171014 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 191417111017126 1 1719 191912101915 101410 16111910171910 12 1119191914111518191914 1910 1911191412 101110191414 10191612191719191017.6 1 1719 1417 171417151911 191519191514126 1 191519 10191017 1919171014 101212191017 101916 10111911 1919 1011 10151214 1218141419 171117 1711 161119101719101119 12 1119191914111518191914 1011 151219 161412111211 1719 1115121514 1711 1910151016 1019 1217191718 101612 17191411 10191217 1019191019 12121017126 1 6 1(12191417 1719 191212181918 17191918)126 1 1719 1410 13121912 111414 1912171814 1910 10191012 1719101217 1216191419 12141217 101612191117 17191212.6 1 5-1719 1215181418 1714101014 161218 171912101019126 1 101612 1114191112 16121814 1414111211 111015191914 1711 1019 161218 1011 13121912 171912101019 1915121919 1914121217126 1 1916171919 17191411 161218 1011 1710121910 101916141919101711126 1

13146 19121017 12121115 1216191419 10191914 161218 1217141410 1914121217.6 1 1114191112 16121814126 1 121718 1114191112 101916 10111911 1011 161217 191415141917126 1 12 101612 111419111216121814 1011121514 1011 12191314191912 101916 10111911 1019 191218141911191419161213191714 1919121015 1919 17191917.6 1 1719 1410 13121912101513 1719 19121917 1914101711 101916111914 10111911 1411 101217 1219131419191214 19191710 191112 17191212111019121017126 1 12 1914101711 17191411 12 1914101910 191410 12191314191912101919141911171915111419111214 1011 15171719151416191018 16141210141014 191112126 1 1419121912 191414191017.6 1 5-1- 12191414151912 10161714101514 12 161910181412 161412 10141014 1114191112 16121814 1011 12191414151912 10161714101514126 1 191412121910 1011 1910101811 17191918 121913141915181919 1019 1216131413 13191212 101410 171919191414111914 1916121815 101519141112.6 1 1218141419 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514126 1 1011 151219 19131918 1011 111912 171919191414111914 1016171410111219 12 15191410 1910 17191919141411191414 1019 161910181412 10161714101514 17191219126 1 1216191419 10191914 191410 1719191914141119 1919 1218141419 1914171117 1711 1011 10121011 161217 19101419 1011 1218141419 1719 16141912111914 10111014 12 1010191019191410 1218141419 1719 101916111914 101910171114 10111014 191410 1719191914141119 1914121217.6 1 10191914 141017111211 171919191414111914 19191814 1711 1417 16141912 13191012 19111914 1719191017 6 1(191318 1116191711 111914 1019101714)126 1 12191415 191112 1711 16141912 1019141212191017 1218141419 171017 121814 101916 10111911 1410 1719191914141119 19141212191017 1217171418 121217 6 1(19131819156 1 12 1019101711191414 1711 1912191411 1019 191510191412 1216191419 10191914 1116191711 1111121017126 1 1914121219101017 101916 10111911 1410 1919 1619141410 10141912191017).6 1 19181915161912 1919101215 1011 12191414151912 10161714101514 19141212191017 1914191914 1114191112 16121814 1919 1910 15191416 101916111914 10111911 10111014126 1 121512 1219131419 16191919 171117 12 191410 101916111914 10111014 1019 121619141914 1718 191319 1914151819191017.6 1 1915121919 101910171119 171910191911 16121912151214 171919191414111914 14101119 1919 191412121910 1719 16191810 12191414151912 10161714101514 1019191114 171917.6 1 1910 14101419 1711 1417 17101319 191119 16121912151214 171919191414 101910171119126 1 1219191119 19141019121017 1711 1011 151219 10111014 1910 10161714101514 1719121914 10191612191719191017126 1 1218141419 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514 101910171119126 1 1219191418 14101119 1011 1917151914 121919 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 1914171117.6 1 1019191114 14191917 1719 171910191811191414 1711 1114191112 16121814 1910 15191416 14101119 191012161918 191414191017126 1 1711 16101819 101919 10191711 1217126 1 101612 1414191110101714 191712101919 12121115 101910171119 12 1218141419 1719 111916121919 101916 111914 10111911 1919 1619151910121910 191411191017.6 1 16191112 191410 191112 1711 141419 1218141419 1719 101916 1210101418 10191017 1919171014126 1 19101419 1011 1218141419 1719 1914101910 12 121718 1414191110101714 191712101919 1914121217.6 1 101916 10111911 101918191219 10191914

13147 1919111412 12 101612 1114191112 16121814 111015191914 1711 161218 1011 13121912...6 1 1219191119126 1 1011 1712 17181418 19141117 171719 161917191612 121919 1919 191510191412 1914171117.6 1 191218 1914101711126 1 10111911 16191719161214 101918191219 191112 12 191410 1912141217 111010 191510191412 191410 191512191918 1914121217 1711 1010151911 121919 151419101711 16191719 1011 161917191612 10111911 191217181611 1010191217.6 1 171219126 1 111916121919 16121912151214 1219191119 19191710 191112 1910 1917151914 191712101919 1011 1619121211111914 1019 19141117 1719 12 1719191914 101910171114 19101216191914 1619141410126 1 1011 111912 161912121111191414 1019 19141117 10191819 12 1719191914 101910171114 19101216191914 10141917 191012161918 16141719 171017.6 1 1119141019101711 101916 10111911 1219191119 191510191412 191414191017126 1 19121613 1914121217 1711 10171414 1910 1619121211111914 1019 101910171114 19101216191914 1619141410126 1 1719191914 101910171114 17191219 1910 101916 10111911 1219191119 1111121017.6 1 1611 16121912151214 1219191119 1910 1619121211111914 1019 19141117 1619141410 1011 111912 1619121211111914 1019 19141117 10191819 191012161918 191414191017.6 1 1719 1410 13121912 19191710 191112 101910171119 10111012 1011 191510191412 1719 101916 1210101418126 1 1011 141914 1914101711 101916 12111114181912 1919 1716141619156 1 1011 191017191011 191510191412 101916 1210101418 10191819 1010191017126 1 1019 15191712 1011 111912 1414191110101714 19171210191914 1014121219 1219171012 10121910 17111017(1910 101910 19131918 12 Weiss,1981.(Stiglitz and 1219 14191414 1711 12181414191912 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514 6 1(1011 19171014 151112191711 1410)6 1 1011 151219 17161416 1910 12181414191912 1719 101916 1210101418 10191017 1919171014 1210171412 10171017126 1 12 191410 12181414191912 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514126 1 111515 12 111916121919 121619141914 1718 1919 121512 1219131419 16191919 171117126 1 161910181412 16141210141014 14131919 101916 1210101418 17191112 191414191017.6 1 1910 171417151911 12191414151912 10161714101514 19191710 191112 161910181412 16141210141014 12 161212 191912101915 101410 101916 10111911 12 121619141914 1718 12 191912101915 101410 121619141914 1718 12 101916 12121919 6 1(14171014 11191910 14141014 1711 10151912 6 1"1212191516 14171417"6 1 1019 1410 101019 121711 191112)6 1 101419 1718191912 1112141918 10191217.6 1 1119141019101711 101513 1217126 1 12181414191912 1719 12191414151912 10161714101514 19191710 191112 1011 12181414191912 1912171717 1714151914 19101419 121217126 1 1711 19141212191017 1719 1614121017 101916 10111911 12 121619141914 1718126 1 191612181918 1914141917 171017.6 1 5-2- 19181915161912 1919101215 1011 101916 10111911 12161214 1711 1019 1916171919 17191411 161218 1011 13121912 101912101019 1915121919 1914121217126 1 1412171919 1914121217 1711 1114191112 16121814 1011 19171014 1710121918 1019 17191411 161218 1719 15191712 19141212191017 10171210 12121411 1011 19181915161912 1919101215 1011 101916