Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org) Title Sub Title Author Publisher 既存財政学批判と財政社会学 : その方法的根幹としての 財政史的考察方法 の検討 "A way of looking at fiscal history" : fiscal sociology as a critique of the previous theory of public finance 茂住, 政一郎 (Mozumi, Seiichiro) 慶應義塾経済学会 Publication year 2015 Jtitle 三田学会雑誌 (Mita journal of economics). Vol.107, No.4 (2015. 1),p.629(85)- 649(105) Abstract 歴史的アプローチを重視する既存財政学は, その依拠する哲学的基礎のため, 結果的に衰退の一途をたどることとなった 統計や現状を見た, 今この時を生きる観察者が心揺り動かされた一時代に関して, 史料に基づいた歴史分析を行い, そこから明らかになったことを通じて現状批判, 既存財政学批判, 政策批判を行うこと, これが財政社会学の方法的根幹である 財政史的考察方法 の役割であることを論ずる Notes 特集 : 財政学の批判的検討 Genre Journal Article URL http://koara.lib.keio.ac.jp/xoonips/modules/xoonips/detail.php?koara_id=an00234610-20150101 -0085
既存財政学批判と財政社会学 その方法的根幹としての 財政史的考察方法 の検討 A Way of Looking at Fiscal History : Fiscal Sociology as a Critique of the Previous Theory of Public Finance 茂住政一郎 (Seiichiro Mozumi) 歴史的アプローチを重視する既存財政学は その依拠する哲学的基礎のため 結果的に衰退の一途をたどることとなった 統計や現状を見た 今この時を生きる観察者が心揺り動かされた一時代に関して 史料に基づいた歴史分析を行い そこから明らかになったことを通じて現状批判 既存財政学批判 政策批判を行うこと これが財政社会学の方法的根幹である 財政史的考察方法 の役割であることを論ずる Abstract Previous public finance studies, giving importance to a historical approach, ended up inadvertently causing their own decline due to the dependence on their philosophical basis. We, as observers living in this age, can revisit an era in which we are interested by seeing statistics and the present condition, and historical analysis based on historical materials. Only through these results, we may perform a critique of present condition, existing public finance theories, and policies. This paper argues that this is A Way of Looking at Fiscal History, which is the methodological root of Fiscal Sociology.
107 4 2015 1 R. J. Schumpeter 1918 1983 10 2007 1997 1960 1949 1931 1 Martin et al. 2009 Pierson 2001 Brownlee 1996 1 2008 35 1997 7 85 629
2007 67 Ibid. 2007 55 Ibid. 2007 69 1 2014 75f. 19 2007 40ff. 1870 2014 78f. 86 630
1939 20ff. 2013 62f. Ibid. 2013 58 Ibid. 2013 2 Ibid. 2013 61 1936 77 Schumpeter 1918 1983 5ff. 87 631
2 2 3 4 5 2 2006 119 2008 75 1993 132 19 2014 20 263 3 1932 317 11 1993 132 1996 10 4 1931 286 1996 12 88 632
10 1993 145 6 1939 10ff. Ibid. 1939 102 8 1949 3ff. 9 7 5 1931 49f. 6 1922 11 1925 14 3 4 46 47 421 7 1929 25f. 8 1932 4 89 633
10 40 11 12 3 9 1978 1960 1978 v 10 11 1996 12 3 2014 135ff. 90 634
13 2006 121 14 2008 47 15 13 1955 iff. 1955 44 14 1955 6 1982 115 15 2008 46 Ibid. 2008 62 91 635
2006 121f. 1982 120 2012 56 4 16 Kocka 1986 2000 22ff. Collingwood 1946 1970 132 16 Engels 1888 1960 62 92 636
17 18 2014 83f. Ibid. 2014 81f. Bacon 1605 1974 77ff. Ibid. 1605 1974 133 Ibid. 1605 1974 131 19 17 1936 146 18 1931 115 93 637
Collingwood 1946 1970 138ff. Descartes 1637 1997 46 19 20 1980 19 Descartes 1637 1997 13f. 20 Collingwood 1946 1970 65f. 94 638
2001 4f. 5 21 Vico 1709 1987 18ff. Vico 1710 1988 49f. 22 Ibid. 1710 1988 46f. 21 Vico 1709 1987 154 95 639
23 Ibid. 1710 1988 33ff. 24 25 Vico 1709 1987 159 Ibid. 1709 1987 35 26 22 cogitatio intelligentia Vico 1710 1988 33 23 2003 46 24 25 96 640
27 Vico 1744 1975 118ff, 224ff, 541f. Collingwood 1946 1970 208ff. Croce 1920 1952 15ff. 26 Vico 1744 1975 156 27 Descartes 1637 1997 34ff. Collingwood 1946 1970 69 97 641
Ibid. 1920 1952 37ff. Ibid. 1920 1952 47ff. 28 29 Berlin 1954 1966 267ff. 30 Carr 1961 1962 90ff. 31 32 28 Carr 1961 1962 39f. 29 Berlin 1954 1966 241 30 Berlin 1954 1966 247 31 Berlin 1954 1966 172f. 98 642
6 Croce 1920 1952 15ff. Durkheim 1895 1978 71ff. Ibid. 33 1895 1978 38ff. 34 Ibid. 1895 1978 24 32 33 99 643
Berlin 1954 1966 267ff. 35 2014 79ff. Weber 1917 1982 311 36 Ibid. 1917 1982 311 Weber 1904 1998 25f. 34 Durkheim 1895 1978 58f. 35 Lefebvre 1934 2007 36 100 644
Weber 1917 1982 311 37 1991 14 37 Weber 1917 1982 315 101 645
38 1939 21 39 38 1991 19 Ibid. 1991 24 39 2013 24 102 646
Bacon, F. 1605 The Advancement of Learning. 1974 Berlin, I. 1954 Historical Inevitability, London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson. 1966 Brownlee, W. E. ed. 1996 Funding the Modern American State, 1941 1995: The Rise and Fall of the Era of Easy Finance, Woodrow Wilson Center Press and Cambridge University Press. Carr, E. H. 1961 What is History?: The George Macalay Trevelyan Lectures Delivered in the University of Cambridge January-March 1961, London: Macmillan. 1962 Collingwood, R. G. 1946 The Idea of History, Clarendon Press. 1970 Croce, B. 1920 Teoria e Storia Della Storiografia in Filosofia come Scienza Dello Spirito, 4, Bari: Laterza. 1952 Croce, B. 1965 La Storia Come Pensiero e Come Azione, 7 a ed., Bari: Laterza. 1988 Descartes, R. 1637 Discours de La Methode. 1997 Durkheim, É. 1895 Les Régles De La Méthode Sociologique, Presses Universitaires de France. 1978 Engels, F. 1888 Ludwig Feuerbach und der Ausgang der klassischen deutschen Philosophie. 1960 Kocka, J. 1986 Sozialgeschichte: Begriff-Entwicklung-Probleme, Auflage, Gottingen. 2000 103 647
Lefebvre, G. 1934 Foules Révolutionnaires. 2007 Martin, I. W., A. K. Mehrotora and M. Prasad eds. 2009 New Fiscal Sociology: Taxation in Comparative and Historical Perspective, Cambridge University Press. Pierson, P. 2001 From Expansion to Austerity: The New Politics and Spending, in Martin A. Levin, Marc K. Landy and Martin Shapiro eds., Seeking the Center: Politics and Policymaking at the New Century, Georgetown University Press. Schumpeter, J. A. 1918 Die Krise des Steuerstaats, Graz and Leipzig: Leuschner & Lubensky translated in Schumpeter, 1954 The Crisis of the Tax State, International Economic Papers, No. 4 1983 Vico, G. 1709 De Nostri Temporis Studiorum Ratione, Introduzione, traduzione e note a cura di Vincenzo De Ruvo, 1941, Padova: CEDAM. 1987 Vico, G. 1710 De Antiquissima Italorum sapientia ex linguae latinae originibus eruenda, Liber Primus sive Metaphysicus, Napoli. 1988 Vico, G. 1744 Principj di Scienza Nuova in La Letteratura Italiana, Storia e Testi, Milano: Riccardo-Ricciardi. 1975 Weber, M. 1904 Die Objektivität sozialwissenschaftlicher und sozialpolitischer Erkenntnis in Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft und Sozialpolitik, Bd. 19, 1904, Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 22 87 1998 Weber, M. 1917 Der Sinn der Wertfreiheit der Soziologischen und ökonomischen Wissenschaften, in Logos, Internationale Zeitschrift für Philosophie der Kultur. Hrsg. v. R. Kroner u. G. Mehlis. Bd. VII, Heft 1, Tübingen, 40 88 1982 1 299 362 1996 133 1 34 2014 2008 59 2 35 59 1931 1932 1 1 293 320 2001 6 1955 XIV 2013 1939 1960 1997 2008 30 1 45 54 1929 1949 2008 30 1 70 88 2014 1993 1936 42 6 104 648
2007 2014 10 74 85 1955 1982 11 106 134 1960 1936 2 41 87 2003 96 3 2006 30 28 2 118 144 2012 54 3 54 56 1978 1991 105 649