P.Q. G.D.H. G.D.H.

P.Q. G.D.H. P.Q. G.D.H. G.D.H. G.D.H. NPO NGO

P.Q. G.D.H. G.D.H.

G.D.H. G.D.H. G.D.H. -ism Hirst : : - systematic deductive hypothetical experimental Latham : : -

: Hirst : - T.H. : - Hirst : G.D.H. G.D.H.

A.W. G.D.H. Wright : - Hirst : - : Penty, A.J. Taylor, G.R.S. New Age Orage, A.R. Hobson, S.G. G.D.H. : - Wright : - : :

G.D.H. G.D.H. Cole, George Douglas Howard the Great Unrest Morton and Tate : - [ ] : the National Guilds League

Hirst : Hirst : Cole b[st ]: ST: - Warren, M.E. Warren : -

Cole b: ST: ST: - ST: - administrative propagandist ST: -

political association vocational association appetitive association religious association provident association philanthropic association beneficence sociable association theoretic association Cole ST: ch.iv, XI ST: -

functional democracy ST: ST: functional associations ST: -

ST: Guild Cole a[gsr ]: - Gild good workmanship GSR: ff A B C D E F GSR: ch.iv, VI - B A GSR: -

ST: [ : ] ST: - - ST: -- ST:

ST: ST: ST: - perversion opposition confusion ST: - joint council

ST: ch.viii - a b c d e f GSR: - demarciation GSR: -

Hirst : Hirst : -

Hirst : Hirst :

Hirst : Hirst : Hirst : - Hirst : - ST: -

Hirst : ff

Hirst : Hirst : Hirst : - Hirst :

G.D.H.

T.H. : - Cole, G.D.H. Conflicting social obligations, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Vol.xv, -. Hirst : Penty [ ] an uncompromising medievalist Wright : Carpenter : ch. - [ ] : Cole b: ST: Carpenter, L.P. G.D.H.Cole: AN INTEL- LECTUAL BIOGRAPHY, London: Combridge Univesity Press. Cole, G.D.H. a Guild socialism re-stated, London: L. Parsons [ ] b Social Theory, London: Methuem[ ] [ ] -

- P. - Hirst, P. Representative democracy and its limits, Cambridge: Polity Press. ed. The Pluralist theory of the state : selected writings of G.D.H. Cole, J. N. Figgis, and H. J. Laski, London: Routledge. Associative democracy: new forms of economic and social governance, Cambridge: Polity Press., E.J. [ ] G.D.H. - - J.N. Latham, E The Group Basis of politics: Notes for a Theory, The American Political Science Review, Vol. XLVI, June. Morton, A.L. and G.TateTHE BRITISH LABOUR MOVEMENT - : A HISTO- RY, London: Lawrence and Wishart LTD., D. [ ] : G.D.H. - - Penty, Arther J. [ ] Old World for New: A Study of the Post-Industrial State, London: Pickering and Chatto. - - Warren, M.E.Democracy and association, Princeton: Princeton University Press. Wright, A.W.G.D.H.COLE and Socialist Democracy, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Towards the Revival of Associationalism: Critical Analysis of Hirst s Interpretation of G.D.H. Cole s Social Theory Shioto FUKUCHI : The purpose of this paper is to critique P. Q. Hirst s interpretation of English classical associationalist G. D. H. Cole s social theory. Hirst claims that Cole s normative assumptions about associations are unwarranted and unjustified. However, Hirst views associations as service providers in his associational alternative governance model. On this point, we can say that Hirst and Cole share a similar view of associations, because Cole also emphasizes the importance of service-providing associations, which he calls administrative associations. We think such a view of associations is incorrect. Ignoring this incorrect view will hinder the real revival of associationalism. : Associative democracy, P. Q. Hirst, G.D.H.Cole, Guild socialism Graduate Student, Graduate School of Sociology, Ritsumeikan University