AR-10J 2006
DRC 10 19
DRC 2006 DRC DRC RMA 11 DRC 15 DRC 21 DRC 29 DRC 37 DRC 45 DRC 53 DRC 57 DRC 65 DRC 75 DRC 83 DRC 89 DRC
97 ( ) DRC 105 DRC QDR 113 DRC 119 ( ) DRC 125 DRC Lessons Learned ( ) 133 DRC 141 DRC
DRC Wikipedia 1 1
2
3
3 4 4 61 5 27 71 15 6 13 4
5
ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/ IDA Institute for Defense Analyses RUSI Royal United Services Institute for Defence andsecurity Studies 2006 10 15 2006 10 15 6
( )DRC 9.11 1950 5 75,000 1954 7
NSC GPS 8
9
10
RMA DRC DRC DRC DRC DRC 1.27 RMA RMA Military Critical Technology 70 40 RMA 11
COTS NCW RMA RMA RMA UAV 3 DII COE IDDN Interagency NCW 12
RMA MD COTS RMA RMA NBC NBC Joint and Alliance/Coalition Interoperability RMA C4ISR NCW NCO 13
3 RMA to protect our information networks from attack 14
DRC 21 10 15
2002 5 2004 11 60 16
1998 SDR 2003 9 17
1998 SDR 4 18
9 NCW Network Centric Warfare NEC Network Enabled Capability C4ISR Robust Responsive Reconfigurable Invisible 19
4 JDCC Joint Doctrine Concept Center DCDC(The Development, Concepts and Doctrine Centre) 2004 3 JDP 01 2004 12 20
DRC 1951 50 1951 1957 5 1960 1980 1965 40 37.9 1975 50 54.3 1984 59 69.2 1997 09 68.2 2005 17 75.1 40 60 1945 60 21
NATO NATO 60 60 1965 1970 1980 1970 9 1 1980 1988 22
2006 9 NATO 3. 2006 7 10 20 10 23
2001 30 ODA 1980 68 1989 1994 2004 30 ODA 24
2006 2 4 QDR: Quadrennial Defense Review 2002 NPR Nuclear Posture Review 3 1 3 C4ISR 2012 17,00 2,200 2002 5 1957 11. 1991 PKO 25
NATO 1960 PAC 26
1999 10 FX PAC3 PAC3 27
200 10 2001 28
DRC 2006 5 2005 10 : 1 2006 5 2 2 29
IT 1997 9 2 30
2003 12 1969 1985 1998 1 12 2002 4 1998 12 31
GSOMIA General Security of Military Information Agreement 1980 GSOMIA 63 17 GSOMIA 2005 10 32
(2+2) : GSOMIA GSOMIA GSOMIA 5 BJOCC : Bilateral Joint Operations Coordination Center 33
BJOCC BJOCC BJOCC BJOCC BJOCC 2 ROE Rule of Engagement ROE ROE (COP : Common Operational Picture) CTP : Common Tactical Picture COP CTP (C2 : Command and Control) (ISR : Intelligence, Surveillance, Reconnaissance) (ACTD : Advanced Concept of Technology Demonstration) IPT : Integrated Product Team IPT LINK-11 LINK-16 STANAG (NATO Standardization Agreement) STANAG NATO NATO STANAG STANAG 34
ICD : Interface Control Document C2BMC : Command & Control Battle Management Communication C2BMC JADGE JNIC Joint National Integration Center 1 1 JNIC MDA Missile Defense Agency & (M&S) JNIC 50 700 35
2008 7 5 AWACS Way of Thinking 36
DRC 37
38
39
40
41
42
RMA C4ISR 43
1996 SM-3 PAC-3 44
DRC ECAFE 45
46
47
48
49
SLOC 50
51
52
DRC 2006 10 9 7 5 7 53
800 4 54
55
NSC C4ISR 56
DRC - 10 8 10 26,925 25,930 6,358 4,878 4,450 2,118 1,693 1,436 1,290 1,258 SIPRI 10 1-2 - 10 UAE 11,677 8,526 5,263 3,395 3,298 3,103 2,755 2,581 2,177 2,018 23 986 SIPRI 57
95 2000-2004 303 6,649 409 900 11,112 510 400 1,680 953 1,562 324 1,094 SIPRI 66 1,678 1,064 796 549 443 427 58
Su-27 2-1 1989 1994 27% 95 93 2005 295 2,440 8.28 18% 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 118.5 274.0 330.0 366.0 395.0 420.0 476.0 510.0 560.0 625.0 61.1 74.0 76.0 97.0 126.0 145.0 170.0 200.0 223.0 250.0 1990 T-34 85 59 100 APDSFS 1950 T-54 5,000 T-55 T-62 69 90 80 105 L- NATO - 85 125 T-72 96 98 51 125 71 HN -5-5A/C,-6 SA- ( ) 1975 59
QW- 91 HQ 1960 SA-2 1959 HQ-2 500 1994 S-300 S-300 SA-10 1,000 SA-17Grizzly SA-19Grisom SIPRI 1959 Ming 87 20 100 16 74 Han 87 Xia 93 19 MVC Song 95 MTU12V 22 Xia 1957 Luda 3,670 16 4,800 60
2000 CSS-N-22 6,500 HY- CSS-N- 97 YJ- CSS-N- CSS-N-22 120Km 2.5 20m 300Kg 160Kg 120Km 2000 MiG-17 MiG-19 MiG-21 J-5 J-6 J- F-86 F-104, 60 750 J-7 MiG-21 50 J-8 1964 MiG-21 85 FCS Zuk-8 R-11F 94 Su-27 400 m, 150Km J-10 90 61
PL -2-5 -7-8 -12 AA AIM- PL- - 05-06 PL-12 AIM- 120AMRAAM 1990 AA- R-60 Km AA-10 R-27 40Km AA-11 R-73 AAM AA 12 R-77 Su-27 YJ -1/2-8 -61-81 -63 expected AS 2000-63 expected AS-17 Kh-31P1 115Km AS-18 Kh-59 1990 NATO 62
04 10 40 Su-30 Su-30 Su-34 F-16 ) 2004 EU EU EU 05 EU EU 63
1990 2005 SIPRI 2004 2005-64
DRC 1982 447 1999 2005 1.5 2004 1966 2005 7 2005 10 65
2006 EEZ 2005 1 22 P3C 9 9 P3C 137 100 P-3C EEZ 5 66
53 SH60J SH60K P C80 ASW AAW ASUW 0 F-2 0 25 44 SSBN 67
ASW Ka-31 AEW 5 600 DF-1 1000 DF-1MOD1, 2000 DF-21C 2010 2 SSK 2 SSN SSN LACM 70 12 14 039 SONG ~3 4 636M K 2006 2004 LADA YUAN 2010 35 SSK SSN 093 SHANG SSN2 2003 III SSN SSN 093 SSN 68
10 2010 180 ASM-2, P-3C ASM-1C SAM 30 2002 F-15J AAM-4 2004 HMD(Helmet Mounted Display ) 1993 2010 AAM-5 F-4J F/A-22 F-35 JSF(Joint Strike Fighter) F/A-18E, F-35 80 P-3C Y-8 100 Su-30 F-15 HMD Helmet Mounted Display 69
R-77 AAM SU-30 SU-30MKK SU-30MK2 100 Kh-31A 110 Kh-31p 2006 285 H- MK JH-7 3 JH-7A JH-7A 50 YJ-81K 130 YJ-82K 280 JY-62 TU-22M3 TU-142ASW/ TU-22M3 TU-142 ASW 2005 9 30 IL-76D IL-78M SY30MKK H-6U SU30 1 SU 33 J-10 AWACS 2006.7.11 2007 20 H- U SU-MKK 2005 9 IL-76D SU-MMK 70
JH-7/A, J-8II,J-10 SU-27 J-11 2006 SU-30MKK 76 SU-30MK 48 SU-27SK 38 95 2006 F-15J/DJ 203 F-4EJ 91 F-2A/B 61 2004 SU30MKI F-15C SU-30 AA-10 AWACS AMRAMM F-22 SU30 F-15 AA-10, AA-11, AA-12 AIM-7, AIM-120, AAM-4 AAM-5 AA-10 AIM-7 AA-12 AIM-120 AAM-4 ECCM AIM-120 AA-11 AIM-7 10 AIM-7 AIM-9X 2000 AAM-5 2004 2004 2 SU-30 F-15 AWACS AWACS B-767 E-767 E-2C 10 AWACS 2006 KJ2000AWACS 40 71
JH-7 YJ-8K( 42 ) YJ-82K 120 JH-7A 2.5-3.0 KH-31A( 70 ) YJ-91( 110 ) J-8II J-10 SU-27SK J-11 KH-31A 636 K YUAN 220 M-54E(SS-N-27) SONG,YUAN, HAN YJ-82( 120 ) YJ-81Q 40 2.5~4 5 160~240 SS-N-22 052B 160~240 YJ-83 052C 280 YJ-62 K YUAN, SONG LUYANG DDG KD-63 200 H-6H TU-22 F-2C E-2C ASM-2 180 P-3C ASM-1C 180 SSM-1B 220 UA UAV P-3C 200X Z 13 P- C P C 100 093 SSN, K YUAN SONG SS 72
YUAN, SONG SS 120 YJ-82 K 220 SS-N-27B MING,R SS HAN SSN SAM 052B DDG 052C DDG 052C 100 HQ-9 052 SA-N-12 3 AWACS, E2C SM-2MR 170 F-15 SS-N-22 ~8 73
EEZ NHK EEZ C ISR, EEZ Growing Asymmetries in the China-Japan Naval Balance Richard Fisher, Jr. International Assessment and Strategy Center http://www010.upp.so-net.ne.jp/kawadai/chain/msdf.htm China Naval Modernization: Implication for U. S. Navy Capabilities CRS Report for Congress Chinese Military Power 2 74
DRC 1945 7 23 i ii 1895 1945 50 50 iii 50 iv v 150km 386km 144km 36,000 km 2/ vi 75
960 km 14,000km 500 6500 viii 19 300 ix 76
1500 1300 2 77
xii xiii 2005 12 SU-27SK SU-30MKK AL31F 150 5 5000 2005 7 100 300 Su-30MKK F-15 10 SU-27 xiv 2005 10 154M TU-154MD xv 2006 4 20 2005 2005 107 7 229 80 1000 2002 0 2003 2 2004 13 2005 107 xvi 2006 5 20 xvii 78
2006 800 GDP 2.5 2008 xviii 79
2006 5 1 2 6 xxiii 1974 2000 3000 1988 2600 2002 11 28 1970 1980 1990 1990 1997 1990 xxv 2004 km 2005 xxvi 80
1999 1 180 10 xxvii 1000 xxviii xxix 8 1980 1980 1988 6 1995 xxx 1970 1980 1992 81
9 1 2006 pp.134 135. 1 2003 pp.133 143 1 18 4 25 1 18 4 25 1 pp.134 135. 1 2003 pp.168 167 1 Courtner Whithey, Macarthur-His Rendezvous with History (N.Y., Alfred A. Knopf,1956), p. 1 2005 pp14. 21. 1 2005 pp14. 21. 1 1 1 2006 pp187. 197. 1 1 18 1 31 1 1 4 23 1 2006 5 21 1 1 1996 5 4 1 1 pp190. 192 1 ( 1999 )pp.163-166 1 18 5 25 1 1 pp197. 205. 1 1 18 5 25 1 2004 05 28 1 1 82
DRC 4 1000 4000m 50 1 2 10 1 2 50 13 83
GPS 21 18 20 21 GPS 200 21 84
1990 30 2004 8 1991 10 2003 11 19 21 3 3500 2004 11 (2006 )8 10 11 6 100 85
2006 4 12 2007 35 ASEM 2007 2 86
2 1994 99 2 240 344 1999 1686 2004 1 100 2003 3 2003 9 180 2004 1 2004 2 120 2 1 2 2004 8 3 130 2003 12 21 87
1 21 21 2 ODA 21 88
DRC 2001 20 2005 2 2000 2 89
3 1 3 2002.7 2002 2000 2005 90
1,977 02 23 1.18% 2006 01 NATO 50 91
2,500 600 60 1,000 92
20 1 90 NATO 6 QDR2006 80km 8,000 93
98% WTO 2020 2006 15 2020 94
95
http://www.jiia.or.jp/pdf/asia_centre/h14_ne_asia/3_arai.pdf 2001 1 http://www.clb.mita.keio.ac.jp/econ/shimada/2003/russia.pdf 2002 http://www.rieti.go.jp/jp/events/bbl/02021201.html 2006. 02. 05 http://www.kokuminrengo.net/2001/rando-usbase.htm www.pekinshuho.com/jp/2002-37/world37-2.htm www.pekinshuho.com/jp/2002-10/sddx10-3.htm 10. http://www.jiia.or.jp/pdf/russia_centre/h16_putin-foreign/07_ito.pdf 11. www.apaoj.or.jp/forum/2003/2003_04_youyaku.pdf 12. 2005.03.22 2005.03.09 2005.12.31 13. 2020 2001.10.4 14.DRC 2002 15. DRC 2006 96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
DRC SIPRI 100 2000 10 2006 300 28 250 6 1300 200 04 8000 BC 700 MD SDI 1992 2005 25 50 100 105
MD PAC-3 BC 2006 2000 300 MD PAC 9.11 300 5000 20 85 106
20 0.1 60 100 0.1 1000 700 10 100 400 450 6 7 H2-A 285 10 30 750 80 2003 05 NASA 7 107
2004 3 11 NASA X-43 A 7.7 9.8 1 1000 100 10 100 06 06 JAXA 8.0 747 400 380 560 600 15 50 20 150 10 150 100 20 100 500 10 100 108
10 7 10 2006 10 1983 SDI 280 300 SDI 91 SDI C4IS&R Command, Control, Computer, Communication, Intelligence, Surveillance, & Reconnaissance SDI 140 140 70 10 7 340 70 19 109
FSX 10 21 EU 4000 500 12 21 500 110
19 21 20 10 4 5 5 7 8 5 TGV 7 9 7 10 111
7 2001 2003 1993 2002 SDI 1986 SDI 1986 NASA -X 2000 2003 SDI and Industrial Technology Policy Walter Zegueld & Christian Enzing, ST. Martin s Press New York, 1987 The Future of SDI Joseph S. Nye Jr., University Press of America Inc. Boston,1988 Commercializing SDI Technologies Stewart Necette & Robert Lawrence Kuhn, PRAGER, New York,1987 The Origins of SDI Donald R. Baucom, University Press of Kansas, Kansas,1992 Beams 92 9 th International Conference on High Power Particle Beams National Research Laboratory, University of Maryland, 1992 The Global Positioning System Scott Pace and others, RAND Corporation, Santa Monica,1995 Weapons in Space Franklin A. Long, W.W. Norton & Company, New York, 1989 United States Security Strategy for the East Asia Pacific Region Department of Defense, 2002 DCAA CONTRACT MANUAL Department of Defense Contract Audit Agency, July 2003 Military Balance International Institute of Strategic Studies, London, 2005 Report to the National Defense Department of Defense, 2005 Military Power of the People s Republic of China 2006, Annual Report to Congress, Office of the Secretary of Defense, 2006 112
DRC QDR QDR NSS; The National Security Strategy of the United States of America 1986 603 NSC; National Security Council NDS; The National Defense Strategy of the United States of America Defense Planning Guidance QDR; Quadrennial Defense Review NDS NMS; National Military Strategy NSS 1986 113
1989 1990 NATO 22 1991 1990 8 1991 1 1993 (BUR; Bottom-Up Review), (2MRC; Two Major Regional Conflict) 1997 BUR (QDR 97; Quadrennial Defense Review 97 ) QDR97 (2MTW; Two Major Theater War) 2001 2001 (Annual Report to the President and Congress 2001) 2001 Jr. (2MTW) (Rogue State) 2001 10 QDR2001 2002 (The National Security Strategy of the United States of America) 11 25 2004 16 114
10 2005 2002 NDS NMS QDR 16 The National Security Strategy of the United States 2002 115
2002 2006 (QDR; Quadrennial Defense Review) 2001 10 WMD QDR 2001 WMD 2001 10 QDR 2001 9.11 9.11 QDR 21 QDR Traditional Warfare 116
QDR 2001 QDR NATO QDR2001 QDR2006 2001 Capabilities-based planning QDR WMD 2007 2008 QDR 2007 9.11 2 (Containment Policy) (2 Major Regional Conflicts, 2MRC) 117
9.11 2 1 QDR2006 10-2 3 4 5-2 2 4-3 17-3 17-2 4 5 3 16-3 16-2006 2007 118
( )DRC VFM Value for Money CPT Cost, Performance, Time (1 5) 10 3 10 3 6 1996 1998 9 119
2001 IT 2002 9 04 7 05 3 7 8 PM( ) IPT( ) (PTC) 1 2006 7 PM IPT 3 120
DGA ( ) VFM CPT 1 5 8 121
CPT VFM CPT C P C SETA (System/Scientific Engineering and Technical Assistance) P 122
CPT VFM P RFP ( 1 ) CPT ( 2 ) 1 CPT VFM 123
Contracting Officer MBA Negotiation 8 DCAA 36 21 MBA 9 Defense Acquisition University Contracting Officer 10 3 1 13DRC 2001 9 2 14DRC 2002 9 3 15DRC 2003 9 4 16DRC 2004 9 5 17DRC 2005 9 6 11 18 7 17 8 Vol.141 No2 2005 5 9 DRC 2003 Vol.13, No.2 P6 124
DRC / /IPT (Integrated Product/Project Team(s)) 125
30 / / OS SW IBM 126
Version 127
COTS / 128
/ 129
/IPT (Integrated Product/Project Team(s)) / /IPT DoD5000.2 Kelman 1994 FASA (Federal Acquisition Streamlining Act) 2003 DoD5000 / Kelman / 130
OMB 12% 131
30 /IPT 17 3 www.jda.go.jp/j/library/archives/sougousyutoku/17.3_b.pdf Vol.41.No.2 2005 5 15 11 18 www.jbaudit.go.jp/kanren/gar/japanese/jartcl21to30/j29d03.pdf Performance of commercial Activities, Part II chapter1 E. Overhead Circular No. A-76 Revised Supplemental Handbook, OMB March 1996 How to Share and Manage Risk in Defense Acquisition/Procurement DRC 2005 Managing Sensitive Information Departments of Energy and Defense Policies and Oversight Could Be Improved GAO-06-369 Report to Congress March 2006 132
Lessons Learned ( ) DRC (PC) PC PC Lessons Learned System Lessons Learned System Lesson Learned System Lessons Learned System Army Regulation 11-33, 10 October 1989, Army Lessons Learned Program: System Development and Application Lessons Learned System Lessons Learned System CJCS CJCSI 3150.25, 25 August 1997, Joint After-Action Reporting System (JAARS) CJCSI 3150.25A, 1 October 2000, Joint Lessons Learned Program CINC Windows Joint Instructional Input Program (WinJIIP) CJCSI 133
3150.25B, 15 February 2005, Joint Lessons Learned Program Navy Lessons Learned System (NLLS) xxxi NLLS Lessons Learned 1991 CNO NLLS Lessons Learned PC Navy Marine Corps Intranet (NMIN) Information Technology for 21 st Century (IT-21) Navy Instructional Input Program (NIIP) WinJIIP NLLS OPNAVINST 3500.37C, 19 Mar 2001 Navy Lessons Learned System (NLLS) Lessons Learned System PC PC 1994 7 7 (Vice Admiral Archie Clemins) ( ) 7 Global Network Initiative (GNI) 1996 4 17 AFCEA 7 PC PC 7 GNI 1996 9 GNI IT-21 (Information Technology for 21 st Century) xxxii IT-21 5 IT-21 IT-21 PC PC COTS 134
C4I 7 IT-21 e- 1997 11 Asia Pacific Center for Security Studies (APCSS) DRC 2 DRC 11 20 IT-21 PC 200 PC PC Lessons Learned System PC MNCI NMCI DON MNCI IT-21 Global Information Grid (GIG) (DON) DON Lessons Learned CJCSI 3150.25B, 15 February 2005 Lessons Learned 135
Figure A-2. CJCSI 3150.25B Joint Lessons Learned Program (JLLP) (Discovery) (Knowledge Development) (Implementation) 136
Lessons Learned 3 JLLP (Observations) (Analysis) (Review) (Validation) Lesson Learned (Findings & Publication) (Release) (Reports, Summaries, Briefings) U.S. Joint Force Command (USJFCOM) JLLP 4 (IWN) (JRAC) DOTMLPF ( ) (DCR) Lessons Learned (NLLS) Lessons Learned OPNAVINST 3500.37C, 137
19Mar 2001, Navy Lessons Learned System (NLLS) CJCSI 3150.25A, 1 October 2000, Joint Lessons Learned Program NMCI IT-21 Lessons Learned (JAARs) NLLS NLLS (NWDC) NWDC Lessons Learned (NLLDB) NLL Lessons Learned (PVRs) (AARs) (RAP) RAP (Subject Matter Expert (SME)) Lessons Learned (WCOEs) SIPRNET NWDC NLL CD-ROM NWDC (SIPRNET ) NLLS (Executive Steering Committee) NLL NWDC CFFC COMPACFLT COMUSNAVEUR COMUSNAVCENT Lesson Learned Navy Instructional Input Program (NIIP) NIIP Version 7.0 NWDC SIPRNET www.nwdc.navy.smil.mil NLL CD-ROMs 138
NIIP NIIP NWDC SIPRNET NLL CD-ROM Lesson Learned (TTP) NLLDB TTP ( ) (NWP EXTAC ) TTP Lessons Learned TTP Lessons Learned Lessons Learned (ISIC) Lessons Learned NLLS ( CINC ) NLLDB Lessons Learned NLLDB SIPRNET CD-ROM Lessons Learned NLLS/NIIP NWDC SIPRNET NIIP Overview Help NWDC NWDC SIPRNET e DRC 2006 5 19 7 Lessons Learned 139
7 Lessons Learned 7 E. 7 Lessons Learned Lessons Learned Lessons Learned CENTRIXS Lesson Learned Lessons Learned NLLS 7 7 NLLS 140
DRC O O 39.3.1 1999 I 1944 19 7 18 26 141
O 1945 20 5 11 24 K 194 2 1 32 142
Y 1945 20 3 29 25 1936 5 143
76 K A 7 144
i 2006 pp.134 135. ii 2003 pp.133 143 iii 18 4 25 iv 18 4 25 v pp.134 135. vi 2003 pp.168 167 vii Courtner Whithey, Macarthur-His Rendezvous with History (N.Y., Alfred A. Knopf,1956), p. viii 2005 pp14. 21. ix 2005 pp14. 21. x xi xii 2006 pp187. 197. xiii xiv 18 1 31 xv xvi 4 23 xvii 2006 5 21 xviii xix 1996 5 4 xx xxi pp190. 192 xxii ( 1999 )pp.163-166 xxiii 18 5 25 xxiv xxv pp197. 205. xxvi xxvii 18 5 25 xxviii 2004 05 28 xxix xxx xxxi http://www.nwdc.navy.mil/nll/nll.aspx xxxii Admiral Archie Clemins, U.S. Navy, IT-21 Moving to the 3rd Stage, USNI Proceedings May 1997 pp 51-54 145