Branwell Brontë and the Authorship of Wuthering Heights Ai SUGIMURA Tom Winnifrith There has always been a feeling that we only have a part of the Bro

Similar documents
Ł\1,4.ai

31 True at First Light Patrick Hemingway Ernest Hemingway, Patrick Hemingway True at First Light Islands in the Stream, 1970 The Gard

04長谷川英伸_様.indd

【人】⑧前田一平先生【本文】/【人】⑧前田一平先生【本文】


p _08森.qxd

C. S2 X D. E.. (1) X S1 10 S2 X+S1 3 X+S S1S2 X+S1+S2 X S1 X+S S X+S2 X A. S1 2 a. b. c. d. e. 2

NO


16_.....E...._.I.v2006

九州大学学術情報リポジトリ Kyushu University Institutional Repository 看護師の勤務体制による睡眠実態についての調査 岩下, 智香九州大学医学部保健学科看護学専攻 出版情報 : 九州大学医学部保健学

09‘o’–

<96DA8E9F82D982A95F944E95F1906C8AD489C88A775F33332E696E6464>


29 jjencode JavaScript

評論・社会科学 84号(よこ)(P)/3.金子

220 28;29) 30 35) 26;27) % 8.0% 9 36) 8) 14) 37) O O 13 2 E S % % 2 6 1fl 2fl 3fl 3 4

Kyushu Communication Studies 第2号

[ ]大野

社会関係資本と外国人に対する寛容さに関する研究―JGSS-2008 の分析から―

自分の天職をつかめ

, 3 2 Marshall [1890]1920, Marshall [1890]1920

56 pp , 2005 * ******* *** ** CA CAMA

\615L\625\761\621\745\615\750\617\743\623\6075\614\616\615\606.PS


,

Virtual Window System Virtual Window System Virtual Window System Virtual Window System Virtual Window System Virtual Window System Social Networking

.y z...Z.I.v24...ren


A5 PDF.pwd

(2) (3) 2 vs vs (9) Edward Mansfield and Jack Snyder, Democratization and War, Foreign Affairs, Vol. 74, No


ABSTRACT

Public relations brochure of Higashikawa April No.750 CONTENTS

L1 What Can You Blood Type Tell Us? Part 1 Can you guess/ my blood type? Well,/ you re very serious person/ so/ I think/ your blood type is A. Wow!/ G

相愛・人文科学研究所年報 4号(よこ)/森光

The Influence of Jane Eyre upon A World of Girls by L. T. Meade Satomi KASHIO Abstract This paper deals with the influence of Jane Eyre upon L. T. Mea

評論・社会科学 89号(よこ)(P)/4.徐

情意要因が英語の読解力と会話力に及ぼす影響-JGSS-2008 のデータから-

関西福祉大学紀要 12号(P)/1.太田

Bull. of Nippon Sport Sci. Univ. 47 (1) Devising musical expression in teaching methods for elementary music An attempt at shared teaching


AERA_English_CP_Sample_org.pdf

< D8291BA2E706466>

評論・社会科学 116号(P)Y☆/1.郭

126 学習院大学人文科学論集 ⅩⅩⅡ(2013) 1 2


KII, Masanobu Vol.7 No Spring

一 先 行 研 究 と 問 題 の 所 在 19

Sport and the Media: The Close Relationship between Sport and Broadcasting SUDO, Haruo1) Abstract This report tries to demonstrate the relationship be



nishi1502_01_24.ai


01 川瀬進 72号 リュウミンL

Juntendo Medical Journal

Title 泌尿器科領域に於ける17-Ketosteroidの研究 17-Ketosteroidの臨床的研究 第 III 篇 : 尿 Author(s) 卜部, 敏入 Citation 泌尿器科紀要 (1958), 4(1): 3-31 Issue Date URL

教育における構成主義

Oda

国際恋愛で避けるべき7つの失敗と解決策

先端社会研究所紀要 第13号☆/2.矢崎

Core Ethics Vol.

II

soturon.dvi

A5 PDF.pwd


* Toyohiko Kagawa and Oceanic Civilization Beyond the Death line and the Great Earthquake HAMADA Yo Toyohiko Kagawa ( ) was deeply i

’¸›Ø‰IŠv†QŒkŸe†Q


open / window / I / shall / the? something / want / drink / I / to the way / you / tell / the library / would / to / me

41 1. 初めに ) The National Theatre of the Deaf 1980

日本看護管理学会誌15-2

( ) ( ) (action chain) (Langacker 1991) ( 1993: 46) (x y ) x y LCS (2) [x ACT-ON y] CAUSE [BECOME [y BE BROKEN]] (1999: 215) (1) (1) (3) a. * b. * (4)

首都直下地震における地方財政への影響

千葉県における温泉地の地域的展開

J No J. J

NINJAL Project Review Vol.3 No.3


Transcription:

Branwell Brontë and the Authorship of Wuthering Heights Ai SUGIMURA Tom Winnifrith There has always been a feeling that we only have a part of the Brontë story, and biographers have rushed in to provide keys and clues to fill in the missing partssometimes the more fanciful biographers have tried to fill in the gaps with mythical Irish Brontë ancestors, a real life Heathcliff, Louis Parensell, a lesbian Emily and various authors for Wuthering Heights. Wuthering Heights Wuthering HeightsEmily Brontë Wuthering Heights Wuthering Heights Branwell Brontë Wuthering Heights Emily Brontë Branwell J. B. LeylandFrancis Grundy, George Searle Phillips, William Dearden, Edward Sloane Branwell Branwell Alice Law CharlotteWuthering Heights EmilyBranwell

Virginia MooreBranwell BranwellEmily Wuthering HeightsBranwell Thomas James Wise John Alexander Symington Mary Robinson Everard FlintoffFlintoff Branwell Wuthering Heights BrontëEmilyS Death Branwell Wuthering Heights Flintoff But it is sufficient to show that Branwell anticipated and probably invented many of the situations in Wuthering Heights. This being so, it is tempting to push the issue further and to ask ifbranwell might have had a hand in the creation of any other characters in the novel. The answer initially seems not. Certainly there is nothing equivalent to either Catherine or to the finest female character of all, Nellie Branwell LockwoodBranwell Joseph Emily AnneWuthering Heights Charlotte Brontë Wuthering Heights ABiographical Notice of Ellis and Acton BellEmily Ellis Bell Charlotte Wuthering HeightsEmily Brontë Branwell Branwell Wuthering Heights Emily BrontëBranwell Wuthering Heights Branwell Branwelland the weary are at rest

Emily Wuthering Heights Branwell and the weary are at rest Wuthering Heights Branwell Victor A. NeufeldtBranwellWuthering Heights Leyland I have, since I saw you at Halifax, devoted my hours of time... to the composition of three volume Novel one volume of which is completednovel Charlotte BrontëThe Professor Jane EyreElizabeth GaskellMary Barton Moorland CottageThe Professor Wuthering HeightsEmily Branwell Charlotte Jane EyreThe Professor Mary Barton Moorland Cottage Gaskell Charlotte Emily Branwell CopyCatch GoldRelated Phrases CFL Software Development David WoollsCopyCatch Gold Content words Function words David Woolls

CopyCatch Gold Files Similarity Phrase patterns Words BB and the weary are at rest WH Wuthering HeightsMBMary BartonPThe ProfessorJEJane Eyre MCMoorland Cottage Files Similarity Words Phrase patterns BB WH BB MB BB P P JE MB MC P1 JE 1 P1 P25 BB WH 1 BB WH34 and the weary are at restwuthering Heightsand the weary are at restmary Barton Branwell Charlotte The Professor The Professor Jane Eyre The Professor Jane Eyre The Professor

Wuthering Heights Branwell and the weary are at rest Wuthering Heights CopyCatch Gold The Professor Jane Eyre, Mary Barton Moorland Cottage and the weary are at restmary Barton Mary Barton Moorland Cottage The Professor Jane EyreMary Barton Moorland Cottage and the weary are at restwuthering Heights CopyCatch GoldStatistics CopyCatch Gold Statistics Content wordsfunction wordsfiles Shared ContentContent words FunctionFunction wordstotal Shared Once only in both Only in

and the weary are at restwuthering Heights Statistics Words Files Shared % Content Function Total BB Total WH Shared BB Shared WH Once only in both BB WH Only in BB Only in WH and the weary are at restmary Barton Statistics Words Files Shared % Content Function Total BB Total MB Shared BB Shared MB Once only in both BB MB Only in BB Only in MB The Professor Jane Eyre Statistics Words Files Shared % Content Function Total P Total JE Shared P Shared JE Once only in both P JE Only in P Only in JE

The ProfessorThe Professor Statistics Words Files Shared % Content Function Total P 1 Total P25 Shared P1 Shared P25 Once only in both P1 P25 Only in P 1 Only in P25 and the weary at restwuthering Heights, The Professor, Mary Barton and the weary are at rest Wuthering Heightsand the weary are at rest Mary Barton BB : WH BB : MB The Professor Jane Eyre P:JE Mary Barton Moorland Cottage MB : MC The Professor PP

and the weary are at restwuthering Heights amid amidst Searcher Words BB WH MB MC P JE amid amidst among amongst before ere can t cannot on upon till until though although toward towards while whilst

Words BB WH P JE MB MC amid amidst among amongst before ere can t cannot toward towards BB WH WH JE BB MB P JE BB MC P MB BB P P MC BB JE MB MC WH MB MB JE WH MC JE MC WH P The Professor Jane Eyre, Mary Barton Mooland Cottage Wuthering Heights Mary Barton and the weary are at rest Wuthering Heights

Wuthering Heights Emily Brontë Branwell Brontë CopyCatch Gold Wuthering Heights Branwell Brontë Tom Winnifrith, The Brontës and Their Background : Romance and Reality. Second Edition Macmillan Press, p Branwell Emily Jane Brontë and the Authorship of Wuthering Heights. Virginia Moore, The Life and Eager Death of Emily Brontë A BiographyLondon : Rich & Cowan, Ltd., Ed. by Thomas James Wise and John Alexander Symington, The Brontës : Their Lives, Friendships & Correspondence. Vol Oxford : Shakespeare Head Press, p Mary Robinson s letter to Ellen Nussey, dated 17th August Everard Flintoff Branwell at the Heights : An Investigation into the Possible Influence of Branwell Brontë upon Wuthering Heights Durham University Journal, p pp Edited by Victor A. Neufeldt, The Works of Patrick Branwell Brontë Volume New York and London : Garland Publishing, Inc., pp Nerfeldt AngriaNorthangerland House Alexander PercyEmily Wuthering HeightsGondal Wuthering HeightsByron Scott Joseph Wuthering Heights Op., sit. p n Ibid. Word and the weary are at rest Wuthering Heights Mary Barton The ProfessorJane Eyre

Moorland Cottage The Professor1 The Professor Jane Eyre1 Wuthering Heights Wuthering Heights and the weary are at rest http : //www.lang.nagoya u.ac.jp / matsuoka / Bronte.html e text Laurence Urdang, The Oxford Thesaurus:An A Z Dictionary of Synonyms Oxford: Clarendon Press Douglas Jarrell