Size: px
Start display at page:

Download ""

Transcription

1 Affirmative Action Fisher Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, F. d ( th Cir. ). Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, U.S. _ (). Fisher Affirmative Action Fisher Fisher Michigan Affirmative ActionAA Grutter Gratz AA Abigail Fisher Texas Austin UT UT Fisher Grutter v. Bollinger, U.S. (). Gratz v. Bollinger, U.S. (). Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, U.S. _ (). 121

2 Affirmative Action AA Fisher AA Fisher Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, F. d ( th Cir. ). UT standardized test Academic IndexAI Hopwood AA Hopwood UT AI Personal Achievement Index 122

3 PAI PAI essays Personal Achievement Score Personal Achievement Score UT UT Personal Achievement Score Texas Top Ten Percent Law Hopwood Texas Texas Texas AI PAI Hopwood v. Texas, F. d ( th Cir. ). Hopwood UT Texas Bakke Powell Hopwood v. Texas, F. d ( th Cir.), cert. denied, S. Ct. () Texas 123

4 Affirmative Action UT Grutter UT UT critical mass UT Personal Achievement Score AI PAI UT Liberal Arts Grutter UT AI PAI UT Fisher UT Fisher UT UT UT Fisher Grutter, U.S. at 124

5 Higginbotham Higginbotham King Garza panel Higginbotham suspect Grutter Grutter Grutter UT Grutter Grutter UT 125

6 Affirmative Action UT AI PAI UT UT AI PAI Grutter percentage plans UT 126

7 Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, U.S. _ (). Fisher en banc Fisher Fisher Grutter Kennedy Kennedy Roberts Scalia Thomas Breyer Alito Sotomayo Scalia Thomas Kagan UT UT Bakke Grutter Gratz Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, U.S. (). 127

8 Affirmative Action Powell Bakke Bakke California Davis Powell quota system Powell Powell benign Powell 128

9 Powell Grutter Gratz Bakke Powell Grutter Powell Grutter Gratz Bakke Powell 129

10 Affirmative Action Grutter Grutter Grutter Grutter Grutter Grutter UT UT 130

11 Grutter UT AI PAI UT 131

12 Affirmative Action UT AI PAI UT trial Grutter UT UT UT 132

13 Scalia Grutter Grutter Grutter Thomas UT Ginsburg Grutter AA UT Fisher Affirmative Action Fisher AA Bakke Grutter 133

14 Affirmative Action Gratz Fisher Bakke AA AA Bakke California Davis Bakke Bakke Bakke Bakke Powell Bakke Powell AA AA societal discrimination Powell Powell U.S.C d et seq. d 134

15 Powell freedom of a university AA Powell Harvard Powell tiebreaker Brennan White Marshall Blackmun an important state interest substantially related AA Brennan 135

16 Affirmative Action AA stigma Burger Stewart Rehnquist Stevens Powell Bakke Powell Rehnquist Court Roberts Court Grutter Michigan Grutter Michigan Grutter O'Connor Stevens Souter Ginsburg Breyer Scalia Thomas Brennan AA 136

17 O'Connor Adarand O'Connor Croson AA O'Connor Bakke Powell AA O'Connor Adarand Constructors, Inc. v. Pena, U.S. (). Adarand O'Connor Croson Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co., U.S. (). Croson Richmond O'Connor AA AA Richmond 137

18 Affirmative Action O'Connor individualized consideration Rehnquist Scalia Kennedy Thomas Rehnquist O'Connor good motives AA Rehnquist Bakke Powell Grutter Powell 138

19 Gratz Michigan Gratz Michigan Gratz Rehnquist O'Connor Scalia Kennedy Thomas Rehnquist AA Rehnquist Bakke Powell Rehnquist Ginsburg Souter 139

20 Affirmative Action Ginsburg policy of exclusion policy of inclusion Ginsburg careful judicial inspection Grutter Gratz Grutter Gratz Fisher Grutter Fisher Pauline T. Kim, The colorblind Lottery, FORDHAM L. REV., (). 140

21 fundamental rights suspect classification stigma San Antonio Independent School District San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, U.S. (). Id. at. 141

22 Affirmative Action Warren Court Gerald Gunther Warren Court strict in theory and fatal in fact Korematsu Black Warren Court Rehnquist Court Roberts Court Gerald Gunther, The Supreme Court Term-Foreword: In Search of Evolving Doctrine on a Changing Court: A Model of for a Never Equal Protection, HARV. L. REV., (). Korematsu v. United State U.S. (). Id. at. Richard H. Fallon, Jr., Strict Judicial Scrutiny, UCLA. L. REV., (). 142

23 O'Connor Grutter O'Connor Croson Adarand Ginsburg O'Conner O'Connor Dworkin O'Connor rebuttal Fisher Kennedy Parents Involved in Community Schools PICS Id. at -. Grutter, U.S. at -. Adarand, U.S. at. O'Connor Affirmative Action RONALD DWORKIN, SOVEREIGN VIRTUE (Harvard University Press ). 143

24 Affirmative Action Croson O'Connor Fisher Kennedy Fisher Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No., U.S. (). Parents Involved in Community Schools Seattle Alabama Jefferson Roberts Grutter Grutter Croson Kennedy O'Connor Croson, U.S. at - Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No., U.S. at. Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, U.S. _. 144

25 Fisher Fisher Kennedy Grutter Grutter Kennedy Grutter Kennedy Grutter Kennedy UT AI PAI Kennedy UT UT Kennedy Id. at _. Id. at _. Id. at _. 145

26 Affirmative Action Fisher Kennedy PICS PICS Kennedy PICS Kennedy Jonathan W. Rash O'Connor Kennedy Fisher Grutter Rash Grutter AA AA Kennedy Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No., U.S. at. Jonathan W. Rash, Affirmative Action on Life Support: Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin and the End of Not-So-Strict Scrutiny, DUKE J. CONST. L. & PUB., () 146

27 AA Kennedy AA Kennedy Grutter O'Connor Kennedy O'Connor PICS Kennedy AA AA Fisher UT Ibid Id. at

28 Affirmative Action Fisher Kennedy AA AA AA Kennedy UT Kennedy Princeton William G. Bowen Harvard Derek Bok AA Fisher Bakke Grutter WILLIAM G. BOWEN AND DEREK BOK, THE SHAPE OF THE RIVER: LONG-TERM COMSEQUENCE OF CONSIDER RACE IN COLLEGE AND UNIVERSITY ADMISSION (Princeton: Princeton University Press, ). 148

帝京国際文化 第18号 山内久史

帝京国際文化 第18号 山内久史 Bakke 1978 Grutter 2003 Gratz 2003 Brown Bakke equal protection clause 14 2003 Grutter Gratz strict scrutiny LSA Brown Bakke Bakke 14 separate but equal 1896 Plessy 1954 Brown with all deliberate speed

More information

本組よこ/本組よこ_榎透_P023-055

本組よこ/本組よこ_榎透_P023-055 23 Agostini v. Felton McCreary County v. ACLU of Kentucky Van Orden v. Perry 24 25 26 Alembik, The Future of the Lemon Test : A Sweeter Alternative for Establishment Clause Analysis, 40 Ga L. Rev. 1171

More information

アメリカ連邦最高裁における公教育像の考察(二)

アメリカ連邦最高裁における公教育像の考察(二) Tinker Abstract In this article, I consider how the Supreme Court of the United States has applied the standard adopted by Tinker, whether teachers can constitutionally restrict the student's freedom of

More information

Ronald Dworkin 2 economic approachlofty approach ibid., p. ibid., p. 2.1

Ronald Dworkin 2 economic approachlofty approach ibid., p. ibid., p. 2.1 Abstract When it comes to the state s policy on art and culture, there are two major approaches. One strand of liberal thought emphasizes state neutrality and claim that the state should fund all art and

More information

1 2

1 2 ( ) ( ) ( ) 1 2 59 2 21 24 275 43 3 26 486 103 27 28 98 105 104 99 1 48 25 29 72 14 33 11-10 3 11 8 14,663 4 8 1 6.0 8 1 0.7 11-6 27 19 22 71 5 12 22 12 1,356 6 4,397 3 4 11 8 9 5 10 27 17 6 12 22 9

More information

32 constructivism Rawls 1971, pp. 137, 158 Rawls 1971, pp Dworkin 2000, p Cohen 1989, p. 931 option luck neutralization Dworkin 200

32 constructivism Rawls 1971, pp. 137, 158 Rawls 1971, pp Dworkin 2000, p Cohen 1989, p. 931 option luck neutralization Dworkin 200 32 2017 p.31 43 VS Rawls 1971 G A reasonably brute luck luck egalitarianism social cooperation social relations egalitarianism veil of ignorance original position 32 constructivism Rawls 1971, pp. 137,

More information

IT Information Technology Information and Communication Technology E mail IT -84-

IT Information Technology Information and Communication Technology E mail IT -84- Protection of personal information and privacy Shinako MATSUI* * 17 19 * -83- IT Information Technology Information and Communication Technology E mail 18 15 17 IT -84- -85- 1980 OECD Guidelines on the

More information

”Y‰Æ”ЛïŸ_‘W40−ª4/ ™ƒ“ª

”Y‰Æ”ЛïŸ_‘W40−ª4/ ™ƒ“ª Fisher & Tronto CC - Ungerson Ungerson DNA Digital News Archives - ...... prospect Goffman Wiles Bateson v socialization T. Mills Oliver Raymond .. -. Bateson G., Step to an Ecology of Mind. Ballantine

More information

1980 30 1 20 1968 1968 1968 199-246 1979 Social Change and Fundamental Law: America s Evolving Constitution 1979 1984 Nuclear Weapons and Law 1984 235-251 1984 377-384 1984 63 181-206 1984 1 9 8 4 41 1243-1309

More information

2 1 life prospect Rawls [] ; Dworkin ; Dennis Mckerlie complete lifetime time-slice time-span Mckerlie : - Mckerlie : social starting position

2 1 life prospect Rawls [] ; Dworkin ; Dennis Mckerlie complete lifetime time-slice time-span Mckerlie : - Mckerlie : social starting position 1 2 1 life prospect Rawls [] ; Dworkin ; 4 4 4 4 Dennis Mckerlie complete lifetime time-slice time-span Mckerlie : - Mckerlie : social starting position natural advantage historical contingency Rawls []:

More information

= : : = : : : 14

= : : = : : : 14 論 文 都 市 社 会 の 公 共 性 と 社 会 的 共 通 資 本 現 代 都 市 社 会 の 社 会 学 的 認 識 枠 組 みに, 鈴 木 広 が 体 系 化 した 私 化 する 私 性 と 全 体 化 する 全 体 性 を 活 用 すると, 後 者 の 主 な 構 成 要 因 に 公 共 性 が 位 置 づけられる. 本 論 文 では, 公 共 性 を 公 と 共 に 細 分 して,それぞれの

More information

untitled

untitled . 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112!! 113 114 115 116 117 118 Gopal, op.cit., p.. Dilks, op.cit., vol., p.. Ibid.,

More information

136 立教アメリカン スタディーズ LGBT Pierceson 2014: 7-13

136 立教アメリカン スタディーズ LGBT Pierceson 2014: 7-13 Politics of Same-Sex Marriage in the United States 西山隆行 NISHIYAMA Takayuki 1 2015 6 26 9 4 4 1 2008 2012 1 LGBT LGBT Rikkyo American Studies 38 (March 2016) Copyright 2016 The Institute for American Studies,

More information

ディスクロージャーの実効性確保

ディスクロージャーの実効性確保 Tamar Frankel, Implied Rights of Action, Virginia Law Review, Vol.67, No.3, p.555 (1981). Larry E. Ribstein, Market vs. Regulatory Responses to Corporate Fraud: A Critique of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of

More information

<88BB8D8293BF5F907D955C B2E786C7378>

<88BB8D8293BF5F907D955C B2E786C7378> 1 1 1 1 2 1 3 2 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 2013 2 22 2655 9 2013 4 1 2013 4 10 3 1 2009 12 4 1 2 2010 1 14 1 14 3 2010 3 28 1960 1963 2009 2 8 2009 6 2010 1 3 10 2012 109 115 2010 6 98 2011 5 4 2013 3 17 2013 3 13

More information

001.indd

001.indd OECD45.1 OECD 13.3 1 50 1 1988 2008 2 3 2 4 6 1 2 3 70 4 1 2011 2KBS 150kg7,000 500 1 20 1.5 870 2080 20102009 65 48.9 58.3 1 2 1 2008 58.4 4.3 46.3 272.2 2 46.527.2 2.0 28.216.4 1.2 58.4 100.0 14.8 25.4

More information

本文/小路邦子3rd

本文/小路邦子3rd The Book of the Order of Chivelry Le Libre del Orde de Cauayleria Mirrour of the World freedom liberal liberal free liberal 27 Policraticus De Regimine Principum Politics Secretum Secretorum 29 Le Mort

More information

金融規制における課徴金制度の抑止効果と法的課題

金融規制における課徴金制度の抑止効果と法的課題 D&O D&O E-mail: [email protected] / /2015.7 143 1. 1 2 3 4 2 5 6 1 2005 13 2 3 6 2 172 2007 31 2 34 21 2 4 2005 40 172 2 1 1 25 3 28 24 301 5 175 1 2 6 2005 13 144 /2015.7 7 8 fairness retribution

More information

Kyoto Sangyo University. NII-Electronic Library Service

Kyoto Sangyo University. NII-Electronic Library Service . No. FX No. IRCInternal Revenue Code a IRC a IRC gross income IRC a IRC,,,,, ,, IRC a personal physical injuriesphysical sickness punitive damages the Income Tax Act of b personal injuries or sickness

More information

4 8 6 1 1 4 8 2001, 3 2 Marshall [1890]1920, 240 19 1 2001 2008 1990 1997 2007 2 Marshall [1890]1920

4 8 6 1 1 4 8 2001, 3 2 Marshall [1890]1920, 240 19 1 2001 2008 1990 1997 2007 2 Marshall [1890]1920 8 2011. 3 199 213 D. H. D. H. 1877-1953 The Evolution of Industry 1911 1904 1908 1919 1922 45 1906 Industrial Combination 2009 20 4 8 6 1 1 4 8 2001, 3 2 Marshall [1890]1920, 240 19 1 2001 2008 1990 1997

More information

Walter et al. 2009: 1 Helleiner 1994 Strange 1971: Gilpin 1987: -65 Strange b, 1998c,

Walter et al. 2009: 1 Helleiner 1994 Strange 1971: Gilpin 1987: -65 Strange b, 1998c, 54 2012 77 92 E. Yano Shuichi 2011 11 2008 40 19821997 1998 LTCM 2001 IT 2007 1970 International Political Economy Helleiner 1994 54 2012 Walter et al. 2009: 1 Helleiner 1994 Strange 1971: Gilpin 1987:

More information

1) 2) K

1) 2) K K M. K. Gandhi, My Religion, compiled and edited by Bharatan Kumarappa, Navajiran Publishing House, 1955, p.123 1) 2) K 3) 4) The Livelihood of Man H W 5) 6) 7) embeddedness 8) 9) 10) 11) good life B

More information

資料2 小林雅之委員からの資料

資料2 小林雅之委員からの資料 1 !!!! 3 2012 3! 2 !! University of California System (! University of California, Berkeley! University of California, Merced! Stanford University (! Mills College!! 3 !!, ( ( 4 !!!! 200! 5 ! Rhodes, Frank

More information

Professor of Epidemiology and Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health Personal History 1945 Born in Hart, Michigan, USA 1970 M.D. University of Mic

Professor of Epidemiology and Nutrition, Harvard School of Public Health Personal History 1945 Born in Hart, Michigan, USA 1970 M.D. University of Mic The Search for Optimal Diets: A Progress Report Commemorative Lecture at the Twenty-Fifth Honda Prize Awarding Ceremony on the 17th November 2004 in Tokyo Walter C. Willett Professor of Epidemiology and

More information

A5 PDF.pwd

A5 PDF.pwd Kwansei Gakuin University Rep Title Author(s) 家 族 にとっての 労 働 法 制 のあり 方 : 子 どもにとっての 親 の 非 正 規 労 働 を 中 心 に Hasegawa, Junko, 長 谷 川, 淳 子 Citation 法 と 政 治, 65(3): 193(825)-236(868) Issue Date 2014-11-30 URL

More information

IMES Discussion Paper Series 98-J-7 1998 3 9 9 9 9 UCC 9 JEL classification K19 * (E-mail:[email protected])

IMES Discussion Paper Series 98-J-7 1998 3 9 9 9 9 UCC 9 JEL classification K19 * (E-mail:kiyoe@rikkyo.ac.jp) IMES DISCUSSION PAPER SERIES 9 Discussion Paper No. 98-J-7 INSTITUTE FOR MONETARY AND ECONOMIC STUDIES BANK OF JAPAN 100-8630 203 IMES Discussion Paper Series 98-J-7 1998 3 9 9 9 9 UCC 9 JEL classification

More information

鈴木雄雅様P1〜22

鈴木雄雅様P1〜22 0288 5913 1 23 79 105 2 6 149 161 169 175 2005 10 17 60 90 01 9 11 05 7 9 11 105 2003 15 90 1996 21 22 2003 15 04 12 48 1 99 5 1 04 12 15 106 2 1997 461 2005 491 90 2003 2001 2000 2 2003 107 1996 1998

More information

KB QuestionPoint KB Web Q&A QuestionPoint Web Q&A QuestionPoint (B)

KB QuestionPoint KB Web Q&A QuestionPoint Web Q&A QuestionPoint (B) QuestionPoint http://www.questionpoint.org QuestionPoint Library of Congress OCLC CDRS Collaborative Digital Reference Service 250 CDRS KB 2002 6 3 QuestionPoint KB 2001 12 2002 4 2100 1 QuestionPoint

More information

4 1 5 737 145 81 56 1 2 3 4 5 1 1943 9 23 2 30 3 4 1945 3 1945 11 20046 23 146 738 2003 5 4 1 1943 7 2004 18 38 1988 2009 739 147 81 56 200433 1932 198523 3 197464 4 1 148 740 2001 106 200277 76 200645

More information

Winter 2009 No Lower Earnings Limit

Winter 2009 No Lower Earnings Limit 特集 : イギリスの社会保障 - ニューレイバーの 10 年 イギリスの公的 私的年金制度改革 丸谷浩介 I 1 50 1997 II 1. 2 15 Winter 2009 No. 169 8 3 4 1999 1989 8 2. 4 1 2 1 1992 6 16 Lower Earnings Limit1 65 60 1 2 16 2.40 16 2 1 5 1 2 3. 6 1970 State

More information

2

2 1002M02 1 2 2002 4 2 30 30 29 5 3 30 2004 1 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 2000 1888 1886 1905 11 1960 18 2002 1999 3 IQ70 8 12 1992 9 American Association on Mental Retardation 1992 75 70 18 / American Psychiatric Association

More information

RX501NC_LTE Mobile Router取説.indb

RX501NC_LTE Mobile Router取説.indb 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 19 20 21 22 1 1 23 1 24 25 1 1 26 A 1 B C 27 D 1 E F 28 1 29 1 A A 30 31 2 A B C D E F 32 G 2 H A B C D 33 E 2 F 34 A B C D 2 E 35 2 A B C D 36

More information

ニューヨーク州の不動産競売手続

ニューヨーク州の不動産競売手続 2007 19 3 I mortgage 1 mortgage legal title title theory lien theory title theory legal title equity of redemption 2 3 II foreclosure equity of redemption 1 Baxter Dunaway, The Law of Distressed Real Estate,

More information

GN151-200.doc

GN151-200.doc Good News No.151 Good News No.152 Good News No.153 Good News No.154 Good News No.155 Good News No.156 Good News No.157 Good News No.158 Good News No.159 CO2 Good News No.160 Good News No.161 Good

More information

) Good Morning 4 In the Autumn Forest b a 3)

) Good Morning 4 In the Autumn Forest b a 3) 23 7 17 2017 Tamagawa University Research Review, 23, 7 17 (2017). 7 2 Reading English Picture Books with an Application of Non-verbal Communication at Japanese Public Elementary Schools Yumi Matsumoto

More information

シリコンバレーとルート128における地域産業システムのその後の展開―経営学輪講 Saxenian (1994)

シリコンバレーとルート128における地域産業システムのその後の展開―経営学輪講 Saxenian (1994) ISSN 1347-4448 ISSN 1348-5504 8 3 (2009 3 ) 128 * Saxenian (1994) Saxenian, A. (1994). Regional advantage: Culture and competition in Silicon Valley and Route 128. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

More information

-2- extrinsic evidence 5 2,000 2,260

-2- extrinsic evidence 5 2,000 2,260 -1-2 Baba Chiba Doi Arai 28 A D C B engineer parol evidence rule -2- extrinsic evidence 5 2,000 2,260 -3- adversary trial system waiver Erie doctrine diversity action -4- $50,000 cross-liability clause

More information

Jr. *1 *2 W *1 Jr. (2005) *2 Arthur M. Schlesinger (2004).

Jr. *1 *2 W *1 Jr. (2005) *2 Arthur M. Schlesinger (2004). Jr. *1 *2 W 2014 6 2008 *1 Jr. (2005) 55-56 *2 Arthur M. Schlesinger (2004). *3 *4 (Unmanned Air Vehicle) *5 2004 2008 5 42 2009 2012 4 252 *6 *7 (Anwar al-awlaki) 2011 9 30 (Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula)

More information

<88BB8D8293BF5F907D955C B2E786C7378>

<88BB8D8293BF5F907D955C B2E786C7378> Transition 1 2 3 4 4 1 4 2 5 1 2006 12 1 1 2013 4 8 2013 4 10 Transition 1 18 18 60 74.8 1839 4059 17 18 60 8.6 13.10 71.70 30.30 70.10 37.2 32.9 1864 19 1839 54.3 4064 9.5 1839 69.4 4064 45.7 1839 50.4

More information

18 (1) US (2) US US US 90 (3) 2 8 1 18 108 2 2,000 3 6,000 4 33 2 17 5 2 3 1 2 8 6 7 7 2 2,000 8 1 8 19 9 10 2 2 7 11 2 12 28 1 2 11 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 2 3 33 2 1 3 2 3 2 16 2 8 3 28 8 3 5 13 1 14 15 1 2

More information

Netcommunity SYSTEM αNX typeS/typeM 取扱説明書

Netcommunity SYSTEM αNX typeS/typeM 取扱説明書 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 2 3 4 5 6 8 3 3-38 1 2 3 4 5 9 1 2 3 10 4 5 11 6 12 1 1-2 1 1-3 1 1-4 1 1-5 1 1-6 1 1-7 1 1 1-8 1 1-9 1 100 10 TEN 1 1-10 1 1-11 1 1-12 1 1-13 1 1-14 1 1 2 7 8 9 1 3 4 5 6 1-15 1 1 7 2 3

More information

H1-H4_政経研究_51-3.ai

H1-H4_政経研究_51-3.ai Employee-Choice Training and Company-Selection Training in Human Resource Development Eugenics and Social Policy Support of Income or Independent Life? :An Overview of Issues Surrounding Disability Pensions

More information

Future like ours FLO Don Marquis, Why AborBon is Immoral, The Journal of Philosophy, vol.86,

Future like ours FLO Don Marquis, Why AborBon is Immoral, The Journal of Philosophy, vol.86, eguchi@kyoto wu.ac.jp Future like ours FLO Don Marquis, Why AborBon is Immoral, The Journal of Philosophy, vol.86, 1989. 1. 2. 3. (1) the best secular argument against aborbon (person) (2) FLO (Cudd 1990)

More information