2
(HEFCELeague tables and their impacts on higher educations in England) 3
4
5 5
!"#" #" #$ % QS 2009 and 2010 World University Ranking 6 Indicators Weight 13 Used Indicators Weight TIME 2010 World University Ranking 13 Proposed Indicators (later possibly 16 indicators) % Weight Research 60% 30% Research 1. Academic Peer Review (composite score drawn 40% 1. Reputational survey-research 19.5% Indicators from peer-review survey) 2. Research income (scaled) 5.25% Research influence 2. Research Excellence (the total number of citations for all papers published from the institution, and then dividing the figure by the number of full-time equivalent staff) (Data: Scopus by Elsevier 2005-2009) 3. Papers per academic and research staff 4.5% 4. Public research income/total research income 20% 5. The number of times its published work is cited by academia: Normalized citation impact** (Data: Web of Science by Thomson Reuters 2004-2008) 0.75% 32.5% 1. Academic papers (scaled-the number of papers produced per member of research staff. (it is a low weighted measure.)) 2. Citation impact (normalized by subject-the number of citations for each paper produced at an institution) 3. Research income (scaled against research staff numbers) 4. Research income from public sources/industry 5. Reputation survey (research excellence) 55% Teaching 3. Teaching Excellence (a simple measure of staff-to-student ratio) 20% 30% Institutional Indicators 11. Reputational survey-teaching 15% 12. PhD awards per academic staff 6% 6. Undergraduate entrants (scaled against academic staff numbers) 7. PhDs/undergraduate degrees awarded (the proportion of PhDs awarded against undergraduate degrees awarded) 25% 13. Undergraduates admitted per academic staff (staff-to-student ratio) 4.5% 8. PhDs awarded (scaled) 9. Reputation survey (teaching excellence) 14. Institutional income per academic staff 2.25% 10. Institutional (overall) income (scaled against staff numbers) 15. PhD awards/bachelor s awards 2.25% International mix 4. International Faculty (measured as a proportion of student body) 5. International Students (measured as a proportion of student body) 10% 5% International Diversity 5% 11. Ratio of international to domestic staff 3% 5% 12. Ratio of international to domestic students 2% 11. Ratio of international to domestic students 12. Ratio of international to domestic staff *1. [Future potential indicator]: a measure of research papers co-authored with international partners] 10% Industry relations 6. Employer Survey (scored on responses to employer survey) 10% 13. Research income from industry (per academic staff) &&'()%*+,-,+./0%,.%)-*(%1-1)2%-2)%*.31-2)4%5+,(%,()%-6)2-7)%/839)2%.:%*+,-,+./0%2)*)+6)4%9;%-<<%1-1)20%189<+0()4%+/%,()%0-3)%:+<)4%-/4%;)-2=% % 2.5% Economic Activity /Innovation 13. Research income from industry (scaled again research staff numbers) *2. [Future potential indicator: the volume of papers co-authored with industrial partners] *3. [Future potential indicator: a subjective examination of employers perception of graduates] 10%
!! Process to Curiculate Citation Impact Score 3(D@E#-*()!;.-(-.$5!<,0(#-! #.-(-.$5+!0&%!0(0&%!F;==G!?! ABC 6$7.8.&7!9$%,().:&7!;.-(-.$5!<,0(#- ;==!-$!->&!4)$1()!(/&%(4&!$8!;==!?!@! ABC 3&4.$5()!6$7.8.#(-.$5! #.-(-.$5!%(-&+ "#$%&!'()*&+ #*,*)(-./&!0%$1(1.).-2!+#$%&! 7
8
Citation Impact 2010 TIMES HE University Rankings TR Essential Science Indicators 2010 QS Asian University Rankings 2010 QS World University Rankings Web of Science 2004-2008(5) Web of Science 2000-2010 (11) Scopus 2003-2007 (5) Scopus Last 5 years (2005-2009 ) Citation/paper Citation/paper Citation/paper Citation/faculty 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Korea, South Japan Japan Japan Japan Japan Taiwan Japan Japan Hong Kong Hong Kong China Hong Kong Korea, South Taiwan Singapore Korea, South Japan Japan Taiwan Hong Kong China China China Singapore Korea, South Taiwan Hong Kong Japan Japan China Japan Japan Japan Hong Kong Japan Japan China Japan 18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
2011200810 200810iPS
2011.5.1 2008.10.1 800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 38
39
40
41