possibilism Development Projects Observed 5

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "43 2000 1964 65 possibilism 1 30 2 3 4 Development Projects Observed 5"

Transcription

1 Shuichi YANO 1967A.O.Hirschman Development Projects Observed Brookings Institution: Washington, D.C.,

2 possibilism Development Projects Observed 5

3 Development Projects Observed The Principle of Hiding Hand

4 p.13 6 Invisible Hand p.14 pp

5 pp Administration

6 pp pp pp.56-59

7 pp pp Research & Development pp latitudes disciplines

8 pp pp Latitude in Substituting Quantity for Quality

9 pp p.127 Trait-Taking Trait-Making pp

10 pp pp pp

11 pp p.169

12 p pp technicians pp p.186 p.188

13 Development Projects Observed Development Projects Observed

14 CDPPP Development Projects Observed 16

15 17 5 Development Projects Observed trained incapacity

16 Development Projects Observed p.5 22 Development Projects Observed 23 Development Projects Observed 1995

17 24 Exit, Voice, and Loyalty 25 voice exit A.O R.Picciotto, Visibility and Disappointment: The New Role of Development Evaluation, in L. Rodwin et al., eds., Rethinking the Development Experience: Essays Provoked by the Work of Albert O. Hirschman, Brookings Institution: Washington, D.C., Assessing Aid: What Works, What Doesn t, and Why, Oxford University Press, R. Wade, Japan, the World Bank, and the Art of Paradigm Maintenance: The East Asian Miracle in Political Perspective, New Left Review, No. 217, 1996.

18 NTT Regional Development in Third World Countries: Paradigms and Operational Principles, International Development Journal: Tokyo, Development Projects Observed A.O.Hirschman, The Strategy of Economic Development, Yale University Press: New Haven, 1958, pp pp p P. Krugman, The Fall and Rise of Development Economics, in Rodwin et al.,eds., op.cit Rodwin et al., eds., op.cit., pp L.Taylor, Hirschman s Strategy at Thirty-Five, in Rodwin et al., eds., op.cit., pp E.Rothschild, Psychological Modernity in Histrorical Perspective, in Rodwin et al.,eds., op.cit. 22 C.Sabel, Learning by Monitoring: The Institutions of Economic Development, in Rodwin et al.,eds., op.cit., p L.Peattie, Society as Output: Exit and Voice among the Passions, in Rodwin et al.,eds., op.cit. 24 A.O.Hirschman, Journeys Toward Progress: Studies of Economic Policy Making in Latin America, The Twentieth Century Fund, A.O.Hirschman, Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States, Harvard University Press, Exit-Voice

Walter et al. 2009: 1 Helleiner 1994 Strange 1971: Gilpin 1987: -65 Strange b, 1998c,

Walter et al. 2009: 1 Helleiner 1994 Strange 1971: Gilpin 1987: -65 Strange b, 1998c, 54 2012 77 92 E. Yano Shuichi 2011 11 2008 40 19821997 1998 LTCM 2001 IT 2007 1970 International Political Economy Helleiner 1994 54 2012 Walter et al. 2009: 1 Helleiner 1994 Strange 1971: Gilpin 1987:

More information

........,.,.,..,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,., International Capital Market Litan et al a b c d M&A a a b E- e- Litan et al. : Table Levine World Bank Levine Greenwald et al. B R F R r R R r B R r B R r B R R Stiglitz

More information

日 本 のFTA 政 策 をめぐる 国 内 政 治 : JSEPA 交 渉 プロセスの Title 分 析 Author(s) 金, ゼンマ Citation 一 橋 法 学, 7(3): 683-719 Issue 2008-11 Date Type Departmental Bulletin Paper Text Version publisher URL http://hdl.handle.net/10086/16369

More information

デフレ不況下の金融政策をめぐる政治過程

デフレ不況下の金融政策をめぐる政治過程 1991 2003 GDP....................................... http://www.stat.go.jp/ http://www.boj.or.jp/ GDP http://www.esri.cao.go.jp/ GDP - - - inflation targeting Krugman a IS-LM liquidity trap Krugman b Krugman

More information

untitled

untitled Trade and Trade Finance in the 200809 Financial Crisis, IMF Working Paper WP/11/16., Understanding the Great Trade Collapse of 200809 and the Subsequent Trade Recovery, Economic Perspectives, 2Q/2011.

More information

冷戦後の戦略環境変化とクリントン政権

冷戦後の戦略環境変化とクリントン政権 1998 11 3558 1 21 2 1 Paul D. Wolfowitz, Clinton s First Year, Foreign Affairs, Vol. 73, No. 15 (January/February, 1994). 2 91 36 3 91 G-7 G-7 4 G-7 5 (primacy) 6 1949 1950 1962 10 71 89 11 91 12 3 James

More information

1980 80 70 a b 90 a b D.Sainsbury Gendering Welfare States 1994 gendering welfare states 80 1 1 2 3 J. 4 a Gøsta Esping-Andersen Orloff, A.S., Gender and the Social Rights of Citizenship : State Policies

More information

政治参加としての自治・町内会参加者の実証分析

政治参加としての自治・町内会参加者の実証分析 JES JES input S. Verba, N. H. Nie NPO NPO NHK R. Pekanen .... %........................................ N JES Ses Socio-economic states H. E. Brady, S. Verba, K. L. Schlozman a civic skills H. E. Brady,

More information

国際流動性に関する財政的側面について

国際流動性に関する財政的側面について IMF SDR IMF 2011 6 1 2 2011 E-mail: [email protected] / /2011.10 35 1. 2007 2009 2 Goodhart [1999] 2010 11 2. 4 1970 IMF 1960 36 /2011.10 international reserve 1 D 35 1 D 35 1960 Eichengreen [2011]

More information

, FAD FAD FED FAO FAO WFP 1999 NGO ) 1. FAD FAD 1999 Lee, FAD % national coping s

, FAD FAD FED FAO FAO WFP 1999 NGO ) 1. FAD FAD 1999 Lee, FAD % national coping s 20 30 280 350 1995 Devereux, 1988: 270 282 Food Availability Decline: FAD Food Entitlement Decline: FED FAD FAD FED 2000, 2002 FAD FAD FAD FED FAD Lee, 2003 FED 1999 59 2000 2000, 2001 2002 FAD FAD FED

More information

æ 1 2 3 rentier state s rent æ æ 1 Zanoyan 2 Gambill æ 3 æ 1987 Luciani Beblawi The Rentier State 4 Luciani Beblawi Luciani 40 æ World Development Indicators 10 1 UNDP 10 / æ æ No.37 2004 19 æ Sadowski

More information

伝統的な経済学では、「消費は重要ではあるが、気にしなくてもよい」と考えられてきた

伝統的な経済学では、「消費は重要ではあるが、気にしなくてもよい」と考えられてきた 2005 1 2004 SARS 2003 IMF 2004 5.0 2004 4.1 0.9 30 2005 2004 2005 2005 2005 2004 2005 IMF 2005 4.3 2004 IMF 2004 2003 3.0 4.3 2003 2 2003 2004 IT 2005 IMF 2005 2004 3.5 IT 1995 10 2.8% 10 2 1 IT IT 2004

More information

19世紀の物価動向―コンドラチェフによる物価長波の検討を通じて―*

19世紀の物価動向―コンドラチェフによる物価長波の検討を通じて―* 19 GDP 1814 1815 1849 1846 1 2 61 2002 1 1991167 2 334 1 3 4 5 19 13 1823-1851 1884-1896 1884-1896 2 1823-1851 1884-1896 2 1 11 19 12 34 3 4 5 2 1 1789-1814-1849 1849-1873-1896 1896-1920-1940 2 6 Mitchell1998

More information

表紙_目次.PDF

表紙_目次.PDF JIL 2 1980 vol.3 15 3 1 3 15 18 IT 26 28 33 20 OECD 80 90 (1998) (2000) 2 Aghion et al. (1999) OECD 1970 1 2 70 1980 90 1.1 Kuznets U inverted U-shaped hypothesis GNP U 1 18901940 6 3 Kuznets(1955) (1963)

More information

政権交代後の自民党地方県連における選挙過程

政権交代後の自民党地方県連における選挙過程 OB Krauss and Pekkanen Reed Reed Reed Hazan and Rahat Dabney Dabney ,,,,,,,, PR YouTube CM CM CM CM CM CM PR OB OB PR CM OB OB - - CM - -. - - - -. - - - - - Dabney Dyron.. Campaign Behavior The Limit

More information

untitled

untitled [ 研究ノート ] 4% 19 19 20 1997a 20 Mitchell, 2002: 123 208 1997b; 2008 2 1960 1980 Abdel-Fadil, 1975; Hansen, 1969; Radwan & Lee, 1986 Abdel-Fadil, 1980; 85 Assaad, 1997 2 Hopkins Hopkins & Westergaard, 1998:

More information

関 志雄  81‐106

関 志雄  81‐106 V GDP CPI QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ CEIC GDP QQ QQ QQQ QQQ QQ QQQ QQQ QQ QQQ QQ V CEIC 2014 CEIC GDP GDP GDP GDP 2014 S&P S&P QFII QDII (Gill and Kharas, 2007, World Bank, 2012) (Lewis, 1954) (World

More information

商学 63‐3☆/6.山本

商学 63‐3☆/6.山本 193 W. A. 1 2 3 1 2 WTO FTA TPP D. P. P. W. A. 194 2 3 Lewis 1954 1982, 1987 1999 1 1 2 2 2 1 2 A B 1987 119 1985 Krugman and Obstfeld 2009 19742006 3 W. A. 195 2 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 A a1 a2 * * i ai i 1, 2

More information

農村生活改善大扉2002.5.1.PDF

農村生活改善大扉2002.5.1.PDF + 1 14 23 29 A36 71 78 82 109 136 146 158 159 + * 1945 20 20 20 20 1 *2 *1 *2 GARIOA EROA p.26 1945 1945 46 *3 10 *3 2 1945 1947 p.17 1947.11.5 *4 1949 *4 1946 1947 1948 3 *5 *5 p.187 4 1949 *6 GHQ 1948

More information

1970). Baumol, W. J., Panzar, J. C. and R. D. Willig (1982); Contestable Markets and The Theory of Industry Structure, 1982. Caves, R. and M. E. Porter (1977); From entry barriers to mobility barriers:

More information

46 RIM 2007 Vol.7 No HSBC WTO 2006

46 RIM 2007 Vol.7 No HSBC WTO 2006 19782006 200716.7 2006 2007 RIM 2007 Vol.7 No.27 45 46 RIM 2007 Vol.7 No.27 2003 HSBC 1978 2006 2007 WTO 2006 RIM 2007 Vol.7 No.27 47 2003 10 92 95 98 99 4,000 20032006 2003 225 AMC 150 joint -stock companies

More information

本組よこ/本組よこ_古川_P289-310

本組よこ/本組よこ_古川_P289-310 289 THEODORE McNELLY, Witness to the TWENTIETH CENTURY The Life Story of a Japan Specialist THEODORE McNELLY, Witness to the TWENTIETH CENTURY The Life Story of a Japan Specialist Xlibris Corporation Contemporary

More information

GDPギャップと潜在成長率

GDPギャップと潜在成長率 2003 output gap 80 1 20 90 20 70 2 1 2 output gap potential output 1 2 (2001) 3 potential rate of growth 2000 Meyer (2000) European Central Bank: (1999b) 2002 10 4 3 (2000) 4 4 () 5 5 5 6 () () 7 Total

More information

長岡慎介  45‐78/45‐78

長岡慎介  45‐78/45‐78 HSBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/business/5074068.stm HSBC HSBC Amanah Saadiq [CIBAFI 2005: 10; CIBAFI, 2009: 4; TheCityUK, 2013: 4; IFSB, 2013: 10; IFSB, 2014: 12] [TheCityUK 2013: 1] [UK Trade & Investment

More information

% 80 70 60 50 1 40 30 20 10 0 2011 03 11 06 11 08 12 01 12 04 12 08 12 12 13 03 13 06 13 08 13 10 14 02 14 06 14 09 14 12 15 03 15 06 15 08 3 Datafolh

% 80 70 60 50 1 40 30 20 10 0 2011 03 11 06 11 08 12 01 12 04 12 08 12 12 13 03 13 06 13 08 13 10 14 02 14 06 14 09 14 12 15 03 15 06 15 08 3 Datafolh Horisaka Kotaro 10 2014 W 2016 2 2000 BRICS 1 1 21 1964 85 30 6 2 1 1 1 3000 2014 10 2014 12 42% 3 3 13% 8 8% No. 645 2015 10 5 % 80 70 60 50 1 40 30 20 10 0 2011 03 11 06 11 08 12 01 12 04 12 08 12 12

More information

CSIS 4 the Asia-Pacific, or the Indo-Pacific region Asia s Democratic Security Diamond 7 11 sea-faring democracies Lake Beijing

CSIS 4 the Asia-Pacific, or the Indo-Pacific region Asia s Democratic Security Diamond 7 11 sea-faring democracies Lake Beijing 1 nifty 2010 2012 3 4 2011 6 20 9 24 1 2 2. 2013 1 3 5 3 2-25- 1 2 23 CSIS 4 the Asia-Pacific, or the Indo-Pacific region 5 2 28 6 12 27 Asia s Democratic Security Diamond 7 11 sea-faring democracies Lake

More information

Attendance Demand for J-League õ Shinsuke KAWAI* and Takeo HIRATA* Abstract The purpose of this study was to clarify the variables determining the attendance in J-league matches, using the 2,699 J-league

More information

18 2 2016 2 5 6 Robert S. Ross 7 Charles L. Glaser 8 Susan Shirk 9 10 5 David Shambaugh, China Engages Asia: Reshaping the Regional Order Internationa

18 2 2016 2 5 6 Robert S. Ross 7 Charles L. Glaser 8 Susan Shirk 9 10 5 David Shambaugh, China Engages Asia: Reshaping the Regional Order Internationa revisionist power status quo power 1 Aaron Friedberg 2 John J. Mearsheimer 3 4 David Shambaugh 2005 1 Alastair Iain Johnston, Is China a Status Quo Power? International Security, vol. 27, no. 4, (Spring

More information

Making Democracy Work Making Democracy Work 2 21 22 142

Making Democracy Work Making Democracy Work 2 21 22 142 Making Democracy Work 1 Making Democracy Work et al 141 Making Democracy Work Making Democracy Work 2 21 22 142 et al 23 143 3 31 144 32 145 4 146 147 148 B p B p B p B p B p N R Bp 149 5 Bowling Together

More information

An Empirical Study of the Securities Firms' Dilemma on Financial Innovation through Diffusion of Internet Deals Yasugi Satoshi Bower, J. L., 1999, Disruptive technologies: Catching the wave,

More information

Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization Quarterly Journal of Economics Review of Economics and Statistics Internal Labor Markets and Manpower Analysis Economics of Education Review Journal of Political

More information

@081807ヨコ/石山玲子 209号

@081807ヨコ/石山玲子 209号 e.g., Iyenger,; Cappella & Jamieson, e.g., Neuman et al., ; Iyenger, e.g., Gitlin, Neuman Iyengar episodic frame thematic frame Iyengar Gitlin G χ n χp p p e.g., McCombs & Show McCombs, Einsiedel

More information

201/扉

201/扉 Mohammad Reza SARKAR ARANI Associate Professor, Allameh Tabatabai University Visiting Research Scholar, International Research Center for Japanese Studies 200718 Mohammad Reza SARKAR ARANI Visiting Research

More information

公務員倫理問題への新アプローチ

公務員倫理問題への新アプローチ OECD CPI CPI CPI CPI CPI CPI / GDP / / / /.............................. Transparency International Corruption Perception Index CPI CPI 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

More information

アジアの資本移動の変化に関するクラスター分析 アジア域内の証券投資活性化に向けて

アジアの資本移動の変化に関するクラスター分析 アジア域内の証券投資活性化に向けて * ** 199 1 1996-97 relation * ** Seoul conference China and Emerging Asia: Reorganizing the Global Economy? held by KIEP and Seoul National University 26 5 11-12 Hugh Patrick Yung-Chul Park 26 9 9-1 East

More information

情報化社会に関する全国調査中間報告書

情報化社会に関する全国調査中間報告書 12 1 1.1 1990 1995: 171 2 Blauner 1964=1971 2 3 United States Department of Labor 1965 1976 Kohn and Schooler 1983 1-2 JIS2001 JIS2002 Kohn and Schooler 1983 126 Kohn and Schooler 1983 3 United States

More information

02古郡氏李氏_a_4.indd

02古郡氏李氏_a_4.indd 55 2014 e.g2004 2005 2001 1980 101990 1 2 2002 2003 25,000 20038,000 2013 10 2013 1,787 21.623 4,302 1 HUD portal.hud. gov/.../huddoc?id=pih2013 15.pdf... 2 14 105 30,000 25,000 25,296 20,000 15,000 10,000

More information

地方政府に対するNPO のアドボカシーと協働

地方政府に対するNPO のアドボカシーと協働 NPO NPO NPO NPO Mar. NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO, NPO NPO NPO NPO Young supplements NPO NPO complements NPO NPO NPO NPO adversaries NPO Mar. NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO NPO advocacy Jenkins a grassroots

More information

- March IMF IMF IMF ITO The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade

- March IMF IMF IMF ITO The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade M&A IMF IMF gold tranche - March IMF IMF IMF ITO The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade IMF IMF IMF GATT OECD OECD BITs. - March. U I = I (r m, i, Z * r m i Z * (= Z / Z) I / r m > I / i < I / Z *

More information

関西福祉大学紀要 12号(P)/1.太田

関西福祉大学紀要 12号(P)/1.太田 Social Work Practice and Methods for Scientific Progress Yoshihiro Ohta Abstract : Although theories and methods of social work have been progressing new ideas and ways that support social work practice

More information

IMES DISCUSSION PAPER SERIES INSTITUTE FOR MONETARY AND ECONOMIC STUDIES BANK OF JAPAN 100-8660 30 IMES Discussion Paper Series 99-J-45 199912 12 1986 General Agreement of Trade in Service Multilateral

More information

bottleneckjapanese.dvi

bottleneckjapanese.dvi 1 M&A Keywords:,. Address: 742-1, Higashinakano, Hachioji-shi, Tokyo 192-09,Japan fax:+81 426 74 425 E-mail: [email protected] ; [email protected] 1 Yang and Kawashima(2008) 1 2 ( MVI

More information

中国の貧困削減と制度的障害

中国の貧困削減と制度的障害 1 1978 1978 2000 2.5 3000 30.7% 3% 2003p.4 1980 1990 1 1994 7 20 8000 1 1 2002 1655 5 2004p.142 1 2 3 4 1 5 6 2 Poverty Line 1978 1984 1 200 2003 637 1 1 1 1985 2 1 1 2100 2001 2003p.56 60% Engel s coefficient

More information

JICA JETRO

JICA JETRO Kyoto Bulletin of Islamic Area Studies, 9 (March 2016), pp. 197 230 JICA JETRO Area Studies TISCO Tata Steel Europe UNDP FS mélange J aime tuffāh uhibbu une pomme camarade A B Ph.D. EU EU EU EU EU EU

More information

個人消費支出からみた戦間期の景気変動:LTES個人消費支出の再推計

個人消費支出からみた戦間期の景気変動:LTES個人消費支出の再推計 LTES LTES LTES 1 GNE GDP GDP 1920 LTES GDP LTES 1931 GDP 76 Hi-Stat E-mail: [email protected] / /2009.3 73 1. Long-Term Economic Statistics LTES 1 1971 LTES 2 LTES LTES System of National Accounts

More information

Dill,, pp. - - EU i - - i - - - COE - COE COE COE Good Practice GP GP GP GP JABEE INQAAHE PDCA Plan-Do-Check-Action - FD FD - - Rice,, p. niche - i - -Jones,, pp. - MCAT - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

More information

untitled

untitled 0663415031 0664476357 Fax 0664476384 0664476258 2005 7 1 2 3 1 2 1 5032264-6100 1962 1962 1965 1966 (UN/ECLAC) (Economic Affairs Officer) 1976 1979 1989 1994 1996 2000 2002 1983 1984 1986 1987 Landau,

More information

評論・社会科学 116号(P)Y☆/1.郭

評論・社会科学 116号(P)Y☆/1.郭 1990 Lewis 1992Fraser 1997 2003Sainsbury 1999 3 1 2 31990 3-1 3-2 3-3 4 4-1 4-2 5 1 1960 2015 12 2 2015 12 18 3 3 1990 2 Esping-Andersen1990 1990 Esping-Andersen1990 1 1990 3 2 Lewis 1992 Fraser 19972003

More information

e.g. Kubota 2011 Piller & Takahashi 2006 Kubota 2011 Piller & Takahashi 2006 Kubota 2011 Piller et al. 2010 2 Heller 2003 Piller, Takahashi & Watanabe

e.g. Kubota 2011 Piller & Takahashi 2006 Kubota 2011 Piller & Takahashi 2006 Kubota 2011 Piller et al. 2010 2 Heller 2003 Piller, Takahashi & Watanabe http://alce.jp/journal/ 13 2015 pp. 83-96 ISSN 2188-9600 * Copyright 2015 by Association for Language and Cultural Education 1 Norton Peirce 1995 2014 2014 2013 2014 * E-mail: [email protected] 83 e.g.

More information

Ł\1,4.ai

Ł\1,4.ai 34 2009 1 2 2.1. 2.2 3 3.1 3.2 4 1 1990-99 - NPO 1) 2 3 4 2 3 2 2.1. ( ) 3 2.1.1 (2002) 2) 1920 3) P - 100 - 4) 2.1.2 () 1995 5) 1990 6) 2000 7) 8) 9) () - 101 - () D D 10) 11) 12) - 102 - 2.2 N 13) J

More information

untitled

untitled 82 1 2016 5 3 7 7 12 14 16 15 16 4 16 17 9 14 N 16 17 16 93 93 3 172 18 1570 1576 17 7 13? 16 N 1612 N 1600 3 2 3 N 16 22 94 94 82 1 2016 5 2014 10 212 3 500 Fabian Drixler Mabiki: Infanticide and Population

More information

1973 Salvador Allende los desaparecidos D Democracy -15

1973 Salvador Allende los desaparecidos D Democracy -15 1 OAS OAS 2 OAS 3 1 2011 p.52. 2 Legler, T., Learning the hard way, in International Journal, Summer 2010, p.603. 3 Casas-Zamora, K. The Honduran crisis and the Obama administration in Lowenthal et al.

More information

Title Author(s) Kobe University Repository : Kernel 公務員の経験学習と人材育成 (Experiential Learning and Development in Public Organizations) 松尾, 睦 Citation 国民経済雑誌,204(5):31-41 Issue date 2011-11 Resource Type Resource

More information

-October TPP ASEAN RCEP TPP MV Islamic State, IS EU EU EU EU EU

-October TPP ASEAN RCEP TPP MV Islamic State, IS EU EU EU EU EU AIIB BRICS TPP ASEAN ARF -October TPP ASEAN RCEP TPP MV Islamic State, IS EU EU EU EU EU EU EU UK MDGs AIIB BRICS ADB IT -October IoT Internet of Things Wearable AI IoT. GE IIC Finance+Technolpgy STEM

More information

’V‰K2.ren

’V‰K2.ren International Journal of Intercultural Relations, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, British Journal of Social Psychology Journal of Language and Social Psychology, Asian Journal of Social Psychology,

More information