aragciv54mac.dvi

Similar documents
わが国企業による資金調達方法の選択問題

わが国企業による株主還元策の決定要因:配当・自社株消却のインセンティブを巡る実証分析

Jorgenson F, L : L: Inada lim F =, lim F L = k L lim F =, lim F L = 2 L F >, F L > 3 F <, F LL < 4 λ >, λf, L = F λ, λl 5 Y = Const a L a < α < CES? C

PFI

Auerbach and Kotlikoff(1987) (1987) (1988) 4 (2004) 5 Diamond(1965) Auerbach and Kotlikoff(1987) 1 ( ) ,

(2004 ) 2 (A) (B) (C) 3 (1987) (1988) Shimono and Tachibanaki(1985) (2008) , % 2 (1999) (2005) 3 (2005) (2006) (2008)

headquarter Gertner et al. winner-picking Wal-Mart s

repocost.PDF


株式保有構成と企業価値 ─コーポレート・ガバナンスに関する一考察─

商学 63‐3☆/6.山本

23_02.dvi

Keynes 1936 Tobin 1 Hicks 1937 Keynes IS LM 2 IS LM 3 IS LM Keynes Keynes animal spirits


Vol.8 No (July 2015) 2/ [3] stratification / *1 2 J-REIT *2 *1 *2 J-REIT % J-REIT J-REIT 6 J-REIT J-REIT 10 J-REIT *3 J-

shuron.dvi

2015 : (heterogenous) Heterogeneous homogeneous Heterogenous agent model Bewley 1 (The Overlapping-Generations Models:OLG) OLG OLG Allais (1

カルマンフィルターによるベータ推定( )

082_rev2_utf8.pdf

autocorrelataion cross-autocorrelataion Lo/MacKinlay [1988, 1990] (A)

濱田弘潤 : 多角化企業の利潤分析 77 多角化企業の利潤分析 多角化ディスカウントの寡占理論による説明 * 濱田弘潤 (diversification discount) Keywords: JEL classifications: D43, L13, L22, G

商学 60周年記念号/24.内田浩徳

わが国のレポ市場について―理論的整理と実証分析―

Winter 図 1 図 OECD OECD OECD OECD 2003

固定資産の減損会計へのリアル・オプション・アプローチ

1 Nelson-Siegel Nelson and Siegel(1987) 3 Nelson-Siegel 3 Nelson-Siegel 2 3 Nelson-Siegel 2 Nelson-Siegel Litterman and Scheinkman(199

季刊 企業と法創造 第1巻第4号(通巻第4号)

さぬきの安全2016-cs5-出力.indd

看護学科案内'16/表紙


( ) z W n u K P N P = (1 + z)wn N = nuk (1) (2) I/K u e f r l (= L/PK) (4) I K = g(u, r, e f, l ) g u > 0, g r < 0, g e f > 0,


BJ-No.7 01 三好秀和.indd

Graduate School of Policy and Management, Doshisha University 53 動学的資本税協調と公的資本形成 あらまし Zodrow and Mieszkowski 1986 Wilson 1986 Batina はじめに Zodr

日本の高齢者世帯の貯蓄行動に関する実証分析


A5 PDF.pwd

アジアの資本移動の変化に関するクラスター分析 アジア域内の証券投資活性化に向けて

野村資本市場研究所|アジアの金融競争力(PDF)

本組/根間弘海

03.Œk’ì

2 / 24

Vol. 3 No (Mar. 2010) An Option Valuation Model Based on an Asset Pricing Model Incorporating Investors Beliefs Kentaro Tanaka, 1 Koich

Ver. 1.0 (discretion) (revenue management) (fictitious revenue recognition) (window dressing) (fraudulent accounting practice) SEC (General

財政赤字の経済分析:中長期的視点からの考察

Transcription:

2013 3 25 ( 4 ) Modigliani-Miller(1963) 1 1 1 IRR ( ) NPV IRR NPV IRR NPV IRR 100 EBIT 20 20% τ (1 τ) 20% CC tax = S V ρ S + B V (1 τ)ρ B (1) S B V ρ S CAPM 1

ρ B *1 (1) MM *2 ( ) MM MM ( ) MM (1 τ) 20% (1) CC tax CC tax CC tax 1 CC tax 1 500 *1 Brealey-Myers-Allen(2011) Ross-Westerfield-Jaffe(2011) *2 Modigliani-Miller(1958) Modigliani-Miller(1963) Modigliani-Miller(1963) MM MM Arditti-evy(1977) Ben-Horim(1979) Boudreaux-ong(1979) evy-sarnat(1990) 2

CC tax 2 CC tax 2 *3 1 1 1 1 *3 Myers(1984) Myers-Majluf(1984) ( ) ShyamSunder-Myers(1999) Fama-French(2002) Frank-Goyal(2003) 3

( ) 2 Hayashi(1982) Dixit-Pindyck(1994) Bolton-Chen-Wang(2011) eland(1998) Morellec(2004) 1 Giat-Hackman-Subramanian(2010) DeMarzo-Fishman-He-Wang(2012) Hackbarth-Mauer(2012) 1 2 3 4 5 6 4

2 2.1 *4 1 2 1 1 EBIT S B S B V V senior debt EBIT EBIT µ σ Φ(µ,σ ) *5 K K= kv ( ) τ 1 V V ( B) B V + B τ[ V ( B)] V + B Q S τ( V [ B]) Q S = 0 (> ) ( V + B ) (V + B> ) Q S V + B (2) *4 Tsuji(2012) *5 N(µ,σ 2 ) 5

3 S > 0 V B( S )>0 V + B (2) 1 ( ) 2 3 Q B Q B K >K Q (>K) B = ( ) K (> K ) 0 (K> ) >K 1 2 K 3 K Q (K ) ( ) B = (4) 0 (> ) 2 S B CAPM 1 S B [ E( Q (>K) B B= [ E( Q (K ) B S = E( Q S ) λ cov( R M, Q S ) (5) 1+R F ]/ ) λ cov( R M, Q (>K) (1+R F ) (>K ) B ) ) λ cov( R M, Q (K ) B ) ]/ (1+R F ) (K ) R F R M (3) (6) λ= E( R M ) R F σ( R M ) 2 (5) (6) partial moment f ( ) Φ(µ,σ ) 6

F( ) E( Q S )=µ [1 τ+τf(v + B) F()]+σ 2 [ f () τ f (V + B)] [1 F()]+τ(V + B)[1 F(V + B)] cov( R M, Q S )=cov( R M, )[1 τ+τf(v + B) F()] E( Q (>K) B )=[1 F()] K[F() F(K)] +µ [F() F(K)] σ 2 [ f () f (K)] cov( R M, Q (>K) B )=cov( R M, )[F() F(K)+ K f ()] E( Q (K ) B )=[1 F()] cov( R M, Q (K ) B )=cov( R M, ) f () 2.2 CAPM ( ) eland(1998) Morellec(2004) CAPM ( ) µ σ cov( R M, ) Q S Q B ( ) (2) (3) ( (4) ) (5) (6) (5) (6) S B µ σ k λ R F cov( R M, ) τ µ σ 3 *6 3 *6 k cov( R M, ) 7

S = S (,µ,σ ) B= B(,µ,σ ) V = V (,µ,σ )=S (,µ,σ )+ B(,µ,σ ) µ σ µ σ µ σ µ σ µ σ µ σ *7 µ σ 2 EBIT EBIT EBIT EBIT EBIT ω EBIT ( ) ( ) µ *7 Hart(1995) 8

ω µ ω µ 1 µ =ω α α>0 (7) α 1 µ ω α *8 = arg max V (,µ,σ ) (8) ( ) σ S σ = arg max σ S (,µ,σ ) (9) (7) (8) (9) 3 µ σ µ σ µ =ω α (10) V (,µ,σ )=0 (11) S (,µ σ,σ )=0 (12) µ σ ω α 2 S B *8 Jensen-Meckling(1976) Myers(1977) EBIT Tsuji(2012) Appendix ((7) EBIT (7) 1 2 9

ω α S = S (ω,α;,µ,σ ) B= B(ω,α;,µ,σ ) V = V (ω,α;,µ,σ ) 2.3 1 10 1 10 EBIT 1 ω ( ) 10 EBIT 50 1 α 0.2 k 0.4 τ 0.45 1 E( R M )=0.11 σ( R M )=0.18 R F =0.06 corr( R M, ) 0.2 E( R M ) 11% 1 1 1 10 (1.11) 10 1 1.839 1 10 E( R M )=1.839 1 10 10 λ 3.236 1 1 µ =47.41 σ =23.66 =12.93 (10) (11) (12) 3 S B V DR B/V ROA R ROA = ω V V (13) ω (50.0) 1 10 10 (10 ) ROA R ROA 1 *9 11.44% *9 ROA (13) R ROA (1+R ROA ) 10 1 1 10

1 ω α k τ E( R M ) σ( R M ) R F λ corr( R M, ) 50.0 0.2 0.4 0.45 0.11 0.18 0.06 3.236 0.2 µ σ S B V DR ROA 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 ( )E( R M ) σ( R M ) R F 1 1 λ 1 10 ω µ σ 1 10 DR B/V ROA ( ) (13) R ROA 1 2 ω ω µ σ S B V DR ROA 40.0 37.93 18.92 10.35 8.41 5.13 13.54 0.379 0.1144 45.0 42.67 21.28 11.64 9.46 5.78 15.23 0.379 0.1144 50.0 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 55.0 52.15 26.02 14.23 11.56 7.06 18.62 0.379 0.1144 60.0 56.90 28.38 15.52 12.61 7.70 20.31 0.379 0.1144 ( )ω 1 1 1 2 ω ω 50 60 1.2 µ σ S B V 1.2 DB ROA 1 (10) ω µ 2 1 1 3 3.1 11

1 *10 I I I B I S I= I S + I B I I I S I B (0) α (0) µ (0) σ (0) V ( ω (0) ( S ω (0) σ µ (0) =,α ; (0),µ (0) α (0) (10),α ; (0),µ (0),σ (0),σ (0) ) = 0 (11) ) = 0 (12) Φ ( ) µ (0),σ (0) (0) S (0) B(0) S (0) = S ( ω (0),α ; (0),µ (0) B (0) = B (,α ; (0),µ (0),σ (0),σ (0) ) ) *10 1 1 10 1 1 10 1 12

Φ ( ) µ (1), (1) S (1) B(1) (1) µ (1) (1) σ S ( ) = arg max S (1),µ (1) σ,σ (10) (14) µ (1) µ (1) = α (1) (15) α α (1) *11 B(1) S (1) S (1) = S ( ω (1),α ; (1),µ (1) B (1) = B (,α ; (1),µ (1),, I I B ) (1 (0) B (1) = I B (16) (1) I B (1) ( ) (1) B (1) 1 (0) ( ) (1) (0) I (1) B 1 (0) B (1) (1) I B I B (0) B (1) B (0) (1) ) ) *11 (15) α α α ( ) 13

I S 1 S P(0) 1 P (1) n (0) S S (0) = n(0) S S S n(1) S S I S /P (1) S S (1) S (1) = n(1) S P(1) S = n(0) S + I S P(1) S P (1) S P (1) P (0) = S (0) + I S+ n (0) S (P(1) S P (0) S ) (17) I S S (1) ( 3 ) P (1) S (17) P (1) S P (0) S S (1) S (0) + I S P (1) S = P (0) S ( ) S (1) = S (0) + I S ( = arg max S ω (1) σ,α ; ) (1),µ (1),σ (14) (1 (0) (1) ( S ω (1),α ; (1),µ (1) µ (1) = ) B (,α ; (1),µ (1), S (0) P (0) S α (1) (15) ) S ( ω (0),,α ; (0),µ (0) ) = IB (16) ),σ (0) = IS (18) (14) σ (15) (16) (18) (16) (18) 4 (0) I S I B µ (1) µ (1) 4 (1) (14) (15) 14

(16) (18) 2 (1) µ (1) (1) R q ω(1) ω(0) I I (1 ) (I B I S ) I I B I S R q I B R q R q R q (I B ) R q (19) min R q 0 I B I I S = I I B (20) I B I B R q 3.2 1 ROA (19) R q 1 (13) R ROA 2 1 S (1) S (0) = I S I S = S (0) I B B (1) S (0)= B (1) 15

I B (1) B (0) = I B (16) (0) (1) B(1) = B (0) (21) (21) 1 I B B (0) (21) B (0) 1 ω c c = cω(0) = cσ (0) = ω(1) σ (0) (22) 2 I( ) B (0) /V (0) I B /I I B I S I B I S B (,α ; (1),µ (1) ( S ω (1),α ; (1),µ (1) = ω(1) σ (0) (22) µ (1) = α (1) (15) ) (, B ω (0),α ; ) (0),µ (0),σ (0) = IB (23), ) S ( ω (0),α ; (0),µ (0),σ (0) ) = IS (18) (18) (15) (23) (22) (23) 16

3 µ (0) σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR ROA 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 µ (1) (1) S (1) B (1) V (1) I B I B /I RRI 55.91 53.02 26.45 14.46 11.75 7.18 18.93 0.758 0.379 0.1144 ( )ω µ σ 1 10 (0) (1) DR B/V ROA ( ) (13) R ROA 1 RRI ( ) (19) R q 1 (22) 4 µ (1) (1) 4 ω(0) (19) I= 2 3 I= 2 0.379 I B 0.758 1.242 I S B (0) ) 10.51 6.42 B(1) ) 11.75 7.18 (S (1) (S (0) I S I B (1) =14.46 µ (1) =53.02 55.91 I=2 =50 ω(1) =55.91 R q 1 11.44% ( 3 RRI ) RRI R q 1 RRI ROA B (0) /V (0) I I B I S 1 I=2 I B 0 2 ( I S = I I B ) ((22) (15) (23) (18) 4 ) R q R q R q R q R q 1 R q I B I S B (0) S (0) 17

0.1151 RRI 0.115 0.1149 0.1148 0.1147 0.1146 0.1145 0.1144 0.1143 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 I B 1 (I B ) ( ) I B I S R q ( ) (I B ) R q I B I I B 1 I I B R q I B 1 I I B R q I B 3.3 R q R q I B I S R q (20) 4 I B = 2 I= 2 R q 18

0.119 RRI 0.118 0.117 0.116 0.115 0.114 0.113 0.112 0.111 0.11 0.109 0.108 0.107 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 I B 2 (I B ) ( ) 4 ( ) µ (0) σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR ROA 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 µ (1) (1) S (1) B (1) V (1) I B RRI 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 10.51 8.28 18.79 2.0 0.1075 ( ) 3 I B 0 2 R q 2 I B R q 6.42 2 6.28 ( B (1) 8.28 I B 2 ) 1 S (0) σ (1) S (1) σ (1) σ (0) = 0 [σ,σ ] S (1) 19

σ σ = ω(1) σ σ (0) 1.3 σ (0) ω σ σ 30% 4 σ σ 4 1 R ROA R q R q R ROA σ (0) 20

4 I α k τ λ corr( R M, ) 1 1 5 11 1 I B /I 1.0 ( ) B (0) OldB OldB OldB B (0) DR (0) DR (1) 1 [σ,σ ] σ ω(0) σ (0) RRI ROA 5 ( (0) ) 2 DR(0) ROA RRI 6 50 I RRI 5 7 α α DR (0) α=0.16 α=0.24 50% 20% 7 α RRI 8 9 k ( 8) τ ( 9) 21

k τ DR (0) k τ RRI k RRI 8 9 τ RRI 10 11 10 λ 11 corr( R M, ) λ corr( R M, λ corr( R M, ) RRI λ corr( R M, ) 1 (1) RRI 5 11 CC tax RRI tax *12 10% 15% 5 CC tax RRI tax CC tax 2 α (0) µ (0) σ (0) α 1 ( ) α (0) µ (0) σ (0) *12 RRI tax = (1 τ)rri 10 1 CC tax RRI tax 22

µ (0) µ (1) 5 σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 40.00 37.93 18.92 10.35 8.41 5.13 13.54 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 45.56 42.67 21.56 14.48 7.00 0.454 5.00 1.000 0.1077 0.0592 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 60.00 56.90 28.38 15.52 12.61 7.70 20.31 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 65.54 61.62 31.00 19.62 9.57 0.431 7.57 1.000 0.1073 0.0590 ( ) DR (0) DR (1) B (0) /V (0) B(1) /V (1) ROA (13) R ROA RRI (19) R q 1 CC tax (1) OldB B (1) I B I B /I 1.0 RRI tax (1 τ)rri α=0.2 k=0.4 τ=0.45 I=2.0 λ=3.24 corr( R M, )=0.2 I 1.0 2.0 5.0 µ (0) µ (1) 6 I σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 52.76 49.77 24.96 14.97 7.35 0.412 6.35 1.000 0.1070 0.0589 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 64.04 59.33 30.30 23.52 11.11 0.514 6.11 1.000 0.1087 0.0598 ( ) α=0.2 k=0.4 τ=0.45 λ=3.24 corr( R M, )=0.2 5 α 0.16 0.20 0.24 µ (0) µ (1) 7 α σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 50.00 47.00 20.89 18.73 8.49 9.27 17.76 0.522 0.1091 0.0599 55.20 51.54 23.07 22.84 11.11 0.567 9.11 1.000 0.1002 0.0551 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 50.00 48.41 24.84 6.62 13.16 3.39 16.55 0.205 0.1169 0.0717 55.83 53.29 27.74 10.62 5.31 0.288 3.31 1.000 0.1130 0.0622 ( ) k=0.4 τ=0.45 I=2 λ=3.24 corr( R M, )=0.2 5 23

k 0.2 0.4 0.5 µ (0) µ (1) 8 k σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 50.00 45.78 19.18 21.12 7.33 10.68 18.01 0.593 0.1075 0.0565 55.15 50.12 21.15 25.13 12.53 0.631 10.53 1.000 0.0992 0.0546 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 50.00 48.02 25.69 9.89 11.67 4.88 16.55 0.295 0.1169 0.0698 55.70 52.89 28.62 14.06 6.75 0.367 4.75 1.000 0.1105 0.0608 ( ) α=0.2 τ=0.45 I=2 λ=3.24 corr( R M, )=0.2 5 τ 0.40 0.45 0.50 µ (0) µ (1) 9 τ σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 50.00 48.79 23.84 6.03 14.45 3.15 17.59 0.179 0.1101 0.0726 55.55 53.56 26.48 9.95 5.08 0.260 3.08 1.000 0.1074 0.0644 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 50.00 46.04 19.63 19.81 7.35 9.84 17.20 0.572 0.1126 0.0553 55.34 50.56 21.73 23.91 11.67 0.613 9.67 1.000 0.1032 0.0516 ( ) α=0.2 k=0.4 I=2 λ=3.24 corr( R M, )=0.2 5 λ 1.62 3.24 4.85 1.62 µ (0) µ (1) 10 λ σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 50.00 47.29 26.82 13.53 11.81 6.60 18.41 0.358 0.1051 0.0592 55.01 51.39 38.37 18.13 7.88 0.400 5.88 1.000 0.0963 0.0529 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 50.00 47.38 21.14 13.12 9.20 6.61 15.81 0.418 0.1221 0.0707 55.96 52.52 23.66 17.16 8.48 0.480 6.48 1.000 0.1153 0.0634 50.00 46.34 41.61 18.28 15.15 8.39 23.55 0.356 0.0782 0.0393 ( ) α=0.2 k=0.4 τ=0.45 I=2 corr( R M, )=0.2 5 24

corr( R M, ) 0.2 0.4 0.8 0.1 µ (0) µ (1) 11 corr( R M, ) σ (0) (0) S (0) B (0) V (0) DR (0) ROA CC tax (1) B (1) DR (1) OldB I B /I RRI RRI tax 50.00 47.41 23.66 12.93 10.51 6.42 16.93 0.379 0.1144 0.0659 55.55 52.14 26.28 17.05 8.29 0.441 6.29 1.000 0.1075 0.0591 50.00 47.22 18.95 13.90 7.89 7.11 15.00 0.474 0.1279 0.0735 56.29 52.72 21.34 17.87 8.99 0.533 6.99 1.000 0.1214 0.0668 50.00 45.87 11.36 20.67 3.47 11.18 14.65 0.763 0.1306 0.0644 56.60 51.72 12.86 24.39 13.11 0.791 11.11 1.000 0.1268 0.0697 50.00 46.34 41.61 18.28 15.15 8.39 23.55 0.356 0.0782 0.0393 ( ) α=0.2 k=0.4 τ=0.45 I=2 λ=3.24 5 I 15% 1 2 1 1974 1983 10 [1](period[1]) 1 1984 1993 10 [2](period[2]) 10 1 S (0) B(0) E( R M ) σ( R M ) R F λ 1 10 corr( R M, ) k τ k=0.3 τ 0.45 12 [1] 515 [2] 592 α 471 578 ( ) 3.1 [1] 442 [2] 576 ( =σ ) [1] 284 [2] 572 σ [2] [1] 3 [1] 3 [2] σ [1] 253 [2] 455 25

12 period[1] period[2] 1 (A) 515 592 (B) 471 578 (B)/(A) 91.5% 97.6% (C) 442 576 (C)/(B) 93.8% 99.7% 158 4 284 572 253 455 31 117 ( ) period[1] 1974 1983 10 ( [1]) period[2] 1984 1993 10 ( [2]) α σ (0) (0) µ (0) 3.1 [1] 1 31 [2] 2 117 σ σ σ σ 13 RRI tax CC tax *13 CC tax RRI tax (s.d.) CC tax RRI tax 2 CC tax RRI tax di f f di f f CC tax RRI tax di f f [1] [2] [1] 0.78% [2] 18.54% [1] di f f 130 [2] di f f 6 CC tax RRI tax [1] [2] CC tax 13 RRI tax CC tax 3 t-test *13 4 CC tax 5 CC tax CC tax 26

13 CC tax RRI tax CC tax RRI tax di f f period[1] period[2] period[1] period[2] period[1] period[2] mean 0.0832 0.0763 0.0822 0.0648 0.0078 0.1774 s.d. 0.0151 0.0091 0.0085 0.0046 0.1140 0.0982 min 0.0549 0.0557 0.0615 0.0550 0.1988 0.1049 max 0.1236 0.1092 0.1069 0.0791 0.3625 0.5874 difference: test statistics correlation firms di f f > 0 t-test di f f - Wilcoxon Pearson Spearman Kendall period[1] 284 130 1.832 1.155 0.856 0.816 0.809 0.624 period[2] 572 566 41.71 43.22 20.68 0.727 0.732 0.541 ( ) RRI tax CC tax di f f di f f = (CC tax RRI tax )/RRI tax t-test RRI tax CC tax t diff- f f = 0 Wilcoxon Pearson Spearman Kendall 5% 1% t- di f f - di f f - 3 Wilcoxon [1] RRI tax CC tax [2] 1% RRI tax CC tax 13 3 (Pearson) [1] 0.816 [2] 0.727 Spearman Kendall 3 [2] [1] 3 2 1% 14 [1] [2] RRI tax CC tax RRI tax 13 2 278 [1] [2] RRI tax CC tax 183 65% RRI tax CC tax 27

14 CC tax RRI tax total 278 same movement 183 (percentage) (65.8%) ( ) total RRI tax [1] [2] RRI tax same movement CC tax ( ) 1% 18% CC tax RRI tax 6 MM 1 1 1 28

1 (7) (15) α [1] Arditti, F. D., and H. evy. 1977. The Weighted Average Cost of Capital as a Cutoff rate: A Critical Analysis of the Classical Textbook Weighted Average. Financial Management 6: 24-34. [2] Ben-Horim, M. 1979. Comment on The Weighted Average Cost of Capital as a Cutoff Rate. Financial Management 8: 18-21. [3] Bolton, Patrick, Hui Chen, and Neng Wang. 2011. A Unified Theory of Tobin s Q, Corporate Investment, Financing, and Risk Management. Journal of Finance, Vol.66, No.5 (October, 2011), pp.1545-1578. [4] Boudreaux, K. J., and H. W. ong. 1979. The Weighted Average Cost of Capital as a Cutoff Rate: A Further Analysis. Financial Management 8: 7-14. [5] Brealey, R. A., S. C. Myers, and F. Allen. 2011. Principles of Corporate Finance(tenth edition). McGraw-Hill/Irwin. [6] DeMarzo, Peter M., Michael J. Fishman, higuo He, and Neng Wang, 2012. Dynamic Agency and the q Theory of Investment, Journal of Finance Vol.67, No.6 (December, 2012), pp.2295-2340. [7] Dixit, A. K., and R. S. Pindyck. 1994. Investment under Uncertainty. Princeton University Press. [8] Fama, Eugene F., and Kenneth R. French, 2002. Testing Trade-Off and Pecking Order Predictions about Dividends and Debt, Review of Financial Studies, Vol.15, No.1 (Spring, 2002), pp. 1-33. [9] Frank, M.., and V. K. Goyal, 2003. Testing the Pecking Order Theory of Capital Structure, Journal of Financial Economics Vol.67, No.2 (February, 2003), pp.217-248. [10] Giat, Yahel, Steve T. Hackman, and Ajay Subramanian, 2010. Investment under Uncertainty, Heterogeneous Beliefs, and Agency Conflicts, Review of Financial Studies Vol.23, No.4 (April, 2010), pp.1360-1404. [11] Hart, O. 1995. Firms, Contracts, and Financial Structure. Oxford University Press. [12] Hackbarth, Dirk, and David C. Mauer, 2012. Optimal Priority Structure, Capital Structure, and 29

Investment, Review of Financial Studies, Vol.25, No.3 (March, 2012), pp.747-796. [13] Hayashi, Fumio. 1982. Tobin s Marginal q and Average q: A Neoclassical Interpretation, Econometrica, Vol.50, No.1 (January, 1982), pp.213-224. [14] Jensen, M. C., and W. H. Meckling. 1976. Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs, and Ownership Structure. Journal of Financial Economics 3: 305-360. [15] eland, H. E. 1998. Agency Costs, Risk Management, and Capital Structure. Journal of Finance 53: 1213-1243. [16] evy H., and M. Sarnat. 1990. Capital Investment and Financial Decisions(fourth edition). Prentice Hall. [17] Morellec, E. 2004. Can Managerial Discretion Explain Observed everage Ratios? Review of Financial Studies 17: 257-294. [18] Modigliani, F., and M. H. Miller. 1958. The Cost of Capital, Corporation Finance and the Theory of Investment. American Economic Review 48: 261-297. [19] Modigliani, F., and M. H. Miller. 1963. Corporate Income Taxes and the Cost of Capital: A Correction. American Economic Review 53: 433-443. [20] Myers, S. C. 1977. Determinants of Corporate Borrowing. Journal of Financial Economics 5: 147-176. [21] Myers, S. C. 1984. The Capital Structure Puzzle. Journal of Finance 39: 575-592. [22] Myers, S. C., and N. S. Majluf. 1984. Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions When Firms Have Information that Investors Do Not Have. Journal of Financial Economics 13: 187-221. [23] Ross, S. A., R. W. Westerfield, and J. Jaffe. 2011. Corporate Finance(ninth edition). McGraw- Hill/Irwin. [24] Shyam-Sunder, akshmi, and Stewart C. Myers. 1999. Testing Static Tradeoff against Pecking Order Models of Capital Structure, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol.51, No.2 (February, 1999), pp.219-244. [25] Tsuji, Y. 2012. Measuring the Agency Costs of Debt: A Simplified Approach. Journal of Business, Economics and Finance 1: 70-96. 30